Sexing the Body: Science, Intersex, and Gender Politics
This paper engages with Anne Fausto-Sterling's Sexing the Body to examine the medical, scientific, and social stakes of classifying human bodies as strictly male or female. Drawing on Fausto-Sterling's critique of intersex surgeries, Ian Hacking's concept of "making up people," and recent neurological and behavioral research on sex differences, the paper argues that mainstream medicine's enforcement of binary sex norms imposes harmful consequences on intersexual individuals. It also considers how acknowledging intersexed bodies challenges long-held scientific assumptions and expands our understanding of nature, gender, and biological diversity.
- Introduction: What Is at Stake in Sex Classification: Medical sex assignment and intersex surgery harms
- Scientific Research on Sex Differences: Brain structure and navigational sex difference studies
- Hacking's Concept Applied to Sexed Bodies: How medicine categorizes and constructs gendered patients
- The Role of Scientific and Medical Expertise in Intersex Births: Hormone research failures and endocrinology history
- Acknowledging Intersexed Bodies: Destabilizing and Expanding Ideas of Nature: Intersex recognition challenges scientific and social norms
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper integrates multiple scholarly frameworks — Fausto-Sterling's feminist biology critique, Hacking's philosophical concept of "making up people," and empirical neuroscience research — to build a multidisciplinary argument.
- It grounds abstract theoretical claims in concrete examples, such as the surgical "correction" of intersex newborns and specific findings about amygdala and hippocampus size differences, giving the argument both conceptual and empirical weight.
- The paper moves logically from personal stakes (intersex individuals' lives) to scientific evidence, then to philosophical critique, and finally to broader epistemological implications, creating a coherent argumentative arc.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective critical synthesis: it presents empirical research on sex differences without accepting it uncritically, using Fausto-Sterling and Hacking to interrogate the social and institutional frameworks that shape how such research is interpreted and applied. This positions science itself as a cultural practice subject to scrutiny.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by establishing human stakes through the example of intersex surgery, then surveys recent studies on navigational ability and brain structure to represent the mainstream scientific view. It pivots to Hacking's theoretical lens on medical categorization, then examines Fausto-Sterling's history of endocrinology and hormone research. It closes with a reflective section on how recognizing intersex bodies both unsettles and enriches our understanding of nature. Approximately five sections of moderate length, each building on the last.
Introduction: What Is at Stake in Sex Classification
What is immediately at stake is the entire life of an intersexual person — meddled into and muddled by mainstream medicine's gender biases (Fausto-Sterling, 2000, pp. 8, 16). Not only modern America but also the world at large demands that a person be either male or female, in unquestioning obedience to, or "sublime" conformity with, medical norms. A mainstream physician who comes across the male sex organ of a newly born hermaphrodite and finds that it measures less than 3 cm, for instance, decides that it should be "repaired" to conform to genital standards. He shortens the small phallus to make it resemble a clitoris through surgical procedures and ultimately declares the newborn to be a girl. A hermaphrodite — also called an intersexual — is a person who possesses both male and female external genitalia (Fausto-Sterling, 2000).
Opposition to the continuing scientific research and medical position on genital difference between males and females comes mainly from intersexual adults who were subjected to these surgeries as children and therefore could not oppose the decision (Fausto-Sterling, 2000, pp. 30, 123). Their overall welfare is at stake in that decision, and they doubt that the physicians who perform the surgeries genuinely consider it. These advocates call this assault on their right to remain intersexual "sex policing." Physicians, on the other hand, uphold society's insistence that children be declared and formed as either boys or girls, and schools are severely penalized for deviating from these determined categories (Fausto-Sterling, 2000).
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.