Symbolism in Shirley Jackson's "The Lottery": Setting and Character
This essay analyzes Shirley Jackson's short story "The Lottery" (1948), focusing on how setting and character function as vehicles for her critique of American society. The essay examines how Jackson uses an idealized rural village to expose the violence and inhumanity lurking beneath post-war American optimism. It explores specific characters—including Old Man Warner, Mr. Delacroix, Mr. Summers, and Davy Hutchinson—as symbolic representations of tradition, religion, civic normalization of brutality, and the cycle of violence. The essay also considers the story as a possible commentary on racial scapegoating and the persistence of superstition-based cruelty in society.
- Introduction: Setting the Stage for Violence: Story overview, premise, and central theme
- The Rural Setting as a Critique of American Society: Idyllic village setting subverted to expose societal darkness
- Tradition, Superstition, and the Scapegoat: Racial scapegoating and superstition as sources of brutality
- Character Symbolism and the Critique of Religion: Old Man Warner and Delacroix as symbolic figures
- Names, Normalization, and the Cycle of Brutality: Names, civic duty, and children drawn into ritual violence
- Conclusion: The Village as America: Village as metaphor for American society's hidden violence
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Grounds its literary analysis in historical context, connecting the story's 1948 publication to post-war American optimism and rural cultural norms.
- Moves systematically through symbolic elements—setting, named characters, collective names—building a coherent thematic argument about ingrained societal violence.
- Draws on specific textual evidence (direct quotations from the story) to support each interpretive claim rather than relying on assertion alone.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates close reading combined with contextual analysis. The author links individual textual details—such as the French etymology of "Delacroix" or the act of handing Davy Hutchinson stones—to broader thematic arguments about religion, racial scapegoating, and the normalization of violence. This dual-lens approach (text + context) is a core skill in literary analysis essays.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens by introducing the story's premise and central theme, then devotes two paragraphs to analyzing the rural setting as social critique. It shifts to thematic claims about superstition and race before turning character by character through Old Man Warner, Delacroix, Mr. Summers, Davy Hutchinson, and the unnamed villagers. The conclusion synthesizes these threads, positioning the village as a metaphor for America as a whole.
Introduction: Setting the Stage for Violence
Shirley Jackson's "The Lottery" is a richly symbolic work in which setting and character are critical to understanding Jackson's message. The theme of the work centers on the inhumanity and violence that underlies human society. Jackson sets the story in a small village, and the different characters reflect the broader community of mankind. In the story, the village holds an annual lottery, and this event forms the story's central setting. It becomes apparent early on that the lottery is something sinister, and by the end, the "loser"—Tessie Hutchinson—is stoned to death by her neighbors.
The Rural Setting as a Critique of American Society
The setting is critical to the story for several reasons. The story was written in 1948, a time when America was returning to normality after the war and when a significant portion of Americans still lived in rural communities. These communities represented a vision of bucolic, traditional America. Jackson's chosen setting is intended to encapsulate the idyllic vision of American society that many people held, especially in the post-war period. She then turns this setting on its head by illustrating a horrific tradition playing out within it. The setting's imperfection—because the lottery is an entrenched tradition—is designed to shock readers who would have been accustomed to viewing this type of community in a positive light.
Jackson uses the setting to reflect the ugliness of American society back onto the audience. The village's lottery tradition is ancient; other villages have already abandoned it, having progressed beyond such brutal customs—yet this village looks down on those that have moved on. The community's desire to cling to tradition is also rooted in superstition: "Lottery in June, corn be heavy soon." Jackson suggests that the brutality of humanity is often fed by superstition. Whether the story constitutes a direct critique of organized religion is debatable, but in a contemporary reading it carries that weight. Jackson's story generated enormous controversy upon its 1948 publication in The New Yorker, in part because readers recognized their own communities in the village she depicted.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.