Ted Hughes's Crow and Hawk: Bird Spirit Poetry and the Soul
This essay examines Ted Hughes's bird poetry, focusing on the figures of Crow and Hawk as symbolic representations of the human psyche. Drawing on Jungian psychology, Schopenhauer's philosophy of the will, and cross-cultural trickster mythology, the paper argues that Crow functions as a post-apocalyptic shadow self embodying humanity's denied instincts, while Hawk represents a cold, fascistic exercise of dominion and will. Together, these figures offer a framework for understanding how Hughes subverts modern symbolic conventions and proposes an animistic path toward metaphysical salvation — one rooted in embracing rather than repressing the raw, noncivilized dimensions of human nature.
- Introduction: Animals, Symbols, and the Poetic Tradition: Animal symbolism in poetry and Hughes's birds
- Crow as Post-Apocalyptic Shadow Self: Crow as Jungian shadow of post-human guilt
- Crow's Religion, Self-Destruction, and the Id: Crow's failed religion and Freudian Id drives
- Hawk as Superego and Universal Will: Hawk as cold dominion and superego figure
- Trickster Mythology and Schopenhauer's Will: Cross-cultural trickster figures and Schopenhauer's philosophy
- Salvation Through Animal Nature: Animal sublimity as path to metaphysical salvation
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The essay weaves together multiple theoretical frameworks — Jungian psychology, Freudian drive theory, and Schopenhauer's philosophy of the will — without losing sight of the poems themselves, grounding each claim in direct quotation.
- The juxtaposition of Crow and Hawk is sustained and analytically productive, with each bird illuminating the other as opposing yet complementary aspects of the human psyche.
- The essay moves from close reading to broad cultural and mythological context smoothly, connecting Hughes's birds to Norse, Greek, and Native American trickster figures without straining the argument.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates sustained thematic synthesis: it identifies a central theoretical lens (the Jungian shadow / Schopenhauer's will) and applies it consistently across multiple poems and mythological traditions. Rather than treating each poem in isolation, the essay builds a cumulative argument in which each example deepens the preceding one, culminating in a unified claim about animistic salvation in Hughes's work.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a broad survey of animal symbolism in literature before narrowing to Hughes's birds. It then develops Crow as shadow self through close reading, introduces Hawk as counterpoint, situates both in mythological and philosophical traditions, and concludes with the redemptive implications of the animal nature Hughes celebrates. The bibliography cites two secondary sources alongside extensive primary quotation from the poems.
Introduction: Animals, Symbols, and the Poetic Tradition
Poets and prophets from Aesop to Isaiah to Blake have traditionally used animal figures to convey a criticism of existing culture, endowing the natural world with metaphoric import. In most preliterate cultures, animals were equally endowed with metaphoric importance, more immediately interpreted into mythologies and shamanistic rituals that enabled people to address and interact with their world. In the modern British and Irish context, it is common to use such animal characters to analyze or criticize society, and moreover to redirect human attention to natural qualities within the human soul that civilization has overlooked or purposefully disrespected. So when Ted Hughes focuses significant poetic attention on birds, one is not surprised by the parallels he draws between these winged creatures and the evolution of the soul. What may seem surprising is the degree to which he subverts modern symbolic understandings of particular bird types by reverting to more arcane symbolisms and understandings of both the animal and human world.
From looking at poems such as Poe's "The Raven" and the nearly omnipresent appearance of black birds as harbingers of death, destruction, war, and evil in the literature of the last thousand years, one understands that crows are symbolically loaded animals with very negative connotations. Certainly some of this stems from the role of crows in Biblical prophetic texts as emblems of the fall of Israel and the aftermath of battles. Crows, which scavenge much of their food from the corpses of the dead, are very much out of favor in our modern antiseptic culture. It is therefore inherently shocking to the self-image to see Hughes slowly shape The Crow into a sort of prototype for evolved humanity, representing both our worst and best traits.
In Hughes's work, Crow serves as a metaphor for humanity. He is explained as that thing God allowed to be created by his own nightmares after humans rejected life; but his experience throughout the poems appears to be that of a human being as experienced through the life of a raven-bird. He is a fallen creature, a trickster, and a graveyard for the body of all those he eats — "his every feather the fossil of a murder" (Hughes, "Crow's Nerve Fails"). Yet he is also a survivor, a dreamer and creator of words, and a theologian obsessed with discovering the truth of art (such as Oedipus), sexuality, and life.
As a foil to the self-congratulating and self-flagellating Crow, Hughes also describes the hawk. This hawk, far from being the noble and somehow sympathetic creature that Romantic symbolism would try to make of him, is a cruel and willful tyrant who nonetheless carries a certain appeal that is very telling. It is Hawk who holds the whole world in stasis while Crow tries to change it, and Hawk who enforces death while Crow seeks alternately to transcend it, become it, and escape it. Hawk too seems symbolic of the modern human mind in its relentless push for power and control — though Hawk is less conflicted and less perverted in his unhypocritical brutality.
Three main points govern the discussion that follows. First, that as a prefiguring of post-apocalyptic humanity, Crow may be designed to embrace essentially human qualities that mankind has tried to deny. Second, that the universe of Crow and Hawk reflects a Schopenhauerian vision of a dirty will and a dirtier sublimity, which is heightened and explicated by their animal forms. Finally, that Crow and Hawk may yet offer a possibility of salvation for humankind amid the deep bleakness they survey, if mankind can also learn to embrace its nonhuman and noncivilized inner nature.
Bibliography
Eddins, Dwight. "Ted Hughes and Schopenhauer: The Poetry of the Will." Twentieth Century Literature, Spring 1999.
Skea, Anna. "Ted Hughes and Crow." 1998.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.