Should the Teen Driving Age Be Raised? Arguments Against
This paper evaluates proposed legislation to raise the minimum driving age for teenagers, arguing that such laws would likely neither significantly reduce accident rates nor be fair to young drivers. Drawing on data from the Journal of Safety Research, the Maryland Highway Safety Office, the National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, and a Liberty Mutual/SADD Teen Driving Study, the paper challenges claims that older age alone reduces crash risk. It contends that inexperience—not age—is the central danger, that drunk driving is an adult problem as much as a teen one, that parents bear primary responsibility for safe teen driving, and that restricting driving rights for all teenagers based on the behavior of a few is inequitable.
- Introduction: Proposed Legislation and the Central Claim: Nevada and Maryland bills prompt debate on teen driving
- The Inexperience Argument Examined: Inexperience, not age, drives crash risk
- Drunk Driving: Not Just a Teen Problem: Adult hardcore drunk drivers cause most fatal crashes
- Parental Responsibility and Role Modeling: Parents better positioned than law to change teen behavior
- Civil Liberties, Independence, and Teen Drivers: Raising driving age unfairly penalizes responsible teens
- Conclusion: Age Is Not the Answer: Age limits fail to address root causes of teen crashes
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper consistently applies a clear argumentative pattern: it states an opposing claim, presents supporting evidence, then systematically refutes it using independent data sources. This structure makes it easy to follow the logical flow even when confronting complex statistics.
- It avoids one-dimensional counterargument by layering multiple refutations — inexperience, alcohol, parental responsibility, and civil liberties — each supported by named studies and surveys, lending credibility to its position.
- The use of specific percentages and survey findings (e.g., the Liberty Mutual/SADD study and Maryland Highway data) grounds abstract policy claims in concrete evidence.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of the refutation-based argumentative essay structure. Rather than simply advocating for a position, the writer acknowledges credible opposing evidence before dismantling it. This technique — sometimes called the Rogerian or concession-refutation method — signals intellectual honesty and strengthens the persuasive impact of the central claim.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a policy news hook and states its thesis early. It then moves through a series of topical refutations: (1) the inexperience vs. age distinction, (2) the drunk driving data reframed toward adult offenders, (3) parental monitoring as the preferred solution, and (4) a civil liberties argument about fairness to teens. The conclusion returns to the core thesis, reaffirming that raising the driving age does not address the root causes of teen traffic risk.
Introduction: Proposed Legislation and the Central Claim
A number of lawmakers in the state of Nevada began pushing for the passage of a bill that would raise the age at which teenagers may obtain automobile licenses (Hagar). The legislators supporting the law cited statistics as their main reason: according to the United States Department of Public Safety, in 2002, 6,327 American youths between the ages of 16 and 20 were killed in traffic accidents. Similar bills in Nevada previously failed, although they were enthusiastically supported by bipartisan legislators. Around the same time in Maryland, bills proposed by the governor and legislative advocates requested greater parental involvement and harsher penalties for driving infractions (Gavant).
Should such laws be passed? Are they fair to teenagers? Will they achieve their stated goal of lowering fatality and accident rates? Regardless of what proponents of these bills argue, such legislation will probably not significantly decrease accident numbers. In addition, these bills are likely prejudicial against younger teenagers.
The Inexperience Argument Examined
Those in favor of raising the driving age point to the conclusions of a series of research papers published in the January 2003 special issue of the Journal of Safety Research (Lin), which make a compelling case for older drivers. According to that report, accident risk is highest among the most inexperienced teens. Drivers 16 years of age experience crashes almost three times as often as more experienced drivers aged 18 to 19.
The key word, however, is "inexperienced." If drivers are only a couple of years older but still inexperienced, will that make a meaningful difference? No matter what their age, new drivers are likely to have the same level of inexperience and pose the same degree of risk. Furthermore, the statistics cited from the United States Department of Public Safety cover accidents involving youth and young adults from 16 to 20. Does this mean it would be best to withhold a permanent license until age 20? Even the strongest advocates for raising the driving age would find it difficult to endorse that conclusion.
References
Focus Adolescent Services. Alcohol and Teen Drinking. 21 February 2005. http://www.focusas.com/Alcohol.html
Gavant, K. "Teen Drivers Face Tougher Restrictions." Montgomery County Sentinel.
Hagar, R. "Bill Puts Stricter Rules on Teen Driving." Reno Gazette-Journal, 17 February 2005.
Lin, M.L., ed. "Graduated Driver Licensing." Journal of Safety Research 2003; 34 (special issue): 1–126.
"Maryland Drivers Fess Up to Risky Behavior." n.d. Maryland Traffic-Safety Awareness for Employers Project. 21 February 2005.
National Hardcore Drunk Driver Project. "Who Are the Hardcore Drunk Drivers?" October 2003. 21 February 2005.
Simpson, H.M., Mayhew, D.R., and Beirness, D.J. Dealing With the Hard Core Drinking Driver. Ottawa, Canada: The Traffic Injury Research Foundation, 1996.
"Teens Copy Parents' Driving Habits." Road & Travel. n.d. Liberty Mutual Insurance Company. 21 February 2005.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.