This paper analyzes the challenges posed by the United States' open border immigration system, with particular focus on immigration from Mexico. Drawing on data from the Center for Immigration Studies, the paper outlines seven major disadvantages of an open border policy: increased poverty from unskilled labor surplus, overburdened social programs, reduced domestic consumer spending, security vulnerabilities, job displacement for low-skilled Americans, negative effects on certain industries, and suppressed regional education standards. The paper concludes by recommending policies to address immigrant illiteracy and notes the possibility of a North American Union that could render traditional immigration debates obsolete.
Over the years, the United States has maintained relatively open pathways for legal immigration from other countries. Among the major beneficiaries of this open border system are Mexicans who have moved in and out of the USA freely in pursuit of jobs, a better life, and other opportunities. However, among them have also been illegal immigrants willing to do whatever it takes to enter the United States for work in California's industries and beyond.
The most pressing problem that many Americans — and the government — face is the issue of illegal immigration into the USA. This concern is fueled by several factors, including the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks, which brought national security and border control into sharp public focus.
An open border policy presents numerous problems for the receiving country compared to nations with strict border controls. The challenges the United States faces as a result of its open border system span economic, social, security, and educational dimensions. The following sections outline the primary disadvantages as identified in immigration research and policy analysis.
It is worth noting that the immigration issue extends beyond Mexican nationals and also encompasses Canadian immigrants entering the United States. Many Canadians are educated and skilled. This means they may compete directly for skilled positions at equivalent salaries, since they hold comparable qualifications and education to native-born Americans. This competition may not benefit local communities, as it creates additional pressure on the job market. Furthermore, the issue of money circulation arises, since Canadian immigrants tend to send earnings back to Canada, further affecting the American economy (The Boston Tea Party, 2011).
(A) Poverty: According to the Center for Immigration Studies (CIS) (2001), immigration from Mexico adds more unskilled labor to the supply already available among American workers. This results in an excess labor supply, which drives down the cost of labor. The number of people earning below a living wage rises daily, and poverty levels rise correspondingly.
(B) Overburdening social programs: The Mexican immigrant population in the USA continues to grow, but because their earnings are meager — a consequence of the low-skill jobs they hold — their tax contributions are minimal. The CIS estimates that two-thirds of Mexican immigrants have not completed high school. Despite this, they continue to use social services such as Medicaid, housing assistance, and food stamps. This places a burden on social programs because there are no equitable returns for those services. The CIS approximates that 10% more is spent on Mexican immigrants than on native-born Americans, largely due to the larger family sizes associated with higher fertility rates. The CIS further argues that the taxes paid by an average adult Mexican immigrant, minus the value of services received, yields a net figure of negative $55,200. Multiplied across an estimated 8 million people, the cumulative burden on the United States is substantial.
(C) Decrease in domestic spending: The immigrant population is engaged mostly in wage labor rather than self-employment. Once wages are paid, much of the money is repatriated to their home countries as remittances. Indeed, remittances constitute Mexico's third-largest source of income, estimated at $8 billion per year. Because these large sums are not spent within the United States, the result is lower consumer spending among this population — a situation detrimental to the American economy.
"National security risks, job losses, and education impacts"
Because unskilled labor is the root cause of most immigrant-related economic problems, the United States should work to create policies that address illiteracy and low educational attainment within the immigrant population. Raising educational levels would, in turn, increase the cost of labor and improve other economic conditions. This approach is especially important given that immigration is unlikely to diminish significantly in the near future — if at all.
You’re 58% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.