Skip to main content
Essay Undergraduate 1,963 words

William James on Self, Conversion, and Saintly Love

~10 min read 5 sections Psychology
Abstract

This paper examines William James's psychology of the self, tracing his division of the psyche into the phenomenal "Me" and the subjective "I," and exploring how religious conversion transforms both dimensions simultaneously. Drawing on James's The Principles of Psychology and The Varieties of Religious Experience, the paper explains how the material, social, and spiritual aspects of the Me-self are reshaped when the I-self undergoes conversion. The second part analyzes James's concept of saintliness — its four defining qualities and consequences — and interrogates whether extreme charitable love ("agape") represents humanity at its best, connecting James's framework to Buddhist notions of cosmic interconnectedness.

Key Takeaways
  • The Two Selves: James's Division of the Psyche: James divides the psyche into I-self and Me-self
  • The Me-Self: Material, Social, and Spiritual Dimensions: Three interrelated aspects of the empirical self
  • Conversion as Transformation of the Whole Psyche: How conversion reshapes both I-self and Me-self cyclically
  • Saintliness: Qualities and Consequences: Four qualities and four consequences of saintly character
  • Brotherly Love, Agape, and the Question of Humanity at Its Best: Agape, Buddhism, and cosmic interconnectedness compared
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • It grounds abstract philosophical concepts in direct quotation from James, anchoring claims in primary source evidence rather than paraphrase alone.
  • The cyclical I↔Me feedback loop is explained clearly and then reinforced with concrete examples (the monk becoming a hermit, the convert's altered marriage choices), making a difficult idea accessible.
  • The comparative move to Buddhism in the final section broadens the argument without overreaching, showing that James's framework has cross-traditional resonance.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper demonstrates close reading of a primary philosophical text combined with synthetic analysis: it extracts a conceptual structure from James (I/Me, the four qualities of saintliness), applies that structure to a specific phenomenon (conversion), and then tests its implications against an independent tradition (Buddhism). This technique — extract, apply, interrogate — is a reliable model for philosophy and psychology essays.

Structure breakdown

The essay moves in two clearly marked parts. Part One builds the theoretical scaffolding: James's dual-self model, the three subdivisions of the Me-self, and the mechanics of conversion as a total psychic transformation. Part Two applies that scaffolding to saintliness and agape, listing James's four qualities and consequences before raising the evaluative question of whether such love represents humanity at its best. The conclusion pivots to Buddhism as a comparative lens, ending on the pragmatic claim that genuine interconnectedness makes brotherly love a pleasure rather than a sacrifice.

Essay 1,963 words

The Two Selves: James's Division of the Psyche

William James saw the human psyche as awesomely complex. To begin with, he divided it into two selves:

The phenomenal self (the experienced self, the "Me" self, the self as known) and the self-thought (the "I" self, the self as knower).

There is the "Me," which is the objective, detached term that we use and that we see — the empirical self. And then there is the "I," the constant flow of subjective thought that a person has about the self, which makes the person perceive the self, moment by moment, in a certain way:

"Personality implies the incessant presence of two elements, an objective person, known by a passing subjective Thought and recognized as continuing in time. Hereafter let us use the words ME and I for the empirical person and the judging Thought." (James, 1890, Vol. 1, p. 371.)

James's discussion of the I-Self is philosophically complex. He points out that we form a holistic sense of self by compounding the I of yesterday with the I of preceding days, aggregating them into one whole. On the contrary, however, the I is constantly fluctuating and is made up of a series of pointillist "I"s that differ according to context. The convert, for instance, is different in the moment after conversion than before. The person thinks in a different way; his reference to himself is different.

The Me-Self: Material, Social, and Spiritual Dimensions

The Me-self is further divided into three different, interrelated aspects:

The material self (anything toward which we feel some sort of physical ownership, such as our bodies, our families, and our possessions), the social self (our feelings about our social relations), and the spiritual self (our feelings about our own subjectivity).

A person has many different social selves, because he perceives himself in numerous ways and is consequently perceived by each of his acquaintances in a diversity of ways. Similarly, a person's self-esteem is shaped by his goals and the level of achievement he sets for himself, while there is a disjunction between ideal self and real self — seeing oneself in one abstract way while functioning, in actuality, as a quite different human being.

3 Sections Hidden · 990 words
Conversion as Transformation of the Whole Psyche380 words
The conversion experience is one that transforms the whole person. This includes both the I and the Me. It therefore has…
Saintliness: Qualities and Consequences320 words
The cartoon about Self meeting Rational Self is appropriate to James's thesis on the two opposing systems that battle within the human psyche: susceptibility to emotional excitement and susceptibility to impulses and inhibitions (p. 212). The first represents the "aye" — it moves a person…
Brotherly Love, Agape, and the Question of Humanity at Its Best290 words
James constructs his theory of love in a reasonable manner: the liminality of conversion leads to an assurance of God as Father and from there to the knowledge — more still, the indelible assurance — that God is the Father of all. As James remarks, the feeling of the convert is that "God…

References

James, W. (1890). The Principles of Psychology (2 vols.). New York: Henry Holt. (Reprinted Bristol: Thoemmes Press, 1999.)

James, W. The Varieties of Religious Experience. Retrieved from

Key Concepts in This Paper
I-Self Me-Self Religious Conversion Saintliness Agape Phenomenal Self Self-Surrender Brotherly Love Cosmic Interconnectedness Cyclical Transformation
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). William James on Self, Conversion, and Saintly Love. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/william-james-self-conversion-saintly-love-107174

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.