This paper examines three theoretical approaches to understanding youth crime in Australia: life experience, transitions, and emerging adulthood. Through an annotated bibliography and literature review, the paper evaluates how each framework addresses youth risk-taking, reckless behavior, and criminal involvement. Drawing on developmental psychology and criminology research, the analysis explores identity formation, peer influence, and psychosocial risk factors across late adolescence and early adulthood. The paper concludes that life experience and transitional approaches provide complementary insights into how young people navigate complex social and developmental challenges that may lead to criminal behavior.
This paper examines three complementary theoretical approaches for understanding youth crime in Australia: life experience, transitions, and emerging adulthood. Each framework offers distinct insights into how young people develop identity, manage risk, and navigate the pathway from adolescence to adulthood. The question of which approach is most useful for exploring youth crime requires careful evaluation of how each theory accounts for developmental mechanisms, peer influence, and the social context of Australian youth. By integrating these frameworks, we can develop a more comprehensive understanding of the factors that contribute to criminal involvement during late adolescence and early adulthood.
Arnett, J. (2007). Emerging Adulthood: What Is It, and What Is It Good For? Child Development Perspectives, 1(2), pp. 68–73.
In this article, Arnett explains the concept of emerging adulthood and the new developmental period created between adolescence and young adulthood. This age period is examined as a positive transition for most people, though some emerging adults may experience developmental challenges and serious problems. The article provides useful theoretical grounding for understanding the distinctive characteristics and challenges of the emerging adult phase, which will assist in explaining how dilemmas and developmental strides contribute to behavioral outcomes in this age group.
Bradley, G. and Wildman, K. (2002). Psychosocial Predictors of Emerging Adults' Risk. Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 31(4), pp. 253–265.
This journal article enhances understanding of life course aspects in emerging adults, examining risk and reckless behaviors and gender differences in how these behaviors manifest. The authors argue that behavior has distinctive demographic and psychosocial correlates, with particular patterns common in emerging adults. The writing style addresses a range of audiences using self-report measures and cross-sectional design, making it accessible while maintaining methodological rigor. This source is valuable for understanding the psychological mechanisms underlying youth risk behavior.
te Riele, K. (2004). Youth Transition in Australia: Challenging Assumptions of Linearity and Choice. Journal of Youth Studies, 7(3), pp. 243–257.
This article critically examines current youth and education policy, challenging the assumption that successful transitions require linear pathways and that individuals always have meaningful control over their life choices. The author's research demonstrates that transitions are often more complex and contingent than policy assumes. The article provides useful information about the risks and opportunities young people experience and identifies factors that affect transition experiences of students in the Australian context, making it particularly relevant to understanding structural constraints on youth pathways.
Wyn, J. and Harris, A. (2004). Youth Research in Australia and New Zealand. Young, 12(3), pp. 271–289.
This article draws on youth research in Australia and New Zealand, examining youth environments in society and participation in youth cultures. The research reveals theoretical debates within the field of youth studies, demonstrating how impacts of social change on society are being addressed through cross-disciplinary approaches. This source is useful for contextualizing youth research within the Australian and regional framework and understanding the breadth of factors affecting youth development and behavior.
Forrest, W. and Hay, C. (2011). Life-Course Transitions, Self-Control and Desistance from Crime. Criminology and Criminal Justice, 11(5), pp. 487–513.
This article directly addresses how a person's level of self-control may be related to changes in their involvement in crime. The authors use data from the Child and Young Adult Supplement of the National Longitudinal Study of Youth (NLSY79). Their findings show that people who marry experience an increase in self-control and a decrease in the probability of engaging in crime. This article is particularly useful for the research topic, as the study supports the hypothesis that major life transitions and increased social bonds reduce criminal behavior while improving individual self-control, providing a direct link between developmental transitions and crime desistance.
The term transition refers to the stages from youth to adulthood, and may be understood as a transition pathway in which individuals choose the direction they wish to pursue. Arnett (2000) indicates that the period of the late teens and early twenties is not merely a short-term period of transition into adult roles but a period of life course characterized by change and experimentation. An effective transition requires a structured pathway, yet people retain agency in deciding their transition direction (te Riele, 2004). Many young people move into adulthood without organizing or managing considerable social, political, economic, and cultural changes in their lives.
Arnett (2000) claims the most volitional years of life span from the early teens to mid-twenties. During this period, adult commitment and responsibilities are often delayed while role experimentation that begins in adolescence continues and intensifies. However, Forrest and Hay (2011) argue that a main criticism of the youth-as-transition framework is that some changes in education, work, and home life can result in failures or disruptions. These failures in transition may increase vulnerability to negative outcomes, including criminal involvement. Understanding transitions as pathways with potential for both success and derailment is essential for examining how youth crime emerges during critical developmental moments.
Emerging adulthood is a concept describing a new life stage between adolescence and full adulthood, characterized by demographic variability, subjective identity exploration, and instability. Arnett states that "thirty is the new twenty," describing a period of exploration and instability in which people experience different alternatives before settling into stable adult commitment. Rather than immediately settling into adult life, emerging adults explore multiple possibilities in relationships, work, and identity. These behaviors are not merely part of emerging adults' identity explorations but also reflect high levels of personal freedom and relatively few social responsibilities.
Psychosocial theories of risk-taking and reckless behavior emphasize that personal, social, and cognitive variables determine the behavior of emerging adults. Bradley and Wildman (2002) distinguish between "risk behavior" (adventurous, socially approved behaviors such as bungee jumping) and "reckless" behavior (actions that threaten safety and lack social acceptance, such as drink-driving or unsafe sex). People engage in these types of behaviors, especially during emerging adulthood, as a means of exploration and experience. However, the distinction between exploration and recklessness becomes blurred when risk-taking escalates or occurs without adequate protective factors, potentially leading to criminal involvement.
Youth use life experiences in the process of developing identity. Life experiences may include personal exploration, gaining self-knowledge, and developing a stronger sense of who they are as individuals. Adolescents working toward goals may develop skills including planning, problem-solving, and time management. However, young people may also seek out risky behaviors that produce negative experiences. These negative experiences become problematic when such behaviors multiply without adequate support systems to assist young people in processing or learning from them.
As individuals grow up and encounter unresolved negative experiences, they may confront many issues that lead to tragedy, crime, or social, emotional, and developmental difficulties. As published by the Australian Institute of Criminology (2001), social problems affect the physical and psychological well-being of youth, depending on neighborhood networks, family resources, and community amenities. The quality of life experience is therefore not simply a matter of individual choice but is significantly shaped by structural and environmental factors that either support or undermine healthy development.
Many young people follow normative patterns through relationships between school, work, and family while facing challenges during this period. Youth crime in Australia demonstrates that both life experience and transitional approaches address problems including homelessness, drug taking, and reckless behavior. During adolescence, peer pressure influences risk-taking, alcohol use, and substance abuse. Bradley and Wildman (2002) found that antisocial peer pressure affects youth behavior and recklessness. Young people rely on peer networks for identity confirmation and social belonging. As Haigh (2009) states, adolescence is a transition period involving complex physiological and social change. During this transitional stage, parental supervision becomes limited, and young people experience greater personal independence and decision-making autonomy. Voas and Kelley-Baker (2008) characterize this as a period in which members of the same cohort share common traits, are affected by the same environments, and share everyday experiences. Life experiences and transitions into adulthood thus play significant roles in shaping youth crime in Australia, mediated substantially by peer relationships and social context.
Life experiences and transitions into adulthood have a significant role in youth crime in Australia. Understanding which approach is most useful requires examining how each framework addresses specific mechanisms of risk and protective factors. The emerging adulthood framework highlights the normative exploration and identity work of this developmental stage, explaining why risk-taking is heightened during late teens and twenties. The transitions approach emphasizes the critical junctures and role changes that either facilitate or disrupt healthy development. The life experience framework grounds these abstract developmental processes in concrete daily realities—neighborhood contexts, peer relationships, family support, and cumulative effects of positive or negative interactions.
You’re 91% through this paper. Sign up to read the full paper.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.