317+ paper examples, study guides & outlines
Herman Melville's short story "Bartleby, the Scrivener" is a foundational text in American literature courses and is widely studied in undergraduate English and humanities classes. Published in 1853, the story follows a passive, enigmatic law copyist whose repeated refusal to comply — expressed through the phrase "I would prefer not to" — raises profound questions about labor, free will, alienation, and the limits of human connection. Its brevity makes it an accessible entry point for literary analysis, while its ambiguity rewards close reading and sustains serious critical debate.
Student papers on this topic most commonly take an analytical approach focused on character, theme, and narrative structure. Many examine the relationship between Bartleby and the unnamed narrator, exploring how power, sympathy, and helplessness interact in a Wall Street office setting. Others connect the story to Melville's biography and artistic development, reading Bartleby as a figure for the frustrated writer or the alienated worker. The recurring focus on characters like Turkey, the narrator's other scriveners, and the Wall Street environment suggests that papers frequently situate the story within its social and economic context.
A strong essay on "Bartleby, the Scrivener" builds a focused thesis around a specific interpretive claim — for example, what the narrator's failure to act reveals about complicity or moral responsibility — rather than simply summarizing plot. Textual evidence drawn from the story's dialogue, imagery, and setting typically carries the most weight. A common pitfall is treating Bartleby as purely symbolic without grounding that interpretation in the story's specific language and events.