Sabrina Comparison -- 1954 Versus Term Paper

PAGES
3
WORDS
984
Cite
Related Topics:

But Sabrina's initial rough exterior is still presented in terms of a kind of casual tomboyishness, in this case, Julia Ormond's bespeckled visage rather than Audrey Hepburn's ponytail. The young woman must put away childish, gender-ambiguous play and adopt a feminine norm, to show she is a 'real' woman, worthy of David's class. Contemporary norms in terms of how males and females are portrayed in the two versions, are perhaps more manifest in how the newer version seems to take a more damning view of David's love of fast women and fast cars and his frequently boorish behavior with the fair sex. But by virtue of replicating the plot, Linus' equally crass seduction of a vulnerable young woman to preserve a corporate merger is still viewed in a reasonably tolerant light.

Also, in terms of the characteristics of both versions of Linus, Linus remains a much older man, which raises the question of how much better his relationship with Sabrina will be, although the viewer may take relief in the fact that she has been saved a marital 'merger' with the self-centered and irresponsible David. In the newer version, Sabrina's intelligence and strength of personally are more forthrightly expressed in her behavior with both David and Linus, which shows how it is no longer acceptable to show a woman's transformation purely visually, or in terms of her cooking and fashion skills, as it was in 1954.

However, although gender...

...

Sabrina originally falls for 'the bad boy' and then she absconds with a father figure. A woman is incomplete until she finds her true love, even if she has been to Paris, even if she is a pediatrician. Gender stereotypes have altered in the sense that male rakishness, as personified by David, is less tolerantly viewed, and it is no longer acceptable to see a woman's destiny only as physical transformation and marriage. But the values of the films remain the same -- love triumphs over all other possible values or life options. There is no question that Sabrina will not be happy marrying an older man.
In some sense, however the feminine values of Hollywood also have remained the same. Linus' focus on money is shown to be hollow, and the love that drives Sabrina to 'improve' herself, becomes an elevating force for the business, for the introverted Linus, and teaches an important lesson to David. The feminine value of love, presumably the value of the feminine audience of the film, reigns triumphant, reflecting common cultural and social myths, if not the practices and norms of real life.

Works Cited

Sabrina." Directed by Billy Wilder. 1954.

Sabrina. Directed by Sydney Pollack. 1995.

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Sabrina." Directed by Billy Wilder. 1954.

Sabrina. Directed by Sydney Pollack. 1995.


Cite this Document:

"Sabrina Comparison -- 1954 Versus" (2006, December 22) Retrieved April 20, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/sabrina-comparison-1954-versus-72940

"Sabrina Comparison -- 1954 Versus" 22 December 2006. Web.20 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/sabrina-comparison-1954-versus-72940>

"Sabrina Comparison -- 1954 Versus", 22 December 2006, Accessed.20 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/sabrina-comparison-1954-versus-72940

Related Documents

Cinderella / Transformation Stories Variants on the "Cinderella" Story The Cinderella story is one that is much loved throughout the world; more than seven hundred versions exist. Many of these versions have been told for centuries. The story has universal appeal because of specific elements that are part of human nature. It is a story in which good triumphs over evil. It is a story that shows that dreams really can come

Cinderella archetype is manifest in characters like Mathilde Loisel in Guy De Maupassant's "The Necklace," Cinderella in Charles Perault's "Cinderella," Wassilissa in Russian folktale "The Beautiful Wassilissa," and Princess Ann in the 1953 film Roman Holiday. Guy De Maupassant's short story "The Necklace" is about a working class woman, Mathilde, who longs to be wealthy but learns a hard lesson about the illusion of glamor. Perrault's Cinderella is about a

Cinderella Perrault's "Cinderella" and the American Dream The Cinderella story has existed since the age of antiquity and has been told in many different cultures in as many different fashions. Yet, in America, one version stands out above the rest. Charles Perrault's version, popularized by Disney in 1950, became the standard, sentimental (Disneyfied) "some day my Prince will come" spawning fairy tale that became the classic progenitor of other animated features like

Cinderella Fairy Tales
PAGES 3 WORDS 1294

Cinderella: Or, On the Virtues of Shutting Up and Sitting Down There are many ways of critiquing folktales. However, they all agree on one central point: the tale is told to children so that they will behave. In less coercive terms, one might say the story is that so that the child will grow up to be a functional part of society. Either way, it boils down to the same thing.

Cinderella The Salvation of Cinderella: Moral Character and Virtue Two entirely different versions of the same basic theme show that gender norms and social roles remain relatively constant and consistent across cultures. The Disney version of the "Cinderella" story, which was originally a European folk tale, is about a girl who lives with her mean old stepmother and step sisters, who work Cinderella like a slave and treat her terribly. Cinderella eventually

The second significant difference between the French and Germany version of Cinderella is the tone used by the authors. Perrault provides a sense of triumph for Cinderella, a caring guardian in the fairy godmother and a positive moral at the end of the story. The Brothers Grimm use grotesque descriptions to illustrate the evil of the stepmother and stepsisters. They force Cinderella to separate lentils while they attend the ball. They