Current Debate About Measuring Poverty and Wealth in Canada Essay

Download this Essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Essay:

Straightened Circumstances": A Review and Analysis of the Current Debate about Measuring Poverty and Wealth in Canada

Although there is no official definition of poverty in Canada, recent estimates place the percentage as high as 14% overall, with significantly higher levels for vulnerable populations such as single elderly females, indigenous peoples, and single females with children. These levels of poverty indicate that the problem is severe and it is important to ensure that the steps that are taken to address poverty in Canada are timely and effective. In order to ensure that the scarce resources that are used to assist impoverished Canadians are applied effectively, though, there must also be some reliable ways of determining whether progress is being made or not. To this end, this paper provides a review and analysis of the relevant literature concerning the current debate about measuring poverty and wealth in Canada, followed by a summary of the research and important findings in the conclusion.

Review and Analysis

By most economic and social measures, Canada is a wealthy nation that enjoys high standards of living and longevity. In this regard, analysts with the U.S. government characterize Canada as "an affluent, high-tech industrial society in the trillion-dollar class [which] resembles the U.S. In its market-oriented economic system, pattern of production, and affluent living standards" (Canada, 2012, para. 3). In addition, Canada has a gross domestic product (GDP) of about $38,000, ranking it 22nd in the world's 220 or so countries (Canada GDP, 2012). This rank, though, is in sharp contrast to Canada's position just 40 years ago when it was ranked third in the world (Canada GDP, 2012). Moreover, this average national GDP does not accurately reflect the tens of thousands of Canadians who live below an ill-defined poverty line, an issue that has become especially important to many observers in recent years. In this regard, the chief statistician for Statistics Canada emphasizes that, "Many individuals and organizations both in Canada and abroad understandably want to know how many people and families live in 'poverty,' and how these levels change. Reflecting this need, different groups have at different times developed various measures which purported to divide the population into those who were poor and those who were not" (Fellegi, 1997, para. 1).

Given this importance, it is not surprising that these issues have assumed new relevance and importance in recent years but there remains a lack of an "official" definition of poverty that is used by all Canadian governmental agencies (Ross, Scott & Smith, 2000). Despite this lack, Reutter, Veenstra and Stewart (2006) estimate that around 14% of Canadians currently live in poverty; moreover, estimates of poverty are much higher rates for some other groups in Canada, including single-parent mother families, female seniors without partners, urban Aboriginals and immigrants who arrived in Canada recently (Reutter et al. 2006).

While the overall rate of poverty has declined modestly during the period from 2001 to 2005, the depth of poverty during this same period increased for many Canadians (Reutter et al., 2006). Indeed, Hicks (2007) emphasizes that, "Most Canadians would be shocked if they knew how a large number of their fellow Canadians survive" (p. 205). Interestingly, Hicks does not say "live" but rather "survive," indicating the dire conditions in which many Canadians find themselves in the 21st century. In reality, though, economic conditions have been tougher in recent years for all Canadians. Given its close geographic proximity to the U.S., it is not surprising that Canada has experienced its fair share of the global economic downturn that originated in the subprime mortgage meltdown in 2007. As a result, the Canadian economy experienced a severe recession by late 2008, and the national government was forced to concede a fiscal deficit in 2009, the first such fiscal deficit after 12 years of budget surpluses (Canada, 2012). Despite this fiscal setback, Canada's major banks were strengthened by the Great Recession and the country has resumed marginal growth and expects to balance the national budge by 2015 (Canada, 2012). It remains unclear, though, whether this rising economic tide will raise all boats.

Despite its close geographic proximity, Canada does not share an "official" or single definition for poverty with the U.S. (Hick, 2007); rather, different definitions are used by various organizations and agencies in Canada which all measure poverty differently (Ross et al., 2000). Indeed, as Ross and his colleagues, "Given the immense complexity of the problem -- the fact that what constitutes poverty varies from place to place, from decade to decade and even from household to household -- it can be argued that the only alternative to an inadequate definition is no definition at all" (p. 13). It is axiomatic, though, that in order to improve something it must first be measured and while Canada does not have official measure of poverty in place, the most widely used approach is the Statistics Canada measure. According to Ross et al., "Virtually all of the statistics used by other national measures of poverty in Canada come from Statistics Canada's annual survey of incomes. Statistics Canada itself does not claim to measure poverty; rather, it defines a set of income cut-offs below which people may be said to live in straitened circumstances" (2000, p. 14). These income cut-off points are widely used throughout Canada as demarking poverty levels (Ross et al., 2000), and Hick reports that, "One in six Canadians live in 'straightened circumstances'" (2007, p. 205).

While the Statistics Canada income cut-off levels provide a basis for measurement, they do not provide any guidance concerning what social programs are best suited for addressing these disparities. Moreover, there remains a lack of consensus among Canadian policymakers and social welfare agencies concerning what should be done, as well as mixed emotions on the part of mainstream Canadians regarding the relative importance of these efforts (Hick, 2007). This point is also made by Armitage (2005) who reports, "Social welfare policy appears now to be stable, with change in policy no longer a government priority. Instead, there are new priorities: particularly, the 'war on terrorism,' and the security and trade relationship with the United States occupy the federal government agenda" (pp. 96-97).

It is also axiomatic that in order for something to improve, it must first be made a priority. Unfortunately, these recent trends suggest that the issue of measuring poverty in Canada has stagnated to the point where many consumers may feel that their tax dollars are being wasted on ineffective initiatives that fail to make any substantive progress in addressing the fundamental social problems that contribute to inordinately high levels of poverty among certain Canadian groups. Complicating the problem even further are the shifting social aspects of poverty and wealth that change over time and place. In this regard, Fellegi (1997) stresses that, "The underlying difficulty is due to the fact that poverty is intrinsically a question of social consensus, at a given point in time and in the context of a given country" (para. 4).

In fact, in highly affluent modern nations, it is entirely possible for people to be relatively well-off in terms of their basic living needs such as shelter, food and clothes and still be viewed as impoverished while these same people might be viewed as affluent in a highly impoverished country where survival is questionable for many (Fellegi, 1997). As Fellegi points out, "Someone acceptably well off in terms of the standards in a developing country might well be considered desperately poor in Canada. And even within the same country, the outlook changes over time. A standard of living considered as acceptable in the previous century might well be viewed with abhorrence today" (para. 4). The essential problem, Fellegi (1997) suggests, involves this highly subjective nature of definitions of poverty as well as a lack of…[continue]

Some Sources Used in Document:


Cite This Essay:

"Current Debate About Measuring Poverty And Wealth In Canada" (2012, February 05) Retrieved October 25, 2016, from

"Current Debate About Measuring Poverty And Wealth In Canada" 05 February 2012. Web.25 October. 2016. <>

"Current Debate About Measuring Poverty And Wealth In Canada", 05 February 2012, Accessed.25 October. 2016,

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Applying Servant Leadership Within a

    Initially, I had to point out when people were saying things that would indicate a connection between group members. However, once those connections were established, the group members moved rather rapidly towards directly relating with one another. Another result of the group meetings is that the group members initially appeared very focused on the past. Small groups tend to do postmortems of old failures, archaeologizing (digging in the past for

  • Inflation Unemployment and Phillips Curve

    2.5. Limitations of the study At the level of the limitations, these refer to the usage of secondary information, as opposed to the collection of primary data through the direct analysis of the Chinese market. This limitation is nevertheless addressed through the integration of multiple sources of valid and verifiable information, leading as such to the creation of solid, relevant and reliable findings. The second limitation is one common to all research

  • Principal Agent Model in Economics and Political Science

    Principal-Agent Model in Economics and Political Science The international political perspectives of free trade A Global Analysis International Trade Impact on Tunisia The Export of agricultural products International trade and development of Tunisia Balance in the Trade Regime Imports and exports of Tunisia Exports Imports Coping With External and Internal Pressures The Common External Tariff (CET) Safeguard Measures Anti-Dumping Duties (ADDs) and Countervailing Duties (CVDs) Rules of origin The New Commercial Policy Instrument Sector Based Aspects GATT/WTO's Main Principles Non-discriminatory trade Multilateral negotiation and free trade The Trading Policies

  • Environmental Sustainability Has Been Increasingly

    Literature Review, Analysis and Discussion 7,500 words This section presents a review of the recent relevant peer-reviewed and scholarly literature concerning environmental sustainability in general and how environmental sustainability initiatives can help multinational corporations of different sizes and types achieve a competitive advantage in particular. Literature Review. According to Michalisin and Stinchfield (2010), "There is widespread consensus that human activity has had a significant impact on global climatic patterns which will have

  • Mass Health Access Cost and Quality of

    Mass Health Access, Cost, and Quality of the Massachusetts State Health Program: A Model for the Nation? Few issues are as controversial or as pressing in terms of national policy than healthcare, which was and continues to be a prominent election issue and matter of public debate and scrutiny. Technological and pharmaceutical advancements and innovation have created a wealth of opportunities for improved quality of life and quality of care for many

Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved