Frame Analysis Vs. Quantitative Frame Term Paper

PAGES
4
WORDS
1315
Cite

"Other researchers think they can be used in combination only by alternating between methods: qualitative research is appropriate to answer certain kinds of questions in certain conditions and quantitative is right for others. And some researchers think that both qualitative and quantitative methods can be used simultaneously to answer a research question" (Barnes et al., 2005). There are two sets of challenges that enfold the idea of frame and discourse analysis. The first takes place in the areas of data collection, analysis, and final presentation results. The challenge surrounds definitions and conceptualizations. Ideational concepts are intrinsically inaccurate and distinctions between frames, ideologies and discourses are often indistinct. Discourse and frames are connected and sometimes overlap. Cultural discourses can comprise frames. Ideologies frequently do the same things frames do and are sometimes called frames (Johnston, 2002).

A second set of challenges has to do with verification and proof. Both frame and discourse analyses tackle the difficult tasks of describing and presenting evidence for concepts that exist in the black box of mental life. Attaining access to mental life has forever been a challenge to social science, but with the utilization of questionaries and focus groups, or by inferring from general texts or observed behavior, it is likely to represent the mental constructs within the limits of the chosen method (Johnston, 2002).

Frame and discourse analyses frequently use qualitative methods of data reduction and presentation. Qualitative data reduction orders a wide diversity of written or spoken textual materials by categories that represent more universal factors. The coding of texts by these categories is founded on the decision of the researcher. Presentation findings rely on texts that are assumed to be representative of a particular category, and without numerical gauge of the categories' contents. Since textual data come contextually entrenched and are frequently gathered in ways that offer insights into their explanation that are lost in survey methods, qualitative analysis presents higher validity of the findings but less reliability. Coding categories are produced...

...

"It is typical that textual materials are analyzed in a two step process, first, to refine theoretical categories and generate new ones, often by review of an exploratory sample of texts, and second, to apply newly refined codes to the broad body of text" (Johnston, 2002).
The majority qualitative discourse analysis intensively analyzes textual materials with the objective of laying exposed the relationships between movement discourse and the discursive field of the broader culture. "A convincing case for this kind of discursive embeddedness may be made by moving between a movement's textual material and those of the broader culture, but this is a research strategy that only secondarily and implicitly can take up the central why questions from the field, such as why a movement succeeds, why a movement fails, or why a movement has a particular trajectory" (Johnston, 2002). Qualitative discourse analysis is distinguished by a concentrated focus on movement-related texts to recognize patterns, connections, and structures of ideas. This typically precludes systematic assessment of patterns over time and how they may vary according to other pressures, a realistic constraint of the method rather than inherent to its reason.

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Barnes, B., Conrad, k., Demont-Heinrich, C., Graziano, M., Kowalski, D., Neufeld, J.,

Zamora, J. & Palmquist, M. (2005). Generalizability and Transferability. Retrieved from http://writing.colostate.edu/guides/research/gentrans/pop2f.cfm

Hathaway, R. (1995). Assumptions underlying quantitative and qualitative research:

Implications for institutional research. Research in higher education, 36 (5), p. 535-
Methodologies. (2011). Retrieved from http://onlineqda.hud.ac.uk/methodologies.php
Retrieved from http://www.uta.fi/~lisaka/LISR%5B1%5D.pdf


Cite this Document:

"Frame Analysis Vs Quantitative Frame" (2012, May 25) Retrieved April 19, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/frame-analysis-vs-quantitative-frame-58296

"Frame Analysis Vs Quantitative Frame" 25 May 2012. Web.19 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/frame-analysis-vs-quantitative-frame-58296>

"Frame Analysis Vs Quantitative Frame", 25 May 2012, Accessed.19 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/frame-analysis-vs-quantitative-frame-58296

Related Documents

Another significant similarity between frame and discourse analyses is that they both generally use qualitative methods of data reduction and presentation. This is in comparison to quantitative analysis, which is more objective and generally presents group rather than individual data. This can make it difficult to apply what it learned to a broader group of people, because they are looking at specific information for different people. This does not mean

Frame, M.W., (2001). The Spiritual Genogram in Training and Supervision. The Family Journal. 9 (109): Retrieved from: http://www.sagepub.com/thomas2e / study/articles/section4/Article87.pdf When dealing with family counselling issues, spiritual issues often arise depending on the culture and belief systems of the individual or family. Often it is beneficial to have an understanding of the entire family structure -- which can be tailored to meet the needs of the specific professional (medical, social,

For the modern military, command is more an art than a science, but certainly has characteristics of both. The "art of command" requires performance of highly tuned leadership skills combined with intuition and a sense of direction that, most often, cannot be gained through only study or education. Command also requires a conscious exercise of authority so that responsibilities of decision making and leadership can be controlled through delegation

Organization Analysis Analysing Organisation: Using relevant theoretical perspectives frameworks, critically analyse organisation choice. Analyzing organization is the process of assessing the organizations systems, functionality and capacity so as to increase the organizations performance, efficiency and overall output. This is done by using various theories and models whose aim is to understand the structure of the organization, technology and behavioral relationships Bate, Khan, & Pye, 2000. This should be a periodic and detailed activity

Technical Analysis in the Implication of Efficient Market Hypothesis on Silver Market The thesis is for the study of simple commonly used technical trading rules, which are applied on silver market. It covers years 1989 to 2005. A famous study carried out by Lakonishok, LebaRon and in year, 1992 has clearly shown that technical analysis can lead to abnormal prices when compared with buy-and-hold strategy. Other studies have been carried out

These findings are consistent with what one might expect from a case study analysis, which typically produces anecdotal evidence that can be scanned for generalized knowledge about the issue. In that respect, Vargas succeeds with his study. A contrasting study comes from Lukas (2008) who argues why EVA does not work. He argues that EVA is not likely to succeed as a standalone technique. Instead, he notes, it needs to