Organizational Decision-Making Mcdonald's Reevaluation of Term Paper

Download this Term Paper in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Term Paper:

After all, the company rationalized that new menu items had always been a part of McDonald's innovative image, and keeping on the cutting edge of restaurant trends, as had been the case with the introduction of its innovative breakfast sandwich items like the Egg McMuffin in 1976 and Chicken McNuggets in 1980 ("McDonald's Case Study,"2008).

Effectiveness of the Decision-Making Process

One problem with initiating changes like the "Made for You" campaign in the fast food industry is that customers are not always cognizant that the changes have occurred, as they are not usually connoisseurs of the food, only apprehending vaguely a decline or improvement in quality. "It seems a little bit better," observed one consumer when prompted by a reporter, noting "the bacon looks like it's just been cooked." Another frequent McDonald's patron was more complementary: "it seems like the Quarter Pounder is juicier," declared Rosemary Frigo, a nurse from Downers Grove, Ill., as she devoured an Extra Value Meal at the McDonald's in nearby Darien. 'The Quarter Pounder used to be thrown in the microwave sometimes and they would overcook the meat,' she added" (Canedy 1998). Still, there was the embarrassment of the similarity to Burger King's famous slogan that customers could 'have it their way,' a problem not apparently anticipated in McDonald's harmonious decision-making process (most of the top level management had agreed to undertake the change without much debate). Upon the "Made for You" campaign launch, Burger King crowed "that in letting customers choose their trimmings," McDonald's has essentially adopted the approach that it has long touted under its slogan, "Have it your way" and Burger King spokespersons openly forecasted that the new campaign would generate unintended publicity for Burger King, not cause customers to return to McDonald's (Canedy 1998).

Yet McDonald's brand proved more durable than Burger King would like to have believed. Food cost savings came even swifter than expected -- at one Manhattan McDonald's, food wastage costs "declined by about $100 a month" while sales increased 7% in the year that the outlet has been using the new system. Less successful in the new campaign were the new menu items based upon the competition. The lesson learned was this: customers did not notice or care that the new delivery and assembly model was inspired by Burger King. However, they did care if the new menu items seemed like imitations of Burger King originals like the Whopper and did not 'bite' at the new offerings, wisely thinking that they would go to the original source, rather than sample McDonald's knock-off. Unlike the truly innovative Egg McMuffin, which brought hot breakfasts to a once breakfast-phobic, cereal eating nation, the Whopper imitation fell flat. There was nothing new about the Big Extra's taste or presentation, fundamentally, unlike the earlier introduction of Chicken McNuggets. Interestingly, when Burger King created a burger with mayonnaise to challenge the Big Mac's ascendency on the front of 'special sauce' or mayo-laded burgers, it was also ignored by Burger King and McDonald's loyalists alike (Canady 1998).

Reflect on your own decision-making process

The lessons of McDonald's may seem to be contradictory -- McDonald's gained a huge payoff and competitive advantage, instituted substantial savings, and experienced less difficulties than anticipated with a 'pull' generated system of hamburger assembling, driven by demand, rather than its usual push system which anticipated demand and held the burgers for too long. Yet its other imitated decision, inspired by Burger King, to introduce new menu offerings similar to that of its rival did little to rehabilitate the company's fortunes. Why? McDonald's had to remain true to itself, to its expected offerings and to its image of offering good-tasting, fast food Learning from Burger King's supply chain did not impinge upon McDonald's brand integrity, shamelessly copying the Whopper did.

McDonald's should learn from these lessons of its recent past. Burger King is once again gaining ground in the eternal 'Burger Wars' of the fast food industry. Acknowledging McDonald's unparalleled dominance in marketing to children and its exclusive advertising campaigns with Disney, Mattel, and Barbie, amongst other popular toys and media outlets popular with kids Burger King is creating its own market base (Buscemi 2007). Burger King, by allowing McDonald's dominance in the younger demographic of consumer and not expending its scarce resources in this area, has turned its eyes to older teenagers and adults, through such off-beat advertising campaigns as the "subservient chicken" the "Creepy King" and promotions involving Xbox games (Buscemi 2007). It has refined its own branding and created a unique niche in doing so, thus making itself a rival for the Golden Arches and also not generating negative publicity about 'pandering' to children.

Burger King has also remained truer to the traditional concerns of the adult fast food consumer for taste over health. After all, a nutritional comparison of the most famous competing menu items yields the following data: the Big Mac looks relatively paltry to the Whopper. While neither burger of either food chain could claim to be "part of a healthy, balanced diet," the Big Mac, weighs in at 540 calories, 29 grams of fat, and 45 grams of carbohydrates, and already contains slices of cheese, while the Whopper, boasts 670 calories, 39 grams of fat, and 51 grams of carbohydrates without the additional, but frequently requested additional cheese (Buscemi 2007). "McDonald's has been advertising their salads, looking to appease the mothers who bring their children into the golden-arched restaurants," but Burger King, acknowledging that it is never going to win any dietary prizes, "has gone the other direction, promoting the Stacker sandwich, a sandwich made of layers of meat and cheese stacking up to four burgers high" (Buscemi 2007).

The lessons to be learned are to stay true to one's brand name and values, whatever these values may be. Innovation in presentation if they result in added speed, savings, and quality improvement, even when these models are based upon observing the competition is acceptable. Fundamentally altering as tried and true a brand name as McDonald's, however, is another thing entirely. Decision-making processes can involve learning from the competition, but learning does not mean obscuring one's fundamental organizational values and mission, and subverting customer expectations.

Works Cited

Barett, Larry. "McBusted." Baseline. Jul 2, 2002. Jul 15, 2008

Buscemi, Eric. "McDonald's vs. Burger King: Battle of the Brands." Blogging Stocks. Apr 9, 2007. Jul 15, 2008. p:/ /

Burger King." Official Website. Jul 15, 2008.

Canedy, Dana. "McDonald's burger war salvo: Is 'Made for You' the way folks want to have it?"

The New York Times. Jun 20, 1998. Jul 15, 2008.

Changes at McDonald's after taste test." The New York Times. Dec 26, 1996. Jul 15, 2008.

McDonald's." Business Case Studies. The Times 100. 2005. Jul 15, 2008. -- 28-273-1.php

McDonald's" Official Website. 17 Jul 2008.

McDonald's Case Study." 17 Jul 2008.

Supersize Me."…[continue]

Cite This Term Paper:

"Organizational Decision-Making Mcdonald's Reevaluation Of" (2008, July 16) Retrieved November 28, 2016, from

"Organizational Decision-Making Mcdonald's Reevaluation Of" 16 July 2008. Web.28 November. 2016. <>

"Organizational Decision-Making Mcdonald's Reevaluation Of", 16 July 2008, Accessed.28 November. 2016,

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Mcdonald s Case Analysis Report Case

    Since the "Made for you" production process has been tested and assured to be a workable process for McDonald's this should be implemented on a storewide basis despite the huge upfront expenses to be incurred by the company. These upfront expenses will be compensated by the huge returns and improvements in quality of customer service that come from the company's use of this new production system Hall, Rosenthal, &

  • Social Business and the Retailer

    Social Media Retailing Applications: Opportunities and Threats How Has Social Media Developed and What are the Benefits and Downsides of Using Social Media for Retailers Today? This study examines social business in general, how it developed and the benefits of using social media in particular. Second, this study provides a discussion concerning the potential positive as well as the effects of social business in the retail sector which is followed by a

  • Application of DNA in California in Criminal Cases

    DNA in Criminal Cases - Solving Cold Cases in California with Forensic Science This research will attempt to analyze and discuss the feasibility of DNA testing in solving cold cases and will study the impact that DNA fingerprinting has had on the forensic science community as a whole. DNA is generally used to solve crimes in one of two ways. In cases where a suspect is identified, a sample of that person's

  • Marketing Plan Mission and Business Objective Products

    Marketing Plan Mission and Business Objective Products and Services Keys to Success Macro Environment Economic Value Added Cash Value Added Cash Flow Return on Investment This report is a detailed marketing plan for a new financial service company called Online Analyst, Inc. The company is a combination database management company that also specializes in the financial services markets. The company will offer a plethora of information, data and financial-based market services such as online real time market segment

  • Organisational Psychology This Chapter Reviews the Literature

    Organisational Psychology This chapter reviews the literature and research outcomes within which the current research is located. It identifies the theory currently in use and sets the theoretical context for the study. Emotions and feelings shape and lubricate social transactions and in this way emotions contribute to, and reflect, the structure and culture of organizations. Order and control, the very essence of the 'organization' of work, concern what people 'do' with their

  • Sizes Are Faced With Many

    42). In the context of higher education, then, redefining mission statements to reflect this wide range of influences requires a balancing act between the interests of all of the stakeholders involved. This not a static, one-time analysis, either, but requires constant reevaluation to ensure that the educational institution is delivering the type of graduates with the skill set needed in the 21st century workplace. For instance, Berg et al. (2008)

Read Full Term Paper
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved