P a Car Salesman Is Advertising One Essay

Download this Essay in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Essay:

P, a car salesman, is advertising one of his cars, made by Ferrari for sale at the price of € 50000 in the newspaper. N see the advertisement and calls to P. offering him €40000. P rejects N's offer and tell N. that he would be willing to discuss an offer for 45000. N agrees on the price but under the condition that P. proves to her that the car is indeed a genuine Ferrari. P promises to disclose all necessary documents in the next 3 weeks. N agrees and waits. Two weeks later N. discovers that P. has sold the car to C. For 50000. Advise N.

In order to advise N, it is critical to analyze the terms of the case.The case is clearly a case of an offer and verbal acceptance.This is a practical case of a unilateral offer. Before proceeding, we can discuss the concepts of a unilateral and bilateral offer. Richards (2010) noted that a bilateral offer is the kind of an offer that arises when one party promises to fulfill or do something in return for another promise that is made by the offeree. In this case, both parties are essentially agreeing to accomplish something in return for a given promise made by the offeree. In other words, both parties are agreeing to accomplish something in return for some other reciprocal promise from the other party. For instance, if N. promises to sell their house in return for B. promising to pay £6,000. A large number of offers are of this particular type. A unilateral offer on the other hand occurs whenever a given party, hereby referred to as the offeror, expressly promises to pay for the act of the other party, in this case we mean a conditional promise. In this case, we see that N. agrees on the price but under the condition that P. proves to her that the car is indeed a genuine Ferrari.This makes this a unilateral offer since it is only one side that promises to buy after her conditions are fulfilled.As Koerner (1958,p.1016) noted, newspaper advertisements can be considered as an offer to sell a product.As was the case in the Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co (1893) case, advertisements can indeed mount into an offer.

It is worth noting that most advertisements never qualify to be offers.Instead, they qualify to be statements inviting other for further negotiations. This is called invitation to treat. A perfect example is the Partridge v Crittenden [1968]

case. In this particular case, the appellants put up an advertisement in a bird fanciers' periodicall and stated that 'Bramblefinch cocks and hens 25s'.They were however charged under the nations' Protection of Birds Act 1954, section 6 (1).Initially, the appellants were convicted but after appealing, their conviction was squashed by the state's Division Court. This particular decision is inline with an earlier decision in the case of Harris v Nickerson in which an auctioneer duly advertised that some specific goods would be on sale in a certain location on a given date. However, the plaintiff went to the much advertised sale only to find that all of the lots that he was interested in were all withdrawn. He then proceeded to sue the auctioneer for his loss of expenses and time. It was held by the courts that the claim failed since the auctioneer's advertisement was merely an clear case of declaration of intent to hold a sale and therefore never amounted to an offer that is capable of being accepted and could never form a basis of a binding agreement/contract. This advertisement therefore amounted to a mere invitation to treat.N must therefore know that the advertisement by P. could indeed be treated as an invitation to treat since it never amounted to an offer. What could have made it to amount to an offer is his verbal confirmation that he would accept to discuss the €45000 that N. proposed. The offer to discuss the situation therefore is a further fact to indicate that indeed this case was an invitation to treat and further negotiation was necessary.N can therefore not succeed to suing P. On the claims that he never honored his part of the bargain since what P. suggested was a chance for further negotiations. This chance for further negotiations is what is referred to as an invitation to treat.

Whenever a product in very large quantities is duly advertised in a poster or newspaper then generally, it is not considered an offer. It is however treated as an invitation to treat because there is no guarantee that the offerer might provide the given item to any individual that might need one. This argument was the basis of the decision in the case, Partridge v. Crittenden.


Harris v Nickerson (1873) LR 8 QB 286,

Koerner, TG (1958). Contracts: Offer and Acceptance: Newspaper Advertisement as Offer to Sell. Michigan Law Review Vol. 56, No. 6 (Apr., 1958), pp. 1016-1019

Partridge v Crittenden [1968] 2 All ER 421

Richards, P (2010). Law of Contract,9th edition.Pearsons

The importance of the Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co (1893) case ?

The Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Co (1893) case is of great importance in contract law since it specifically highlights the meaning of an offer as part of a contract. Before delving deeper into the basics and implication of the case (case analysis), it is important for the facts of the case to be presented.

Facts of the Case

In this particular case, the plaintiff (Mrs. Carlil) bought a certain product called 'The Carbolic Smoke Ball' ( a supposed cure for influenza cold and such like ailments) from the defendant (Carbolic Smoke Ball Co) on the basis of the promise by the defendant's advertisement that they would promptly pay £100 ( a large sum of money at that time) to any customer who contracted influenza after using the product as prescribed and for a certain period of time. As a 'show of their sincerity', the defendant indicated that they had in turn deposited a total of £1,000 with the Alliance Bank, located at Regent Street.

The plaintiff bought the smoke balls and then used it according to the prescription but in an unfortunate twist of events, caught influenza. She then sued the Carbolic Smoke Ball Co for the originally advertised amount -£100. However, the defendant argued that the advertisement was not to be taken as a serious and legally binding offer.The defendant therefore maintained that there was no form of agreement between them and the plaintiff and then used a considerable level of ingenuity in trying to promote this argument and contention.

One of the defenses employed was that it was ever possible to make an offer to the 'whole world' since that would in essence enable the whole world to effectively accept the offer; a scenario which was beyond the limits of commercial reality. This defense was easily rejected by the Court of Appeal when Bowen LJ indicated that position very clearly by saying that;

"It was also said that the contract is made with the whole world -- that is, with everybody and that you cannot contract with everybody. It is not a contract made with all the world. There is the fallacy of the argument. It is an offer made to all the world; and why should not an offer be made to all the world which is to ripen into a contract with anybody who comes forward and performs the condition? . . . Although the offer is made to the world, the contract is made with that limited portion of the public who come forward and perform the condition on the faith of the advertisement." (Richards,2010,p.16)

The defendants also argued that the plaintiff never accepted their offer and therefore no consensus…[continue]

Cite This Essay:

"P A Car Salesman Is Advertising One" (2012, November 20) Retrieved October 21, 2016, from http://www.paperdue.com/essay/p-a-car-alesman-is-advertising-one-83143

"P A Car Salesman Is Advertising One" 20 November 2012. Web.21 October. 2016. <http://www.paperdue.com/essay/p-a-car-alesman-is-advertising-one-83143>

"P A Car Salesman Is Advertising One", 20 November 2012, Accessed.21 October. 2016, http://www.paperdue.com/essay/p-a-car-alesman-is-advertising-one-83143

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Five Year Career Plan a Clear

    Identification of three action steps to reaching stated career goals and objectives In order to achieve my ultimate five-year career goal of opening my own business, I need to complete many different tasks to get to where I eventually want to be. As part of my overall business plan, I need to obtain funding (a recent article itemizes the costs to be between $150k to $240k just to get going

  • Selling American Used Cars in

    Customer Roles At least three customer roles are needed for a marketplace transaction: (Ibid) 1. Buying, choosing a particular product or service; 2. Closing sale by paying for product or service; 3. Consuming or using product or service. Subsequently, one customer may be a buyer, a payer, or a user; or each of these roles may be filled by an organization; various individuals; or different departments. During the process of transforming a showroom visitor to

  • Bribing Unethical and Illegal or Just a

    bribing" unethical and illegal or just a cost of doing business? Bribery is unethical and illegal in some societies and a regular part of business in others. Whether or not an activity is unethical is largely dependent on the culture, customs, norms, values, and laws of the country where the activity takes place. It's a matter of perspective. When you consider that the act of bribery is intended to supplement

  • Marketing Involvement Consumer Involvement Refers to the

    Marketing Involvement Consumer involvement refers to the amount of time, though and energy that a consumer puts into a particular purchase decision (McNamara, 2014). This can be categorized along the emotional/rational scale. So many small purchases like impulse purchases are low involvement. At the very low involvement end of the scale is something like fries with your burger -- you might not even want them, and accept the suggestion for them almost

  • Business Environment in Japan BMW Group Business

    Business Environment in Japan BMW Group) Business Environment of Japan History of BMW in Japan Competitors Sales volume statistics Political and Legal Environment of Japan Barriers of entry for foreign-owned companies Safety and environmental issues Cultural environment of Japan Customer demographics BMW marketing strategy The BMW Group has enjoyed immeasurable success in the Japanese market through ambition, determination, the appointment of several clever key people, comprehensive research undertaken on the nature of the Japanese political, business and cultural environment, and a

  • Impact of Likeability in Management

    likeability is effected by management in the international workplace. It assumes a phenomenological approach to the notion of likeability, and is based on the idea that likeability in management is fundamental to achieving "connectedness" among employees and to inspiring the drive needed to ensure an organization's success. By conducting a survey of employees and managers from every major business continent of the globe (Asia, Europe, America, the Middle East),

  • Marketing Explain Why and How

    Over the course of time, as others on the sales team see that one person is engaging in such actions, they will do the same. This creates an atmosphere, of corruption within an organization, where a large number of people will engage in questionable activities to achieve their objectives. A good example of this can be seen with Enron, during the boom years, when the company stressed that they

Read Full Essay
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved