Sign Up Now
Get instant access to over 1 million+ study documents
OR
Already registered? click here to login
By creating your account, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and student honor code.
Atwater v. City of Lago Vista
Supreme Court's decision in Atwater v. City of Lago Vista (Atwater v. City of Lago Vista, 2001) has been highly criticized. Interestingly, the case has been criticized by conservatives and liberals alike. Even for the most ardent law and order advocate, the fact that the Court ratified the authority of the police to jail someone for what was a fine-only offense. The potential for abuse by allowing such process means that the police are now free to arrest and search any person and their vehicle driving on public streets and highways. Atwater represented a further expansion of police authority in regard to traffic stops and essentially has opened the way for police officers to arrest individuals for very minor offenses in order to open the door for investigating more serious crimes for which they would otherwise not have authority to arrest. The potential for abuse should be obvious in that nearly every time any given driver takes to the road some minor traffic law is violated. Given the broad powers afforded...
In essence, the Atwater decision has removed the element of probable cause from the arrest and detention process at least as it pertains to vehicle stops.
In light of the profound possibility for abuse following the Supreme Court's decision in Atwater, it is difficult to understand how the Court could have considered such procedure to "reasonable" as required by the Fourth Amendment. As argued in the strong dissent presented Justice O'Connor, the majority's decision in Atwater was a "pointless indignity' that served no discernible state interest (Atwater: p.360.)." In the final analysis, Atwater is bad case law that has expanded police authority beyond the limits of fairness and represents an infringement on the Fourth Amendment rights of every American citizen.
2. Consensual Search
Traditionally, valid consent for a legal search…
References
Atwater v. City of Lago Vista, 532 U.S. 318 (U.S. Supreme Court 2001).
U.S.V. Matlock, 415 U.S. 164 (U.S. Supreme Court 1974).
Criminal Evidence and Procedure
Disadvantages of police discretion The blanket use of discretion can result in repressive tactics being utilized against suspected criminals. If the police department refrains from guiding and controlling the use of this authority, abuses as well as extreme disparities can occur. Where, various individuals could become corrupted from the large amounts of authority they are given. As they could begin seeking out special favors (bribes / kickbacks) or they could use
Mooching: Undermining Police Authority For the most part, it would be exceedingly difficult to prove that specific acts of mooching and chiseling -- or of these practices in general -- actually undermine the effectiveness for police officers to carry out their duty -- which is primarily regarded as a charge to protect and serve the general well-being of society at large. Generally speaking, mooching and chiseling can be considered independent acts
The fact that it is neither arbitrary nor motivated by atavistic animosity in a vacuum distinguishes this type of infringement from those that are absolutely impermissible in principle. Conclusion: In a wider perspective, the issue of police profiling is merely one type of constitutionally impermissible tactics that may require re-evaluation under the exigent circumstances posed by the prospect of continued domestic terrorism. More than one renowned legal authority (Dershowitz 2002) has
Police Misconduct Case Study The district attorney declines to press charges and both juveniles are released. They flee the jurisdiction and are never found. Your partner is brought before a police investigation Board and suspended from the Department after 20 years service. Justification for Answer Choice #1 The District Attorney (DA) had no choice but to drop the charges and release the suspects because my partners actions apparently violated one of the most
Police Recruiting Just like every other institution in the country, American policing system went through a long period of evolution to finally achieve the shape that it has today. And similar to other laws and institutions in America, even police recruitment methods were heavily borrowed from Britain. In the 19th century or at least for most part of it, American police was shaped after the British policing laws (O'Keefe, 2004). However
Police Ethics The research plan as outlined in the previous section is well on course and the outlined steps are relevant to the main objective of the research. There are however several challenges that are already being experienced. One of them is at section 1 where the types of sources to be used are to be identified. The difficulty is in classifying some sources like the police themselves among the sources