Positive Contributions and Negative Effects dissertation

Download this dissertation in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from dissertation:

Since 2005, hundreds of California state teachers have participated in this initiative and provided thousands of hours of English instruction to migrant students (Lomeli et al., 2006).

Given the wide array of resources that are available for after-school venues, it is not surprising that their numbers have increased in recent years with higher numbers of students participating each year, but the frequency of their operation also varies from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. Consequently, another measure of the successfulness of a given after-school program for migrant students is its frequency. According to Zhang and Byrd, "With such a variety of locations, the number of after-school programs has increased in all major urban areas, and youth participation in these programs strengthens every year. Indeed, it is currently estimated that approximately 25 to 30% of American youths spend between three and five afternoons each week in organized after-school programs" (2005, p. 6).

According to Dietal (2009), students participating in effective after-school programs that offer services three to five times a week achieve significantly higher math, science, and reading grades compared to nonparticipating peers and those students who participating in five or more of the activities offered by the after-school programs attained higher reading scores compared to nonparticipants as well as other after-school program participants who participated in fewer than five activities. Based on these findings, Dietal concludes that, "Measuring breadth of activities, together with intensity and duration, seems a worthwhile approach to future after-school evaluations" (2009, p. 63).

Another study by Frankel and Daly (2007) used attendance intervals in their evaluation of the Beyond the Bells Partner Agencies after-school program. These researchers identified a relationship between after-school attendance and higher scores in math and language arts, as well as attendance at regularly scheduled day-time school (Frankel & Daly, 2007). The after-school program, though, became ineffective when students failed to attend a minimum number of activities throughout the school year, with higher ineffectiveness rates for younger students (Frankel & Daly, 2007). For instance, elementary students who failed to attend at least 100 days' of after-school activities and middle-school students who failed to attend at least 50 days' worth of after-school activities did not achieve the higher scores in math and language arts identified in other program participants (Frankel & Daly, 2007).

Beyond the foregoing attributes of successful and unsuccessful after-school programs, it is also possible to gauge successful initiatives by determining their degree of responsiveness to the changing needs of their migrant students. In this regard, Zhang and Byrd emphasize that, "Although there is no single formula for establishing quality after-school programs, successful programs typically combine academic, recreational, physical, and artistic elements within a curriculum designed to engage youths in a variety of structured and supervised activities" (2005, p. 6).

One such after-school program that could be readily tailored to the needs of migrant students that has proven effectiveness is Project ESTRELLA (Encouraging Students through Technology to Reach High Expectations in Learning, Life skills, and Achievement); a 5-year initiative, Project ESTRELLA is among four other initiatives examining the efficacy of applying technology specifically to the problems faced by migrant students sponsored by the U.S. Department of Education's Office of Migration Education (Branz-Spall et al., 2002).

Although not an after-school program exclusively, the resources that are provided by Project ESTRELLA can be used in tandem with after-school programs or by the migrant students at home or elsewhere, including alone or with other students in migrant worker camps, school libraries or wherever migrant students are located in sufficient numbers (Branz-Spall et al., 2002). One of the most beneficial aspects of Project ESTRELLA is this flexibility in service delivery, as well as the fact that it provides coordination and continuity of service delivery wherever migrant students travel in the country (Branz-Spall et al., 2002).

The foregoing examples of characteristics of after-school programs can be further informed by the following indicators of effective and ineffective after-school programs provided by Table 1

Indicators of Effective and Ineffective After-School Programs

Effective After-School Program Indicators

Ineffective After-School Program Indicators

Presence of a program coordinator or committee to oversee implementation and resolution of day-to-day problems

Lack of knowledge about effective program delivery

Involvement of individuals with highly shared morale, good communication, and a sense of ownership

Poor quality of leadership and management

Employment of qualified personnel

Ineffective organizational structure

Ongoing processes of formal and informal training, including the involvement of knowledgeable experts

Poor quality and inadequacy of program staff

High inclusiveness of all school stakeholders

Inefficient and inappropriate financial management

High visibility in the school and the community

Poor communication and cooperation between the after-school program and the regular day-school program

Program components that explicitly foster mutual respect and support among students

Lack of active instructional components

Varied and engaging instructional approaches

Lack of performance measures

Linkage to stated goals of schools or districts

Imbalanced curriculum

Consistent support from school principals

Low program enrollment

Balance of support from both new and seasoned administrators

Lack of focus on program impact

Lack of cooperation with community organizations

Lack of parental and volunteer involvement

Lack of understanding for sustainability in resource adequacy

Source: Zhang & Byrd, 2005, p. 6

As can be readily discerned from the characteristics of ineffective after-school programs shown in Table 1 above, there is no "lack of lacks" but there are a number of attributes of effective programs that can be used as a set of best practices in the development and implementation of these initiatives based on the unique needs of the migrant students that are present at any given point in time. This means that in order to be as effective as possible, administrators of after-school programs for migrant students must make an ongoing effort to assess the individual needs of their participants as well as the pool of other migrant students who could benefit from participation in the program. Clearly, this is a challenging enterprise, but attracting new participants and retaining existing participants can be facilitated by providing curricular offerings that combined with recreational, sports or other "fun" activities.


Branz-Spall, A.M., Rosenthal, R. & Wright, A. (2003). Children of the road: Migrant students,

Our nation's most mobile population. The Journal of Negro Education, 72(1), 55-57.

Dietal, R. (2009). After-school programs: Finding the right dose -- if the dose of time and activity are right, after-school programs can impact student learning. Phi Delta Kappan,

91(3), 62-64.

Frankel, S. & Daley, G. (2007). An evaluation of after school programs provided by Beyond the Bell's partner agencies: Executive summary and synopsis of methodology and findings.

New York: Partnership for After School Education, Retrieved from www.pasesetter.


Garner, R., Zhao, Y. & Gillingham, M. (2002). Hanging out: Community-based after-school programs for children. Westport, CT: Bergin and Garvey.

Jones, T.S. & Compton, R. (2003). Kids working it out: Strategies and stories for making peace in our schools. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

Kail, R.V. (2005). Advances in child development and behavior. New York: Academic Press.

Lomeli, J., Parks, J., Basurto, I. & Padilla, F. (2006). California Mini-Corps: Developing quality teachers for 40 years. Education, 127(1), 100-103.

Soukup, G.J., Schilling, E., Stelzer J. et al. (2006). Should after-school programs be structured as an extension of the school day?…[continue]


  • Positive and Negative Effects of

    (Economic Impacts of Tourism: United Nations Environment Program) The development of the tourism industry could cost the local government as well as local taxpayers a huge amount of money. The government resources being utilized on developing the airport, roads as well as other infrastructure or providing tax breaks for developing the tourism industry could enable the government to minimize their investment in other important sectors like education as also health

  • Military Stereotyping the Negative Effects

    This situation can be somewhat complex, as an individual is likely to be placed in a position where their own skill set will be put to efficient use, meaning that their capabilities often (and ideally always) match the position and designation they have (USAI 2009). This means that perceptions of an individual's capabilities based on his or her MOS is likely at least partially rooted in truth, but that

  • Causes and Effects of Environmental Degradation

    negative effects of degradation of the environment. It will first discuss human population as a cause for environmental degradation by also relating to afferent effects. It will then bring into equation urbanization and industrialization which are closely linked. Ultimately, the general effects of global warming, as both a cause and an effect in itself, will be considered. Key terms: environment, population density, urbanization, industrialization, global warming. Man has impacted the environment

  • Effect of Socio Cultural Factors on Online Buyer Behavior

    Socio Cultural Aspects on Online Buying Behavior In world of today, survival without internet is extremely difficult as internet serves as an efficient and effective way of communication globally. Earlier when internet was introduced, the focus was mainly to communicate with the people or organizations across the globe. The main purpose was to quicken the process of communication and to enhance the communicating opportunities for businesses in order to improve

  • Effect of Downsizing on Manufacturing Industries

    downsizing on Manufacturing Industries The amount of information on the effects of down sizing on manufacturing was not plentiful, however one main point that flows through all of the articles is that even though down sizing may be done to help a company it can end up hurting them in the long run. In the paragraphs to follow we look at the effects that downsizing has on people and companies

  • Effects of Employee Stock Ownership Plans on Employees Since September...

    Employee Stock Ownership on Employees in the Airlines Industry since September 11th. Review current materials on the issue. Airline industry ESOPs tend to be very volatile. This paper will examine the effects of the September 11th tragedy on employees' employee stock ownership plans in the airlines industry. The following generic information is provided for background before examining the main issue for this paper. In the United States, the main vehicle for employee ownership

  • Global Change Science the Negative

    As the road is being laid the fumes from the chemical materials and the concussive force of the construction equipment are devastating to local wildlife (Forman & Alexander, 1998). The result, is displaced organisms which ultimately put increased pressure for food, land, and water on other ecosystems. The extent of these ripple effects are still yet to be fully known. In instances where above or below ground water supplies must

Cite This Paper:

"Positive Contributions And Negative Effects" (2011, June 23) Retrieved October 20, 2016, from http://www.paperdue.com/essay/positive-contributions-and-negative-effects-42724

"Positive Contributions And Negative Effects" 23 June 2011. Web.20 October. 2016. <http://www.paperdue.com/essay/positive-contributions-and-negative-effects-42724>

"Positive Contributions And Negative Effects", 23 June 2011, Accessed.20 October. 2016, http://www.paperdue.com/essay/positive-contributions-and-negative-effects-42724

Leave a Comment

Register now or post as guest, members login to their existing accounts to post comment.

Read Full Dissertation
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved