Sign Up Now
Get instant access to over 1 million+ study documents
OR
Already registered? click here to login
By creating your account, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and student honor code.
Public vs. Private Sector Unions
Public and Private Sector Unions
Collective bargaining in public sector is a recent phenomenon that became common in 1960 and started gaining momentum at the time when unionism in private sector was slowly declining (Reilly, 2012). Changes in the government policies and the legal requirements made the way for the increasing unionism in the public sector. There has always been a debate regarding the issue if private and public sector unions are same; however, Troy (2003) states that public sector bargaining is not the extension of bargaining in the private sector. This paper will answer the problem statement " Are there more similarities or differences between the public sector unions and the private sector unions" by comparing and contrasting the key similarities and key differences between the private sector and public sector unions and labor relations.
Background Information
It is very essential to know the difference between private and public sector in order to understand the similarities and differences between the private and public sector unions. The private sector is composed of the organizations that are owned and run privately. These include all profit and non-profit corporations and partnerships that are not owned by the government in any way. For instance, local businesses, super stores, credit unions and all other organizations operating in the private sector.
The public sector on the other side is composed of all organizations owned and run by government. These organizations are the public authority and include federal, state, provincial, and municipal governments depending upon the structure of the place. For example, police, government educational institutes, government hospitals, prison services etc.
Key Similarities: Public Vs Private Sector Unions
Along with many differences that will be discussed later in this paper; following are some of the key similarities...
. Therefore, public sectors often hire staff that has experience in the private sector experience. Hence many of the participants of in public sector bargaining are actually trained and gained experience from the private sector (Holley, Jennings and Wolters, 2011).
Employees in the private organizations, join unions when they are not satisfied with the terms and conditions of employment. For instance, if they have issues with the workload, supervision, promotions for which they cannot fight individually. Similar is the case of public sector; employees join unions then they consider union as an institution that can solve their job problems and bring positive outcomes. In fact, public sector employees have more favorable attitude towards union, due to their perception that public managers are less hostile compared to the private sector managers.
The collective bargaining settlements are very much influenced by the persons who participate in the negotiations due to their abilities to increase the bargaining power in front of the opposite party. Therefore, employees of public as well as private sector join unions in order to increase the bargaining power " over the opponent by either increasing the cost to the opponent of disagreeing or reducing the cost to the opponent of agreeing" (Holley, Jennings and Wolters, 2011, p.590). This issue is even more critical in case of public organizations as the public opinion is considered as a very important cost in public sector labor relations.
The private sector unions and the public sector unions, both work for improving the working conditions of employees and increasing their wages.
Key Differences: Public Vs Private Sector Unions
Unlike the case…
References
Belman, D., Gunderson, M and Hyatt, D. (1996). Public Sector Employment in a time of Transition.
Industrial Relations Research Association
Holley, W., Jennings, K., Wolters, R. (2011). The Labor Relations Process, 10th Edition, South Western
Cengage Learning.
Public and Private Sector Unions? More than 200 members of the U.S. House of Representatives and U.S. Senate have in recent times supported the Employee Free Choice Act to permit workers the freedom of choice to develop unions. The consequences of the support surrounding the legislation and the larger concentration on the economy and workforce-related issues have made the right of workers and unions the topic of many discussions across
First Flanagan offers four hypotheses: one, changes in the structure of the American economy "favor nonunion over union employment"; two, union organization is less intense than it was; three, workers' interest in general has tapered off with reference to unions; and four, management vigorously opposes unions in many instances (Flanagan, 2005, p. 33). Adding to that list, Flanagan asserts that many companies have adopted "human resource management policies" that
Public Sector Unions Public-Sector Unions in United States HISTORY OF PUBLIC SECTOR UNIONS COSTS OF PUBLIC SECTOR UNIONS OVER THEIR BENEFITS DEMOGRAPHICS OF LABOR IN AMERICA EDGE OF PUBLIC-SECTOR UNIONS OVER PRIVATE ONES THE HIDDEN COSTS OF PUBLIC UNIONS THE DISTORTION OF DEMOCRATIC POLITICS STATE UNIONS VS. FEDERAL UNIONS THE FUTURE OF PUBLIC SECTOR UNIONIZATION HISTORY OF PUBLIC SECTOR UNIONS Labor unions are seen as the representatives of the labor employed in our industries and are known as the advocates of
Labor Relations and Collective Bargaining What is European Union's Social Charter The Social Charter of Europe is a treaty by the European Council which guarantees fundamental economic and social freedoms. It is an equivalent of the European Human Rights Convention, which deals with political and civil freedoms. It guards a wide range of day-to-day freedoms of human beings that have to do with education, housing, social welfare and protection, employment and health.
They also stand to receive more from collective bargaining arrangements, because they are often negotiating with public officials who have a direct role in allocating funds for projects and salaries, versus the private sector, where wages and demand for labor is highly influenced by consumer demand. Private sector employees also know if that if they bargain too hard, the competitive nature of their organization may be compromised. In Chapter 2
Kuwait labor market is one of the major components of the country's economy and has played a significant role in current economic problems in the country. Since the beginning of the oil era in Kuwait, the country has increasingly relied on a growing workforce (labor market) across all sectors of the economy. Given the role of the labor market in the nation's economic growth and development, understanding the major issues