Regulatory Ethics When Evaluating the Research Paper

Download this Research Paper in word format (.doc)

Note: Sample below may appear distorted but all corresponding word document files contain proper formatting

Excerpt from Research Paper:

This is a major oversight because as stated above, one of the areas in which the use of former SEC officials seems to have been most successful is in the securing of waivers and releases. In leaving out these areas, the prime evidence in support of the revolving door demonstrates itself to be woefully inadequate. In contrast, the POGO report details a number of problems with this earlier academic study while demonstrating that some of the things the academic study tried to downplay, such as the SEC's tendency to settle rather than pursue charges to their fullest, are actually evidence of SEC regulation being affected by its close relationship with the industry it is meant to regulate (POGO, 2013, p. 28).

The study's findings are persuasive precisely because they are so comprehensive in their dismantling of the primary academic justification of the revolving door. By demonstrating the critical errors in the primary piece of evidence used in support of the notion that the revolving door does not affect regulation, the POGO report manages to simultaneously draw attention to worrisome trends within the SEC as a whole while demonstrating that the stated justifications for those trends do not hold up when scrutinized closely. The Corporate Crime Reporter's coverage of the POGO report manages to convey this fact effectively, because it summarizes many of the major points of the study while augmenting it with an author interview.

In particular, the Corporate Crime Reporter largely got its coverage of the report right because it was careful to highlight the study's goals, methods, and conclusions without either assuming too much or attempting to claim that the report said something it did not. For example, the news report was careful to highlight that the study did not claim that specific SEC employees were intentionally downgrading regulatory enforcement in an effort to secure lucrative private sector jobs, but instead was geared towards demonstrating how the culture as a whole contributed to an environment of relaxed regulatory efforts (Corporate Crime Reporter, 2013). This kind of accurate reporting is necessary when discussing issues of government accountability, because misrepresenting either the extent of possible malfeasance or conflicts of interests can ultimately serve to undermine efforts at reform by making it easier to accuse reformers of relying on straw man arguments and hyperbole. By ensuring accurate reporting, it is much easier to go forward with reform efforts, because the empirical justifications for those reforms cannot be as easily challenged.

By analyzing the Project on Government Oversight's study on the revolving door between the SEC and the industries it is supposed to regulate, one is able to not only learn more about the problems facing government regulators, but also gain some insight into how the proper research methodologies can contribute to effective, insightful reporting. The POGO report relied on secondary data provided via Freedom of Information Act requests on top of interviews with former and current SEC officials, and the combined use of these different methods of data acquisition allowed the report to provide a much clearer, broader picture of the regulatory environment than has been previously possible. In particular, the POGO report managed to demonstrate the critical gaps in previous examinations of the revolving door issue and highlight the way in which the granting of waivers and releases serves to diminish the SEC's regulatory capabilities. Furthermore, examining the news coverage of POGO's report served to demonstrate the need for clear, accurate reporting on issues such as this, because it is necessary for this research to be accurately presented if the general public is going to be privy to the kind of insights previously only held by specialists and analysts. The POGO report and its attendant coverage are a good example of the need for rigorous analysis and reporting when it comes to government accountability.


Assistant Comptroller General. General Accounting Office, General Government Division.

(2000). Studies helped agencies measure or explain program performance. Washington,


Corporate Crime Reporter. (2013, February 21). Pogo on sec's revolving door. Retrieved from

Project on Government Oversight. (2013). Dangerous liaisons: Revolving door at sec creates risk of regulatory capture. (pp. 1-39). Washington, DC.: Project on Government


U.S. General Accounting Office, General Government Division. (2003). Data Collection

Methods. Washington, DC.

U.S. Government Accountability Office, Center for Evaluation Methods and Issues. (2013).

Information resources on program evaluation. Washington, DC.

Wholey, J., Hatry, H.,…[continue]

Some Sources Used in Document:


Cite This Research Paper:

"Regulatory Ethics When Evaluating The" (2013, March 19) Retrieved December 3, 2016, from

"Regulatory Ethics When Evaluating The" 19 March 2013. Web.3 December. 2016. <>

"Regulatory Ethics When Evaluating The", 19 March 2013, Accessed.3 December. 2016,

Other Documents Pertaining To This Topic

  • Ethics and Regulatory Issues Related Party Transactions

    Ethics and Regulatory Issues Related party transactions reported on by Arthur Andersen & Co. Flaw in the accounting firm's logic Checklist for special projects performed by external auditors Checklist Proposed rules or laws to prevent similar occurrences Enron was one of the Wall Street's favorite blue chip stocks before an accounting scandal of the firm surfaced in 2000. The revelation that company has been misreporting its profits and losses during 1990s crashed the company's stock. The

  • Ethics Take it From the Top

    Ethics: Take it From the Top Ethics take it from the Top The essay "Ethics: Take It from the Top" is written by Maynard Dolecheck and Carolyn Dolecheck, who discussed the problem of unethical business practices and suggested some solutions to eliminate it. As the name indicates, the authors suggested that ethics must be followed by the top-level management so that the low level employees follow them without any fear. According to

  • Ethics Corporate Governance & Business Ethics it

    Ethics Corporate Governance & Business Ethics It is quite interesting to note that, academic research in business ethics was a totally distinct discipline from research in corporate governance, and the application of the word 'ethics' was uncommon in available research on corporate governance. The chief responsibility of corporate governance was understood to be safeguarding the benefits of the shareholders. Because of the severance between ownership and management, and the incapability of the

  • Ethics Corporate Governance and Company Social Responsibility

    Ethics, Corporate Governance and Company Social Responsibility Information that is essential to share includes financial performance, business strategy and overall company actions (Pfeffer, 1998). Sharing this information gives the employees the power to evaluate their performance and help them make the right decisions on how they can improve it. This is a simple and very straightforward practice but most companies are still apprehensive about this practice. One cause for this is

  • Changes in US Business Ethics Practices Since Sept 11 2001

    Business Ethics Changes in U.S. Business Ethics Practices Changes in U.S. Business Ethics Practices Since Sep 11, 2001 The incident of 9/11 made the world pass though many sad and undesirable changes. One of such changes is declining rate of ethical considerations in U.S. based commercial organization. The subject is important to explore as it is likely to affect the image of U.S. business organizations. Furthermore, it is also expected that U.S. literature

  • Ethics Program Imagine Company Toyota Ethics Program

    Ethics Program Imagine company Toyota ethics program effective program . The Federal Sentencing Guidelines Organizations encourages firm set ethics programs. Review Website, located, prior assignment. Toyota Corporation is a multinational automaker in japan and is the world's largest automobile manufacturer. The company employs a large number of employees in different departments with different key objectives in order to achieve the organizations different objectives. Toyota Corporation has a corporate philosophy that

  • Ethics in Group Counseling

    Ethics in Group Counselling Ethics in Group Counseling Group Therapy Counselling: Ethics The ethical concerns of therapists have been getting larger in quantity and sophistication. Managed care demands professionals to think about problems with discretion as well as delivery associated with proficient treatment whilst other decisions might include informed consent, a variety of relationships together with customers, and ignoring discretion given clients' harmful conduct. These types of deliberations have been happening inside

Read Full Research Paper
Copyright 2016 . All Rights Reserved