Tenth Justice Influence Of The Book Report

PAGES
3
WORDS
960
Cite

One could even argue that the entire premise of the book exploits the degree to which the legal system has been corrupted and become incredibly malleable and too easily manipulated. The word "corruption" most often calls actions like bribery or kickbacks to mind, and while there are examples of this type of corruption in the Tenth Justice this is not the type of corruption that is truly insidious or causal of the plot in the novel. Instead, it is the illegality -- or at least the alegality -- of the structure of the Supreme Court as presented by Melzer (which is likely rooted in some truth, if exaggerated in the fictional world) that creates the power structures and conflicts that allows the plot to take place. The Constitution of the United States establishes the Supreme Court, but says nothing of law clerks being legally employable and paid for by federal dollars, and certainly says nothing about law clerk fresh out of law school being responsible for the research and interpretative acumen to effectively render Supreme Court decisions. The Court is very specifically described, and while it would be foolish to attempt to read a full rationale for the Court's design into the subtext of the Constitution it can be assumed with a high degree of certainty...

...

Altering the Court in this fashion places the Court itself outside the law, operating in a no-man's land that lacks real control or definition. It is precisely because there is so much ambiguity and grey area that Addison is able to do the things he does, both his initial creation of the central conflict of the novel and his ongoing attempts to redress the wrongs he has committed and restore "balance" to this bastardized Court.
Breaking the law is generally seen as sexier than keeping it, given the typical tone, theme, and required steaminess of the legal thriller genre. Melzer's characters and admittedly his readers seem to agree with this perspective, as it is in the manipulation of the law and often in the breaking of it that excitement and action is found. None of the characters presented are wholly innocent, not even the venerable Justice Hollis who never seems to be at work and is thus guilty by absenteeism. In a world like this, the law merely becomes the rules of a game that were meant to be broken.

Cite this Document:

"Tenth Justice Influence Of The" (2012, March 05) Retrieved April 24, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/tenth-justice-influence-of-the-54767

"Tenth Justice Influence Of The" 05 March 2012. Web.24 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/tenth-justice-influence-of-the-54767>

"Tenth Justice Influence Of The", 05 March 2012, Accessed.24 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/tenth-justice-influence-of-the-54767

Related Documents
Day War and Its Influence
PAGES 7 WORDS 2215

Today, with hostility being shown from the Arabs, the Jews believe that they can live through these times if they continue to stick together with the Zionistic principles and values. Any change in the current political policies from the Israeli side, such as withdrawal from the occupied territories, is hard to imagine (Ram Uri, 1994). The political culture in Israel is also facing another major contradiction of the role of

RICO Act and the Mafia
PAGES 7 WORDS 2269

Oreto, 37 F.3d 739 (1st Cir. 1994). The 2st Circuit rejected the defendant's claim that requiring two predicate acts for conviction under one theory of liability but only one act for conviction under "loan sharking," violated equal protection. Due Process. The forfeiture provisions of RICO have been criticized for violating the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. Numerous cases have rejected this criticism including U.S. v. Nichols, (10th Cir.

Organized Crime / Counterterrorism AL CAPONE OR AL QAEDA?: ORGANIZED CRIME AND COUNTERTERRORISM AS LAW ENFORCEMENT PRIORITIES IN 2014 Should law enforcement in America prioritize fighting counter-terrorism or fighting organized crime? A full examination of the history and issues involved with both will, I would argue, make the answer clear: with the proper definitions involved of both terror and organized crime, it is the latter which genuinely deserves the attention of law enforcement, and

Reward and Punishment
PAGES 4 WORDS 1257

Reward and Punishment The American system of justice is designed to ensure that criminal activity is punished and those responsible for crime are made to serve retribution for their choices. The system is based on the idea that it is better for 100 criminals to get away with crime than for one innocent man to go to prison. However, miscarriages of justice still take place in the American justice system. Innocent

London Housing Issues
PAGES 31 WORDS 11592

London Housing The research was undertaken to study the link between inequality and depravity, poverty and crime in the housing structures of London. The study found that there is wide spread economic disparity in London. This divide is evident in the living styles and the types of housing structures that people live in. The council or housing estates of the city are primarily the residences of the lower income families. This

Edgar Allen Poes story "The Cask Amontillado" You write, setting, theme story, point veiw, plt, language signifagace story. THE CASK OF AMONTILLADO Edgar Allan Poe (1846) THE thousand injuries Fortunato I borne I, ventured insult I vowed revenge. Poe's "The Cask of Amontillado" - analysis Edgar Allen Poe's 1846 short story "The Cask of Amontillado" puts across an account involving a vindictive character who tries to reinforce his self-esteem by luring