Respect Act: An Overview Of Research Paper

The new definition, critics contend, is nonsensical as "it would be highly unusual for any employee, even a Vice President of Human Resources, to spend more than 50% of his or her weekly time doing hiring, firing and disciplining employees" and direction forms the bulk of most supervisor's job responsibilities (RESPECT, 2009, Foster Swift). Approximately 8 million current workers would be declassified from their current supervisory status (RESPECT, 2009, Foster Swift). In other words, a very large proportion of what would once be considered white collar 'management-level' persons would now be eligible for unionization. "Under current law, a supervisor is considered an agent of management and owes a duty of undivided loyalty to the employer in labor-management relations, such as during union organizing campaigns, grievances, picketing and strikes. That duty would be compromised by the RESPECT Act" (RESPECT, 2009, Foster Swift). The supervisors would have dual loyalty, between labor and managerial interests, given their own potential 'stake' in the unionizing process.

Critics of the Act believe it could have a deleterious effect upon business practices in general, depriving businesses of flexibility. Because of the new definition of supervisor, "under the RESPECT Act, employees classified as supervisors would be largely "precluded from performing non-supervisor or bargaining unit work," making it difficult for companies to use supervisors to 'pick up the slack' during union strikes (another intention of the Act) (Sherk & O'Donnell 2009). Proponents of the law state that such evasion...

...

It is trying to stop employers from classifying individuals with labor interests as supervisors and preventing these employees from unionizing and from using supervisors to cushion the effects of organized labor actions.
Given the recent politically rightward shift of the current Congress, passage of the bill within the next several months seems unlikely. Promoters of RESPECT wished for it to be passed in conjunction with another pro-labor law, the "Card Check" Act (Employee Free Choice Act) which "would eliminate an employee's private election of union representation and replace it with automatic unionization if more than 50% of the employee's election cards support unionization" (RESPECT, 2009, Foster Swift).

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Bills promote unionization: The "Card Check" Act and the "RESPECT" Act. (2009, July).

Employment, Labor & Benefits Practice Group. Foster Swift Employment, Labor & Benefits Quarterly. Updated January 2011. Retrieved January 12, 2011 at http://www.fosterswift.com/news-publications-Card-Check-and-RESPECT-Acts.html

National Labor Relations Act (NLRA). (1936). Full text available January 12, 2011 at http://www.nlrb.gov/about_us/overview/national_labor_relations_act.aspx

Sherk, James & Ryan O'Donnell. (2009, May). How the RESPECT Act hurts companies and employees alike. The Heritage Foundation Research Report. Retrieved January 12, 2011
http://www.heritage.org/Research/Reports/2009/05/How-the-RESPECT-Act-Hurts-Companies-and-Employees-Alike


Cite this Document:

"Respect Act An Overview Of" (2011, January 12) Retrieved April 19, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/respect-act-an-overview-of-11523

"Respect Act An Overview Of" 12 January 2011. Web.19 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/respect-act-an-overview-of-11523>

"Respect Act An Overview Of", 12 January 2011, Accessed.19 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/respect-act-an-overview-of-11523

Related Documents

For example, almost all companies doing business on the Internet will have a link disclosing their privacy policy and the steps they will take to ensure the customer's privacy. Privacy matters become an issue because, in order to transact business of the Internet, one is required to enter such personal information as credit card numbers, addresses, emails and personal phone numbers. The vast majority of online businesses will have policy disclosure

Affordable Care Act Constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act: What Would Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson Say? The cornerstone of the recently-passed Affordable Care Act is the requirement that all Americans must buy some form of health insurance. This is necessary, given the new requirements put upon health insurance companies to cover the uninsured with preexisting conditions, so people cannot simply wait until they are sick to buy health insurance. The constitutional

Business Ethics Company Overview Ethics and Code of Conduct Guiding Principles Our Ideology; Our Objectives; Our Core Values that shape us; As a part of my Business Ethics lesson I have a task to criticize and improve my company's code of ethics, before doing that I want to briefly explain about my company; MLS Holding and what we do? The most effective statements in regard to business ethics are rooted in the strategic vision of an organization

Cobol: Overview of a Third
PAGES 18 WORDS 4692

This is unlikely to change short of an amazing new technological innovation that takes "natural" language capability and programming to a new level. Let us now compare how COBOL meets the needs of organizations working in various industries. The next section will help clarify why COBOL is in such demand among commercial enterprises worldwide. Chapter 3 - COBOL and Organizational Goals This section analyses how COBOL supports organizational goals. COBOL supports

Procurement Law Overview, Part One Solicitation Elements The federal government's basic procurement or acquisition process involves an agency identifying the goods and services it needs also known as the agency's requirements, determining the most appropriate method for purchasing these items, and carrying out the acquisition. Although this process is simple in theory, any given procurement can be complex, involving a multitude of decisions and actions (Halchin, 2006). One process that is involved is

Legal/Ethical Framework Overview of the legal system: In Australia, each state is responsible for legislation under which child care services are licensed. Licensing provides a legal "floor" below which no service is permitted to operate, according to CCQA. These include structural factors related to space, range of equipment, number and ages of children, staff-to-child ratio, and qualifications of staff. All of these factors are what contribute to quality. Legislative Basis: A child care