2005 Study By Mohala Tucker Besser Et Article Review

Length: 4 pages Sources: 5 Subject: Disease Type: Article Review Paper: #38383830 Related Topics: Cesarean Section, Infectious Disease, Infant Observation, Birth Order
Excerpt from Article Review :

¶ … 2005 study by Mohala Tucker Besser et al., conducted upon HIV-positive pregnant women who are about to undergo voluntary caesarian section to give birth. Mohala Tucker Besser et al. used a sample population to study whether or not HIV was present within the amniotic fluid of these pregnant women, and discovered that -- contrary to a previous study published in 1987 -- it was not. Additional relevant studies -- including the original 1987 Lancet publication by Mundy Schinazi Gerber et al., and further studies involving viral transmission between mothers and newborns and specific risk factors for HIV transmission in prenatal and perinatal situations -- are examined in conjunction with Mohala Tucker Besser's 2005 study. The finding has implications for preventing HIV transmission between mothers and newborn infants, and confirms the growing clinical consensus that elective caesarian section remains one of the most reliable ways to reduce viral transmission from an infected mother to the infant.

Mohala Tucker Besser et al. (2005) conducted a study regarding one of the remaining mysteries about HIV transmission. It has been long established that an HIV-positive pregnant woman is capable of infecting her unborn child with the virus, however this does not always happen. Indeed Mohala Tucker Besser et al. give the most accurate current estimate of infection rates for the unborn child at being about ten to fifteen percent of such pregnancies (488). Obviously this issue is significant for a number of reasons. For a start, pediatric HIV is a massive public health concern: Mohala Tucker Besser et al. quote World Health Organization statistics that estimate approximately ten percent of new HIV infections in developing countries are children, and over ninety percent of these cases represent perinatal transmission. Even in the United States, over ninety percent of pediatric HIV infections are due to perinatal transmission.

Mohala Tucker Besser et...


(2005) are engaged in the specific examination of whether or not the amniotic fluid of the pregnant woman is involved in these cases of perinatal transmission. What is most significant about this is that they are revisiting an issue which had been reviewed earlier in the 1980s at more or less the height of the AIDS epidemic. At that point in time the American team of Mundy Schinazi Gerber et al. (1987) published an article in The Lancet claiming to have isolated the active form of the human immunodeficiency virus in amniocentesis samples taken from an HIV-positive pregnant woman's amniotic sac at 32 weeks (459). As Mohala Tucker Besser et al. (2005) explain about this earlier publication, it was restricted to "describing a single patient" and more importantly "maternal blood contamination of the amniotic fluid was not excluded" (488). As a result, this earlier publication -- which represented the entirety of prior literature on the subject of amniotic fluid involvement in perinatal HIV transmission -- really does not have the status of scientific inquiry. As a result, Mohala Tucker Besser et al. organized the present study to present a more consistent overall examination of the question of amniotic fluid involvement.

In addition to the implicit response to the earlier publication by Mundy Schinazi Gerber et al., however, Mohala Tucker Besser et al. are also able to benefit from advances in relevant knowledge in terms of how this particular study should be structured. For example, ten years after Mundy Schinazi Gerber et al., Mofenson (1997) published a survey on the state of existing knowledge regarding the "pathogenesis of perinatal transmission" in order to assist with the effort to minimize transmission and thus reduce the number of pediatric AIDS cases worldwide (759). Mofenson's summary emphasizes that certain facts are distinctly responsible for a vast reduction in the number of cases of mother-to-child HIV transmission. Breast feeding, for example, is implicated in a significant number of previously identified mother-to-child infections. But more significantly perhaps the rate of transmission to the newborn infant is dramatically reduced if the mother undergoes birth by voluntary caesarian section rather than natural childbirth. Indeed not restricting the virology to HIV, the work of Lin Kao Hsu et al. (1996) studying the actual process of "microtransfusion" during different types of childbirth concluded that generally speaking that the level of any mother-to-fetus viral transmission is least in "elective caesarian" and that this should have "implications for reducing perinatal…

Sources Used in Documents:


Lin HH, Kao JH, Hsu HY, Mizokami M, Hirano K, Chen DS. (1996). Least microtransfusion from mother to fetus in elective cesarean delivery. Obstetric Gynecology 87: 244-248.

Magder LS, Mofenson L, Paul ME, Zorrilla CD, Blattner WA, Tuomala RE, LaRussa P, Landesman S, Rich KC. (2005). Risk factors for in utero and intrapartum transmission of HIV. Journal of Acquired Immune Deficicency Syndrome 38: 87-95.

Mofenson LM 1997. Mother-child HIV-1 transmission: timing and determinants. Obstetrics and Gynecology Clinics of North America 24: 759-784.

Mohlala BK, Tucker TJ, Besser MJ, Williamson C, Yeats J, Smit L, Anthony J, Puren A. (2005). Investigation of HIV in amniotic fluid from HIV-infected pregnant women at full term. Journal of Infectious Diseases 192: 488-491.

Cite this Document:

"2005 Study By Mohala Tucker Besser Et" (2014, April 29) Retrieved January 20, 2022, from

"2005 Study By Mohala Tucker Besser Et" 29 April 2014. Web.20 January. 2022. <

"2005 Study By Mohala Tucker Besser Et", 29 April 2014, Accessed.20 January. 2022,

Related Documents
Elective Cesarean Section There Are Many Paths
Words: 1263 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Children Paper #: 33716431

Elective Cesarean Section There are many paths to consider when a person becomes pregnant. The parents must decide whether to keep the child or not, then what type of care they will have while pregnant, and finally how they will bring the child into the world. There is the traditional method of birth where the infant is pushed through the vagina and there is Cesarean Section, or C-Section, wherein the baby

Elective or Emergency Childbirth, a Choice Between
Words: 14295 Length: 40 Pages Topic: Health - Nursing Paper #: 87724855

elective or emergency childbirth, a choice between general and local anesthesia is often called for. Cognizing the surroundings helps the birthing process. Therefore, a local anesthetic administered via an intrathecal spinal injection or through a catheter in the epidural space will prove an advantage. Ratcliffe and Evans at John Radcliffe Hospital in Oxford, England attempted tested this advantage on more than 90 elective Cesarean parturients. (Ratcliffe & Evans, 1993)

Social Acceptance of Elective Cosmetic Surgery: A
Words: 1803 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Health - Nursing Paper #: 23178600

Social Acceptance of Elective Cosmetic Surgery: A dangerous addiction to perfection Reconstructive surgery has its uses, such as restoring the face or body of someone disfigured in a car crash or other accident, or helping someone with genuine physical limitations (such as a harelip) which can have major negative medical and social consequences. However, the majority of reconstructive or plastic surgery is performed for purely cosmetic purposes in the United States.

Nursing Elective Abortion and Nursing
Words: 1183 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Women's Issues - Abortion Paper #: 87971050

Section 79-i of the New York State Civil Rights Law, passed in 1971, allows health care workers to "refuse to perform or assist" in abortion procedures "contrary to the conscience or religious beliefs" of the workers (Callahan, 1998). To invoke this protection, a worker must "file a prior written refusal" with the hospital. Violation of the law is a misdemeanor. This means that nurses have an obligation to provide good

Analyzing Early Elective Delivery
Words: 1096 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Health - Nursing Paper #: 33639389

Elective Delivery The Publication and the Issue that it Presents The article entitled Born too early: Improving Maternal and Child Health by Reducing Early Elective Deliveries was published on NIHCM Foundation, Transforming Health Care Through Evidence and Collaborations. The article discusses the issue of possible negative health consequences that early elective deliveries poses on infants, mothers and on health care system collectively, along with additional costs as an unnecessary burden. Infants

Mental Health Aged Care Mental
Words: 2439 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 92213909

It is in the nursing homes job description, that the nursing staff employed should be certified, and be able to perform a number of tasks in order to better understand the patient. This includes an assessment of the patient's mental status and thought process, an understanding of the patient's health concerns, ailments and other physical issues, with an open discussion between the nurse and the patient of anything troubling