Accounting Fraud Of Countrywide Case Study

Length: 9 pages Sources: 6 Subject: Economics Type: Case Study Paper: #30783221 Related Topics: Forgery, Corporate Fraud, Government Accounting, Accounting Ethics
Excerpt from Case Study :

Countrywide Accounting Fraud

In the year 1969, David Loeb moved to NY from Virginia to begin a home loan and advance organization named as "United Mortgage Servicing." He was joined by his trusted aide Angelo Mozilo. Both shared common dreams of big money and making their presence felt across the nation. The sole owner of the firm, David Loeb had to, under pressure of work, circumstances and colleagues part with half of the ownership. David Loeb and Angelo Mozilo became equal partners of the new firm that they formed, "Countrywide." They began their operations from and opened their new office in California. Angelo Mozilo was a very forceful and opportunistic marketer, and began pushing for contracts in the market aggressively. The organization was chipping away at two fundamental boards; David's NY-based credit exercises and Mozilo's home loan plot trades in the city of California. After they attempted to present open share by coasting a stock in stock trade, David needed to move to Los Angeles. For about two years, the two carried on this formation and had a rather localized presence. By the year 1974 organization had begun an alternate eight business locales yet it was still a neighborhood player and much expansion and work needed to be done before their dream of being known across as "Countrywide" would be realized. (Chomsisengphet, & Pennington-Cross, 2006)

Before long, it was David Loeb who understood that some extraordinary measures ought to be taken to make organization to realize the inner desires. He chose to change whole staff and enroll new, highly skilled one with high pay. Mozilo was hesitant to such an extreme move however was persuaded to the imagination of the future possibilities wit a similar depiction of dreams that had brought them to the present from the modest past and upbringing. With, fresh recruits implanted, organization soon made huge benefits with the new thoughts put and actualized by new group. In the year 1978, organization was making astounding profits. It was not sheer hard work. Key to their prosperity was foresight in understanding and anticipating changes in investment rates before it happened accompanied by institutionalizing strategies (Chomsisengphet, & Pennington-Cross, n.d.).

Mozilo effectively snatched the opportunity with refinancing of homes as investment rates fell. Before long numerous property holders began to contribute with Countrywide for refinancing and by mid 1980s within 26 states it had 104 work places. 1984 to 1986 turned out to be the most happening for the organization as it topped a landmark figure of $3.2 billion. For initial 20 years, Countrywide registered development relentlessly and financial analysts were looking forward as the industry was hit by numerous money related and capital embarrassments. Countrywide, because of its clean image and considerable trust component, was favored by many investors and got a cushion of additional funds of over four hundred million dollars in late eighties & early nineties. The organization was sufficiently shrewd to peruse the technologically advancing times and immediately acquainted itself with new technical skills with minimum expense and application handling time for the clients. For 1990, as a matter of example, the association displayed its own state- of-the- art workmanship development start-up organization, EDGE, through which it was proposed to decrease the dangers of deficient credits and affirmation evaluating (Chomsisengphet, & Pennington-Cross, n.d.).

The system had limited, by and large lessened expense by taking care of costs, while stimulating financing time to a period of less than 30 days on standard home loans, by engaging development specialists to enter customer information simply once. Typical information could then be copied to diverse records hence; figures, for instance, credit rates and refund centers could be downloaded similarly. EDGE then printed out completed genuine copies of all chronicles on a laser printer, discarding the prerequisite for preprinted development structures and saving the association $1 million a year (Chomsisengphet, & Pennington-Cross, n.d.).

Countrywide upheld its dedication to this industry by promising to offer $5 billion in House-America kind of credits to the country's two biggest home loan banks, the Federal National Mortgage Association, "Fannie Mae," and the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corp., "Freddie Mac," both of which were made by Congress to guarantee that moneylenders have a consistent wellspring of cash for home loans. Plans to enter into money market funds, stocks, no-load mutual funds, annuities and in 1996 also contributed to the company's prediction...


(Chomsisengphet, & Pennington-Cross, 2006).

The Transgressions and the transgressors

Without conventional capital requirements on the scale of home loan loaning exercises, Countrywide's exercises extended quickly from 2000 onwards. The main features of the mortgage loans originated by Countrywide during the boom years also changed. The relative decrease in office credits and increment in non-organisational advances was risky from a profitable management point-of-view in light of the fact that the non-organization advance business was less fluid. Very much in contrast to non-office credits, the agency advances must meet certain criteria, for example, most extreme advance to home value proportion, greatest obligation to salary degree, and a certain level of home loan documentation. To expand the capital accessible for home advances, the business sector for office credits is supported by government supported infrastructure by way of norms, and regulations. This manifested in decrease in credit quality of Countrywide mortgage activity. This actually added a huge risk factor and contained within it a likely cause for downslide of the organization (Freeman, Wells, & Wyatt, 2013)

This possibility of increasing danger being taken by Countrywide was possibly understood in the financial media sector as possibly early as 2004, when Countrywide was recognized as a forceful loan specialist in the more hazardous domains of the home loan market, and the media expressed worries about the helplessness of Countrywide to provide the much needed strength to the U.S. home-loan market. Thus came into being first major alteration that Countrywide undertook . Countrywide had entered into riskier domains of initializing mortgages and subsequently securitization. Although, this possibly, was the main cause of the shipwreck. The second major and consequent (to the first) was that the financial statements did not explicitly state the risk the company was exposed to. Lastly, it was apparent that the CEO of the company was privy to information that he should have divulged, ad he failed at that. (Tam, Q, 2012).

It was also noted that the Equal Credit opportunity Act (ECOA) was also violated by Countrywide. ("USDOJ: U.S. Attorney's Office - Central District of California,")

The market was on an upswing beginning 2000 through 2006 and hence was oblivious to the undercurrents as also some obvious facets of the mortgage market. Real estate market was exceeding its limits and government was largely ignorant about manipulations of its credit rating policy. Borrowers were given a free hand to declare their state of difficulty and sell their property to make profits. The Problem was realized quite late when average market cost of the property fell by a whopping twenty six percentage points and the obvious result was that these defaulting borrowers were stuck deeply into the debt-cycle, unable to find a way out of the rut. The most significant time in the default context was in the year subsequent to origination, and across the nation, the foreclosure rate on subprime mortgage loans originated during 2006 was more than 10 per cent in during the entire year and upto September 2007, and in some states (such as California) it topped 20 per cent (Chomsisengphet and Pennington-Cross, 2006; Demyanyk and Hemert, 2008).

This led to Countrywide's mortgage originations falling 11.2 per cent in 2007 (from $468.17 billion to $415.63 billion). (Michael Hudson, 2011) As if it was not sufficient, Countrywide made a recourse to its mortgage loan policy and started writing lower yielding agency loans GSEs would securitize and purchased it. This had the result that Countrywide's avenues and even caps of the "higher default risk" non-agency mortgage originations fell 42 per cent in just one year, from a holding of $305.98 billion in 2006 to $176.42 billion in 2007. With the increasing reduction in investor appetite for higher yield, mortgage securitized bonds (arising from the securitization of non-agency mortgages loans), liquidity soon started posing problems for Countrywide. (Michael Hudson, 2011). Situation soon became untenable for Countrywide and they chose to seek a bailout by yielding to Bank of America 7.25% of its shares. All this happened in August 2007 and by October 2007, its subprime transactions were under the investigations of SEC. In January 2008, Bank of America offered rescue deal that Countrywide had to accept to avoid bankruptcy.

The laws, rules, ethics that were violated by the fraudster(s)

From 2000 onwards until 2006 company showed extraordinary and almost unnatural growth in its profit growth. The major component of this runaway trajectory was 'gain on the sale of loans and securities', which reached $5,681.85 million or almost half of its total accruals in 2006. There was a non-linear correspondence between loan quality and profit margin. In…

Sources Used in Documents:


Chomsisengphet, S., & Pennington-Cross, A. (n.d.). Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis Review, 88(1),(January/February 2006), 31 -- 56.

Freeman, W., Wells, P.A., & Wyatt, A. (2013). Insights from the Failure of the Countrywide Financial Corporation (SSRN Scholarly Paper No. ID 2275772). Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network. Retrieved from

Karlan, D.S., & Zinman, J. (2013). Long-Run Price Elasticities of Demand for Credit: Evidence from a Countrywide Field Experiment in Mexico (SSRN Scholarly Paper No. ID 2272723). Rochester, NY: Social Science Research Network. Retrieved from

Michael Hudson. (2011, September 23). Mortgage industry tanks, fraud continues at Countrywide. Retrieved December 19, 2014, from
Olster, Scott. (2013, October 20). How the roof fell in on Countrywide. Retrieved December 19, 2014, from
Tam Qui, T., T.M.-D. C. with a S.F. On G. The R.O.C. (2012, January 24). Federal Law Violations at Countrywide Home Loans and Bank of America. Retrieved December 19, 2014, from
The Sarbanes-Oxley Act 2002. (n.d.). Retrieved December 19, 2014, from
USDOJ: U.S. Attorney's Office - Central District of California. (n.d.). Retrieved December 19, 2014, from
Yuliya S. Demyanyk, Otto Van Hemert. (2008). Understanding the Subprime Mortgage Crisis. SSRN. (n.d.). Retrieved December 19, 2014, from

Cite this Document:

"Accounting Fraud Of Countrywide" (2014, December 19) Retrieved January 16, 2022, from

"Accounting Fraud Of Countrywide" 19 December 2014. Web.16 January. 2022. <>

"Accounting Fraud Of Countrywide", 19 December 2014, Accessed.16 January. 2022,

Related Documents
Blow the Whistle on What You Heard
Words: 1086 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Business - Ethics Paper #: 15849755

blow the whistle" on what you heard in the garden? If so, how will you blow the whistle? If you decide to blow the whistle, what are your reasons for doing so? Your discussion should reflect knowledge of what Boatright says about issues, problems and justifications for whistle-blowing. Also, in discussing the answers to these questions you should include the following: 1) you should evaluate real and potential conflicts

Improvements in Integrity, Financial Accountability, Ethical Conduct...
Words: 1568 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 64221091

Improvements in Integrity, Financial Accountability, Ethical Conduct and Corporate Responsibilities under the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002 We passed Sarbanes-Oxley in the wake of the Enron scandal to try to root out financial and accounting irregularities. How could similar irregularities occur at Lehman Brothers? History has a way of constantly repeating itself. -- Joseph Grant 2010 The high-profile corporate shenanigans by Enron and Lehman Brothers have made it clear that tough legislation was

Estimation Techniques of the U S Financial Crisis
Words: 1335 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Finance Paper #: 23237024

Estimation Techniques of Financial Crisis The unquestionable ethical conducts within the corporate circle had been the major factor that led to 2008/2009 financial crisis. By studying the root causes of the crisis, it has been revealed that bad conducts among the CEOs of Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers, Citigroup and Countrywide Financial have been the primary factors leading to 2008/2009 financial crisis. Objective of this paper is to argue that the CEOs of

Bank of America SWOT Analysis
Words: 2395 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 20449719

Bank of America was one of the largest recipients of the troubled assets relief program (TARP) which was created in 2008. The U.S. Government made the terms of the TARP program very favorable to the bank. As a result, in December, 2009 the bank was able to repurchase all shares of TARP Preferred Stock. Paying off TARP quickly saved the bank over $25M which would have been cash outflow

The Subprime Mortgage Crisis and Aftermath
Words: 3228 Length: 11 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 63051684

What caused the subprime mortgage crisis and what was the result of the Treasury's and Federal Reserve's response to that crisis? Most people are familiar with the overall story of events leading up to 2008. They may have seen the film The Big Short, which helped the public to learn about collateralized debt obligations (CDOs) and credit default swaps (CDSs). However, there is a lot more to the story than

Business Ethics Recognizing and Resolving
Words: 2980 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 81658066

The Bank CEO's Role in Defining Ethical Integrity Based on a thorough review of existing literature of the role of ethics in the banking industry, the role of the CEO as the ethical leader of their organization is next discussion. Based on the concepts presented in the paper to this point as the foundation, these key points provide insights into how CEOs and senior management actively shape the ethical standards of