Kolchin's Unfree Labor
Kolchin uses primarily "printed primary materials" as his sources -- material that was either printed and published at the time of the events which he chronicles or collected by historians later (377). The fact that these materials are not hard to find and that they exist quite abundantly is what made this possible. Thus, what Kolchin does in his comparative history is to simply "order" the information and make sense of it: he has no difficulty gathering it; on the contrary, putting the pieces together to form a coherent whole or a convincing picture is his goal.
For example, Kolchin utilizes "records left by the masters (and their allies)" as sources as well as other records such as "diaries and reminiscences, plantation and estate records, and correspondence between owners and their administrative subordinates" as he builds his foundation of historical data (377). This is a solid foundation because it is using primary source documents (though sometimes they are collected in secondary sources) lifted straight out of the time and place under scrutiny to give a vivid account of the subject matter at hand.
Thus to compare Russian serfdom to American slavery, Kolchin examines the records of men like the American planter Jack P. Greene or John Spencer Bassett, whose surviving letters are collected in The Southern Plantation Overseer as Revealed in His Letters. To...
I. Morozova and Krasnyi arkhiv, 77. Essentially, these are letters and records that have been preserved by other historians, which Kolchin uses so as to better understand how these two worlds in which slavery looms large compare to one another. However, as many of these collections are edited, it is debatable whether they are good sources for a historian to utilize in order to cultivate an undiluted or pure vision of history. Nonetheless, that objection aside, the sources do give a glimpse into the eras through the eyes of those dictating policies and directing the affairs.
The findings the Kolchin presents that one might not find were one only studying one world and not the other are that there appear to be consistencies as far as the justification of slavery goes, when one looks at Russia and the America. There is material that is printed and circulated that is pro-serfdom and pro-slavery -- tracts, etc., that are used to promote the ideology behind enslavement. This is one finding that one might not think about initially unless one were to view the two worlds simultaneously, because in America we are used to hearing about anti-slavery groups and abolitionists, but we do not stop to think about the other side -- the side that supported the slavery and offered…
Russian & Chinese Intelligence PRC & RUSSION INTELLIGENCE: Any reviewer of the intelligence structures of Russia and the People's Republic of China can see that size and complexity still matter. They each have intensive and comprehensive structural forces with targeted elements designed to achieve certain aims. While it is likely that each has grown with an eye toward the other, often it is said that the Chinese Ministry of State Security
Russian Orthodox Religion The Russian Orthodox Church has been through many evolutions and challenges along the way to being more than a thousand years old. The Church originally emerged from a pagan society and was greatly influenced by existing Christian beliefs from other regions. This paper reviews the changes that the Church has gone through -- including the attacks on its beliefs and buildings and its monasteries by the Bolsheviks, who
Russian Tobacco Health Promotion Plan: Reducing Tobacco Use Amongst Members of the Russian-American Culture Russian Cultural Synopsis There are several unique or otherwise noteworthy practices in the Russian culture that could have an impact on areas of health. Consumption practices tend towards the extreme, with food and drink supplied amply for guests and families alike, resources permitting, and with the extending of hospitality a common and expected practice in the culture (Ries, 2012).
Russian Organized Crime in America The fall of Soviet Union worked as a catalyst for the spread of crimes throughout the world. Not only the countries connected to the Russia are vulnerable to "Russian Mafia," but entire world is facing the threat of criminal activities originating from Russia. Crimes like human trafficking, money laundering, trading stolen automobiles, arms and ammunition, and drug trafficking are among the major activities, which is being
On the other hand, competition brings about order, whereby the consequences of a particular behavior determine its selection and the most successful becomes the leader of the group (Dunne, 2007, p.49). 5. What does it mean to say that a theory is useful? How should one approach the question of determining the relevance and value of a theory (theory-testing), according to Waltz? Waltz emphasizes that a useful theory must have the
Russian Revolution Sheila Fitzptrick Author's Writing Style and Book Organization Author Point-of-View Sheila Fitzptrick is a well-known writer who has written more than ten books on modern Russian society and its history. 'Russian Revolution' is one of her recent books. This paper will highlight some of the facts in relation to the October Revolution in Russia as highlighted in a more opinionated manner by the author. Author's Writing Style and Book Organization There is no