Animal Abuse And Crime Does Research Proposal

Length: 15 pages Sources: 15 Subject: Sports - Drugs Type: Research Proposal Paper: #95193786 Related Topics: Animal Cruelty, Animals, Animal Research, Animal Testing
Excerpt from Research Proposal :

A study by the Chicago Police Department found that persons who had been arrested for animal cruelty often had a history of other crimes as well (Chicago Police Department 2008). These offenses included homicides, narcotics charges, battery, firearms charges, sex crimes, and gang related activities (Chicago Police Department 2008).

A similar study found that animal cruelty was more common among incarcerated individuals with aggressive tendencies, then for non-aggressive individuals (Keller and Felthous 1985). The study found nine distinct motivations for animal cruelty. It also found a higher incidence of family violence, particularly paternal abuse, and alcoholism (Keller and Felthous 1985). Merz-Perex, Heide, and Silverman, (2001) also found a relationship between childhood animal cruelty and later violence towards other human beings.

The graduation hypothesis contends that children who are cruel to animals progress, or "graduate," to more serious crimes towards humans (Wright and Hensley, 2003). This theory contends that animal cruelty is a link that set eventual serial killers apart from the rest of society (Wright and Hensley, 2003). That is not to say the all that are cruel to animals will become serial killers. It is just to say the serial killers have a tendency towards animal cruelty as a child or adolescent.

Battered Pets: Battered Family

The above referenced literature demonstrates a strong connection between animal cruelty as children and those that are incarcerated as adults. However, one must be careful in the assumption that one automatically leads to the other. Individual circumstances differ, as do motivations. Just because someone abuses an animal does not automatically mean that they will eventually batter someone as an adult. However, the connections between the number of battered women and children who seek assistance through shelter and whose partners had threatened or attacked the family pet are astounding. This special area of literature requires attention.

Nearly 75% of domestic violence victims indicated that their partners had threatened or killed family pets at some time before the incidents of violence towards them or their children began (Faver and Strand 2003; Loring and Bolden-Hines 2004). Women often will not leave an abusive situation for fear of what the batterer will do to their animals (Ascione, Weber, and Thompson et al., 2007). Children living in violent homes are more likely to abuse animals (Currie, 2006). Another study found that batterers who harm animals commit more dangerous acts than those that did not abuse animals (Simmons and Lehmann 2007).

In a study of perpetrators of family violence, several common characteristics were found. The first is the pet-abusing batterers were less likely to show affection towards their pets than their non-abusing counterparts (Carlisle-Frank, Frank, and Nielson 2004). They were more likely to communicate through commands and threats. They were more likely to view animals as property (Carlisle-Frank, Frank, and Nielson 2004). They were more likely to scapegoat their pets for their own problems (Carlisle-Frank, Frank, and Nielson 2004). They were more likely to have unrealistic expectations about their pets and punish their pets frequently for normal animal behavior (Carlisle-Frank, Frank, and Nielson 2004). Pet-busing batterers will are more sensitive to life events, particularly those that they feel are caused by the pet (Carlisle-Frank, Frank, and Nielson 2004).

Pet abuse is one of the four standards used to detect battered women and children (Walton-Moss, Manganello, and Frye 2005). Children will often intervene in domestic disputes to save their animal. They will even go as far as allowing themselves to be abused to save an animal (Edelson, Mbilinyi, and Beeman, 2003). The abused animal and the abused child often share a special common bond.


The problem with these studies is that they used a population that had already committed a crime. These studies established a reverse direction of causality that makes animal abuse appear to be a predictive factor, when this may not...


A majority of the studies used a different factor as the independent variable. For instance, they used previous crime and conviction, battered women and other factors as the common factor that linked the subjects. Animal abuse served as a dependent variable.

In order to develop predictive abilities, studies must be conducted where animal abuse is used as the independent variable and the commission of crime is the dependent variable. This type of study is needed to do what other studies examined during the literature review attempted to do in the establishment of causality. This research will fill this important gap in literature regarding animal abuse and the tendency to commit crime at some time in the future.

Section 3: Selected Methodology

The literature review revealed that the topic of animal cruelty and its association with deviant behavior is well researched. It was suggested that animal cruelty is predictive of later adult behavior. However, none of the studies review addressed this issue in a manner that would allow such conclusions to be drawn. All of the studies found addressed the issue to animal cruelty as an adolescent after the fact. None of them tested the predictability of adolescent animal cruelty in connection with adult behaviors. This study will address the topic of animal cruelty as a predecessor of later criminal behavior using a longitudinal study.

Study Design

In order to determine the connection between animal cruelty and later criminal behavior, animal cruelty must be treated as the dependent variable, rather than the independent variable as in other studies. In this study, two groups of adolescents between the ages of 12-15 will be selected. One group will have abused an animal in some manner prior to the time of the survey. The other group will not have abused an animal and will have strong feelings against such behaviors. These two groups will be administered a survey profiling their feelings and past actions regarding animal cruelty. Both groups will be followed until the age of 18, at which time they will be surveyed to determine if they have engaged in criminal behavior.

The age of 18 was chosen for the post-test for criminal behavior for several reasons. At the age of 18, it will have been between 3-5 years since the pre-test. If the tendency towards criminal behavior is present, it is reasonable that it will have surfaced by then. Even if the subject has not engaged in actual criminal behavior, certain patterns and attitudes will be present that may lead to criminal acts in the future. At the age of 18, it is expected that many of the subjects will still be in high school. Therefore, they will still be available to take the criminal behavior survey.


The subjects for this study will consist of males, aged 12-15 years of age that are attending local metropolitan junior high schools and high schools. Potential subjects will be identified with the assistance of school staff and guidance counselors. The goal will be to identify a group of adolescent males within the target age range, that have the tendency towards animal cruelty and one group that does not have the tendency towards animal cruelty. A target size of 200 students for each group will be the goal.

Students will be divided into the two groups through a screening survey administered by the school guidance counselors. A list of potential candidates will be provided to the researcher. As the subjects will be under the age of 18, parental permission must be obtained for participation in this study.


The research will take place in several metropolitan junior high schools and high schools. School administration will assist with data collection. They will administer and select both sets of surveys and return them using a sealed manila envelope to the researcher at the scheduled time. The researcher will coordinate with school administration regarding the most convenient time for drop off and pick up of the surveys for both the pre-test and post-test.

Survey Instruments

Both the pre-test and post-test survey instruments will be developed by the research, specifically for the purpose of this study. The pre-test will rely on information discovered during the literature review as the basis for the development of the survey questions. The post-test will repeat some of the questions regarding animal cruelty that were included on the pre-test.

This will serve as a validity measure for the pre-test. It will also eliminate those whose attitudes towards animal cruelty have changed. It is expected that adolescents whose attitudes towards animal cruelty have changed represent a third group that will not be addressed in the study, but that will have an affect on the outcome of the study. There may also be some students that were non-abusers at the beginning of the study, but that later become abusers. These two groups that changed attitude represent a threat to the internal validity of the study.

Students that change their attitudes towards animal cruelty are not expected to represent a major portion of the study participants, but it is possible that some…

Sources Used in Documents:


Arluke, a., Levin, J., Luke, C., Ascione, F. (1999). The relationship of animal abuse to violence and other forms of antisocial behavior. Journal of Interpersonal Violence, 14, pp. 963- 975.

Ascione, F.R., Weber, C.V. Thompson, T.M., Heath, J., Maruyama, M., & Hayashi, K (2007). Battered pets and domestic violence: Animal abuse reported by women experiencing intimate violence and by non-abused women. Violence Against Women, 13: 354-373.

Carlisle-Frank, P., Frank, J., and Nielson, L. 2004. Selective battering of the family pet. www.ingentaconnect.comAnthrozoos:a Multidisciplinary Journal of the Interactions of People & Animals, 17 (1): 26-42.

Chicago Police Department (2008). Statistical Summary of Offenders Charged with Crimes against Companion Animals, July 2001-July 2004. Chicago Police Department, Chicago, IL.

Cite this Document:

"Animal Abuse And Crime Does" (2009, March 13) Retrieved October 22, 2021, from

"Animal Abuse And Crime Does" 13 March 2009. Web.22 October. 2021. <>

"Animal Abuse And Crime Does", 13 March 2009, Accessed.22 October. 2021,

Related Documents
Animal Rights - Animal Abuse
Words: 963 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 31372219

The fur industry is well-known to house minks and other animals raised for their coats in cruel conditions and to kill them by such devices as anal electrical probes designed to kill without damaging fur (HSUS 2007). The problem is that the underlying rationale for criminalizing animal cruelty is that animals (even those defined as "pests") feel physical pain the same as animals protected as "pets" in our culture. Unfortunately,

Abuse of Horses Boarding Horses
Words: 1556 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Animals Paper #: 89578883

" Works Cited American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals. "ASPCA Equine Program." Retrieved April 6, 2007, at Australian Broadcasting Corporation. "Neglected horsed die, more in danger." Retrieved April 6, 2007 at Crawfurd, John. "On the Relation of the Domesticated Animals to Civilization." Transactions Of the Ethnological Society of London Vol. 2 (1863): 387-468. Flynn, Clifton P. "Why Family Professionals Can No Longer Ignore Violence toward Animals." Family Relations 49.1 (2000): 87-95. Hortness, Darci. "Neglected

Animal Cruelty and Human Violence Animal Cruelty
Words: 656 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Family and Marriage Paper #: 58927594

Animal Cruelty and Human Violence Animal cruelty includes an assortment of different behaviors harmful to animals, from neglect to more serious malicious action, and even various forms of brutal killing. Studies indicate that animal cruelty may also be followed by more serious forms of crime, such as drug use, inappropriate violent outbursts, and even in some cases homicide. Many studies in psychology, sociology, and criminology have addressed the issues involving animal

Animal Testing Negatives of Animal Testing Outweigh
Words: 2261 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Animals Paper #: 31285894

Animal Testing Negatives of Animal Testing Outweigh Its Positives and Therefore Should Not be Allowed Many cures and treatments have been developed in the last three hundred years due to advances in medical technology. These developments are sometimes attributed partly to the fact that scientists and researchers have been able to use animals as "guinea pigs" for testing new medications or treatment methods before passing them to human volunteers. There is strong

Crime Scene Preservation: Analysis of
Words: 763 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 30644717

4-8). While these standard procedure are relevant in the preservation of any crime scene, certain specifications exist when dealing with the unique challenges associated with the different types of crime scenes including homicides, rapes, arson, and nighttime crime scenes. For instance, in the case of homicide, as well as the aforementioned steps, the area must be preserved for trace evidence such as fingerprints. In the case of rapes or sexual

Economics of Alchohol Abuse Alcohol for Consumption
Words: 1853 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Sports - Drugs Paper #: 61366901

Economics of Alchohol Abuse Alcohol for consumption is not a necessary food item, but for some has become a standard part of adult culture. Increasing the level of alcohol consumption, however, moves from an economic paradigm to a social issue due to the ancillary health and behavioral effects from alcohol abuse. In turn, this becomes part of economics in that it requires fiscal resources to treat societal issues caused by alcoholism: