Verified Document

Bias In Textbooks Essay

Bias in Textbooks Davidson, J.W. And Stoff, M.B. (2010) America: History of Our Nation. Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, New Jersey.

The objective of this work is to review a K-12 textbook in terms of the seven forms of bias which include: (1) invisibility; (2) stereotyping; (3) imbalance and selectivity; (4) unreality; (5) fragmentation and isolation; (6) linguistic bias; and (7) cosmetic bias. Toward this end this work has chosen to relate the review of a textbook published by Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, New Jersey entitled "America: History of Our Nation."

Invisibility

The invisibility bias is clear in Davidson and Stoffmans' (2010) textbook characterized by the lack of representation of women characters in the recounting of the history of the early Americas. Certainly, the women who assisted in settling the 'new land' should be mentioned as their role in this endeavor certainly was one of a critically important nature however, women are little mentioned in the historical accounts in this specific textbook. Also invisible in Davidson and Stoff's work are the women and white southerners who contributed positively to live in general and to dispelling the mindset that propelled such bias respectively.

II. Stereotyping

Stereotyping is clearly evidenced in this textbook and specifically on pages 876 and 877 in which it is stated "Many white southerners were adverse to segregation" which is an absolute perfect example of stereotyping white southerners during the time that desegregation was a current and heated issue. Many southerners can recall the stories of a husband, father, grandfather or other family member who served...

Wallace blocking the entrance to the school. To state that many white southerners were against segregation is quite simply a blatant stereotypical representation of white southerners of that day.
III. Imbalance/Selectivity

On pages 662 and 663 of Davidson and Stoff's (2010) work it is stated that Mexican immigrants to the United States wanted to preserve their language and culture and that they therefore created barrios or ethnic Mexican-American neighborhoods. The historical account in this instance is biased in that it is an imbalanced and selective type of account of history. Mexican-American immigrants desired greatly to integrate into the American society in most cases and that which barred them was not their living arrangement in the form of having made their own choice but instead was living arrangements that were forced upon these individuals and families in what was in actuality segregation of neighborhoods based on race and ethnicity during that timeframe.

IV. Unreality -- Rose Color Glasses

It is reported by Davidson and Stoff (2010) on pages 972 and 973 of the textbook that in March 2003 that the U.S. led a coalition of "about 30 nations in an attack on Iraq" and the fact is that there were not that many coalition nations involved and moreover the United States managed to alienate some of their most loyal and long-standing allies. This report glorifies the actions of the U.S. with President Bush in command…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Bias in the Curricula
Words: 995 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Bias in Curricula Native American Bias in K-12 Literature There are many artifacts used in curricula that illustrate a racial bias towards marginalized groups. American Indians are one such group adversely affected by stereotypical and offensive portrayals in educational material and literature. Native Americans are typically not even mentioned in American history textbooks past 6th grade curriculum. When they are referenced, it is often in terms of Pilgrims and Thanksgiving. Other times

Bias With Respect to Social
Words: 936 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Paper

The Tampa Bay Times recently reported on the standoff between school administrators, who claim the offending passages have been taken out of context, and protestors who have cried foul over what they perceive to be ideological indoctrination, stating that "the concerns raise the specter of textbook wars in other states, especially Texas, where ideological camps have long locked horns over everything from the validity of evolution to how much

Gender Bias & Inclusion Recently,
Words: 1392 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

In another McGraw Hill edition, entitled American History: Early Years to 1877, there does seem to be more of a stress upon being clear and factual, rather than presenting an equal number of women and men than in the Houghton Mifflin approach. Major figures such as George Washington, Abraham Lincoln, and Ulysses Grant are given the greatest amount of attention. Issues of sex, gender, and sexual orientation and gender identity

Cognitive Bias May Exist in
Words: 2013 Length: 6 Document Type: Thesis

If the student has a tendency to make errors based on cognitive conditions the correction of those conditions should probably take place as early as possible in the student's life. A recent study on cognitive development found that "cognitive developmental psychology and constructivism offer possibilities for the future of entrepreneurial cognition research" (Krueger, 2007, pg. 124). Krueger extrapolates that the reason entrepreneurial teaching is so effective is that it

The Danger of Media Bias to American Democracy
Words: 376 Length: 1 Document Type: Creative Writing

Interest Groups and the MediaToday, American voters enjoy access to a veritable cornucopia of information about anything, including most especially the high-profile political events that have characterized life in the United States in recent years. Indeed, the combination of mainstream media outlets such as radio, television and the Internet together with opposing views from fringe media resources that espouse extremist views of all ilk have contributed to a flood of

Race in My Community
Words: 2455 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

bias based on gender, race, or ethnicity considered unacceptable, in some instances, like employment or pay status, it can be illegal. Our nation does not condone discrimination on factors like these, and for many years we have, as a whole, enforced laws and policies that make racist or biased behavior difficult to institute. This attention to equality, however, does not mean that racism, gender bias, or other biases do

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now