Business Management - Leadership Comparing Essay

Within this leadership framework, leaders motivate employees by directly promoting and modeling the desired personal commitment to the organization in a manner that often transcends the boundaries of the vocational environment. Instead of viewing their employment as merely an occupation or a quid pro quo arrangement, employees within a transformational organizational culture incorporate elements of their employing organization into their personal psychological orientation. In that regard, the mission, goals, and values of the organization become part of the employee's persona in a manner that often generates much higher levels of personal commitment than purely transactional leadership schemes.

Typically, transformational leadership relies on social rituals that encourage the melding of personal identity and organizational values and objectives. For this reason, transformational leadership style is most suitable for sales staff, because the clarity of organizational goals of increasing revenue are directly related to the specific efforts of employees (Bass, 1997; Bass & Steidlmeier, 1999). However, precisely because transformational leadership demands such a psychological investment, that motivational framework is also susceptible to burnout, especially in sales-oriented vocational environments.

Transformational leadership is also applicable to organizational missions that manifest a moral focus, such as environmental conservation, religious commitment, and social concerns. In addition to being well-suited to the specific leadership techniques within transformational motivation dynamics, employees motivated by morally-based organizational values are less likely to experience burnout by virtue of the independent value of the organizational focus. While this is generally true of transformational leadership within organizations in general, it is particularly true where the employees share the organizational values before their employment within that organization (Bass & Steidlmeier, 1999).

Fundamental...

...

Transformational leadership, on the other hand, is often considered one of the most intense and personal types of direct leadership that much more closely parallels charismatic leadership styles, the primary difference being orientation and loyalty to organizational mission and values rather than to any individual within the organization (Bass, 1990; Bass, 1997). While all leadership styles differ in various ways, this fundamental difference makes transactional and transformational leadership diametric opposites: the former is commonly associated with complacency, mediocrity, and lack of motivation among employees, the latter is associated with a high level of personal and psychological investment that psychological burnout becomes a potential issue (Steidlmeier, 1999).
Finally, the two leadership styles also differ substantially in the requirements for successful leaders. Within transactional leadership-based organizations, the primary requirement for supervisors is technical competence. Conversely, within transformational leadership-based organizations, supervisors must possess charismatic interpersonal skills and the ability to motivate employee performance by leading social rituals and maintaining the high energy and commitment required under that organizational culture.

Bibliography

Bass, B. (1990). "From Transactional to Transformational Leadership: Learning to Share the Vision" Organizational Dynamics, (Winter, 1990).

Bass, B. (1997). "Does the Transactional/Transformational Leadership Transcend Organizational and Motivational Boundaries" American Psychologist, 52.

Bass, B. And Steidlmeier, P. (1999). "Ethics, Character, and Authentic Transformational Leadership Behavior." Leadership Quarterly, 10.

Sources Used in Documents:

Bibliography

Bass, B. (1990). "From Transactional to Transformational Leadership: Learning to Share the Vision" Organizational Dynamics, (Winter, 1990).

Bass, B. (1997). "Does the Transactional/Transformational Leadership Transcend Organizational and Motivational Boundaries" American Psychologist, 52.

Bass, B. And Steidlmeier, P. (1999). "Ethics, Character, and Authentic Transformational Leadership Behavior." Leadership Quarterly, 10.


Cite this Document:

"Business Management - Leadership Comparing" (2009, March 05) Retrieved April 27, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/business-management-leadership-comparing-24249

"Business Management - Leadership Comparing" 05 March 2009. Web.27 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/business-management-leadership-comparing-24249>

"Business Management - Leadership Comparing", 05 March 2009, Accessed.27 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/business-management-leadership-comparing-24249

Related Documents

Business Management Supply chain management is a process conducted by several business entities, which involves planning, implementing and controlling any production and supply activities, with an aim of providing it to consumers in efficient ways. While supplying, there are intermediaries who play a role in connecting producers and consumers, who ensure efficiency in the supply chain too. Supply management is done to ensure collaboration between the intermediaries (Catholic Relief Services, 1999,

Analysis of the Apparent Disconnect between Human Resources and Management In this case, Sue has taken it upon herself that specific human resource practices are the right course for her new organization despite explicit indications from management that those particular practices do not fit the organization's strategic vision, organizational values, or available resources. In her inexperience, Sue has employed a myopic view of the concept of best practices, largely oblivious to

Where that is accomplished, formal disciplinary and termination policies do protect organizations against wrongful termination liability. In principle, the worst possible scenario is where such policies exist but without sufficient training to assure that they are not violated when they apply. Succession Planning Programs In my opinion, effective succession planning must be a continual and ongoing process if it is to have the desired results and achieve its desired objectives. While

Any manufacturing operation has an inherent strength in high volume, low cost production or low-volume, high value production. In deciding this strategy I would look first at production efficiency of existing operations and also examine which processes on the production floor were the more accurate and cost-effective. After making a decision on the manufacturing area, I would look next at the supply chain efficiency of the company, specifically in

Business Management Jack Watson Organizational Change Solgar is one of the foremost manufacturers of vitamin, mineral and herbal supplements in the nation. It has a long history of providing quality products to consumers who are interested in alternative methods for improving health and treating ailments. Throughout its history, Solgar has been faced with a number of changes that have fundamentally altered the way in which business is conducted. From the passage of legislation

However, the prospect of relocating manufacturing operations abroad raises new potential issues that must be considered. Specifically, it may be ethically permissible to take advantage of certain prevailing circumstances in foreign countries that are responsible for lower labor (and other overhead) costs. On the other hand, there are also limits to that concept. It is not ethically permissible to relocate manufacturing operations to countries where economic and social conditions are