Change Resistance In Healthcare Research Paper

Length: 3 pages Sources: 3 Subject: Leadership Type: Research Paper Paper: #64890349 Related Topics: Health Belief Model, Deception, Bureaucracy, Non Verbal
Excerpt from Research Paper :


Changes in nursing procedures:

Applying Quinn's theory of change

Change resistance can often be extremely difficult to overcome in a healthcare environment. Given that nurses operate with a great deal of autonomy, they are often suspicious when new initiatives interfere with standard operating procedures that have worked in the past. To change the locality of shift to shift reporting from the break room to the bedroom, a nurse manager must generate staff buy-in so that employees genuinely believe that the change is needed and will make substantive improvements for patients, enough so that any of the inconveniences generated by the change seem warranted. Rather than demanding immediate and radical changes, James Brien Quinn "suggests that the most effective strategies of major enterprises tend to emerge step-by-step from an iterative process in which the organization probes the future, experiments, and learns from a series of partial (incremental) commitments rather than through global formulations of total strategies" (Barnat 2014). Quinn argues that incremental change is preferred because this results in improved quality of information dissemination, better organizational awareness, decreased uncertainty and thus improved psychological commitment.

The model of change theory embraced by the organization must be founded in the principles of ACT (Advanced Change Theory) and depart from traditional theories of change. In contrast, the old empirical-rational...


While this is an important component of change, unfortunately rationalism alone will not generate buy-in. People can become very emotionally attached to old ways. Also, there may be personal dynamics within an institution to the leader that cause resistance. The power-coercive strategy suggests that a series of carrots and sticks created by the leadership will generate needed changes (Pochron 2008: 126). Unfortunately, in a healthcare environment, this is often the worst method of generating change, given that nurses will feel dictated to in a negative fashion and as if their expertise is being ignored. Even the normative-reeducative strategy which "assumes people are rationally minded and need to be engaged in the process of change" and depends upon consensus-building is problematic according to the ACT model because it does not focus on the leader as well as the follower (Pochron 2008: 125). The leader must be engaged in an intensely self-reflective process about how he or she brings about the change process and be willing to learn from the needs of his or her followers.

Some of the ten principles of ACT can seem extremely idealistic, such as the need to "create an emergent system" (principle one) or to "develop a vision for the common good" (Pochron 2008:127). This stress upon inspiring and visionary leadership is transformational in nature and may initially seem to be difficult for a nurse-manager to grasp, given the bureaucratic model of leadership required in most organizational contexts in healthcare. Nurse managers…

Sources Used in Documents:


Barnat, R. (2014). Quinn's incremental model. Strategic Management. Retrieved from:

Pochron, R.S. (2008). Advance Change Theory Revisited: An article critique. Integral Review.

4(2): 125-132. Retrieved from:,%20Article%20Review,%20Vol.%204%20No.%202.pdf

Cite this Document:

"Change Resistance In Healthcare" (2015, May 09) Retrieved January 27, 2022, from

"Change Resistance In Healthcare" 09 May 2015. Web.27 January. 2022. <>

"Change Resistance In Healthcare", 09 May 2015, Accessed.27 January. 2022,

Related Documents
Changes in Healthcare
Words: 544 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 66930358

Health Services Administration Developing an Action Plan Imagine that you are the Director of the Admitting Department of a hospital, and your strategy to increase patient satisfaction is to hire additional staff to register patients. Outline the action plan (who, what, and when) that you would use in order to effectively implement your strategy. The most effective way to implement this strategy is to bring in qualified personnel who can deal with the

Changes in Healthcare Aligning with Organizational Values
Words: 1291 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 76076069

Planning and Implementing Change in Healthcare: Creating a Mentoring Program One of the most common problems on all nursing units is the tendency of nurses to “eat their young,” or to be highly critical of younger and less experienced nurses. Given the need to recruit and retain new nurses to address the deficit of retiring nurses and to ensure that currently employed nurses are not overburdened and overworked, addressing this issue is

Health Care Economics in Economics, Cost-Benefit Analysis
Words: 1422 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 79639299

Health Care Economics In economics, cost-benefit analysis assists in evaluating the costs of an approach in terms of resources spent while cost-effective analysis evaluates the costs as achieving some sort of benefit which is not evaluated in monetary terms. Moreover, cost-benefit study examines several aspects including net-present value, present value of benefit, and present value of costs; in line with this, if a project indicates that the monetary outcome is greater

Healthcare: Collaboration and Raising the Bar on Current Standards...
Words: 731 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Health - Nursing Paper #: 56186048

Healthcare can be a stressful occupation. When providers encounter individuals who are experiencing problems with their health, it is only natural these patients may be brusque and harried, especially if they feel that they or their loved ones are not getting the attention they need and deserve. It is very easy to take out patient frustrations on nurses. Also nurses may find themselves struggling with long, back-to-back shifts because of

Health Care Policy
Words: 1569 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 56432040

Governmental Roles The political system and the medical profession are entangled in many ways. The serious nature of medicine and healing the sick and ill requires a collective guide in order to ensure that proper and sustainable care is offered at all times. When problems arise due to changes in the environment or culture, government officials are often asked to solve these problems that influence a great number of people. In

Nursing Healthcare Business
Words: 5470 Length: 20 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 30995758

Healthcare We can compare the healthcare workplace to what is seen by a person when he/she looks through a kaleidoscope: since there are numerous different patterns that appear as the moments pass by. The shortage of nurses which has been publicized widely and the high turnover rates amongst the nurses are some of the unwanted patterns which have occurred. The dependence of healthcare institutions on the nurse-managers for the retention and