Merton's conditions for hostility towards science and scientific ethos
✍️ How to write this paper — guide & tools ▾
¶ … conditions does hostility towards science arise? According to Merton in Science and the Social Order, there are two conditions in which general hostility is focused upon the discipline of science. The first is the logical idea that "the results of methods of science are inimical to the satisfaction of important values" (p. 255). Essentially, this view holds that by its very nature scientific views are hostile to prevailing cultural and social values; the theory of evolution being hostile to a Christian approach to creation, the disproving of heliocentrism, etc. The second, rather illogical, says that there is "incompatibility between the sentiments embodied in the scientific ethos and those found in other institutions" (p. 255). This view believes that if one believes in the scientific method, for instance -- observation, hypothesis testing, etc., then one cannot believe in other institutions, be they religious or political. Science becomes god, or is used to justify behaviors that are inherently non-scientific with scientific jargon or pseudo-science (as in racial profiling in Nazi Germany). In essence, though, both of these conditions are based more on fear and ignorance than on fact, and fail to recognize the true nature of science being one of inquiry rather than blind acceptance -- of continual curiosity rather than status quo.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.