Deploying A Pilot Case Study Case Study

Length: 18 pages Sources: 15 Subject: Teaching Type: Case Study Paper: #78400947 Related Topics: Epistemological, Black Studies, Behavior Modification, Holistic
Excerpt from Case Study :

The more that your questions are descriptive or explanatory the more that the case study method will be relevant;

How should I select the case to be studied?": According to Yin: "you need sufficient access to the potential data, whether involving people to be interviewed documents or records to be reviewed, or observations to be made in the 'field'. Given such access to more than a single candidate, you should choose the one(s) that best illuminate(s) your research questions. Absent such access, you should consider changing your research questions, hopefully leading to new candidates to which you do have access."

I am studying a school. What is my case: Is it the teachers? The reading program? The whole school?: Yin states: "The specific definition of your case again depends upon your research question(s). The least desirable question is to want to know "everything that happened." Your literature review should help lead to more specific questions of interest and they, in turn, should readily point to the appropriate definition of the case. As a further part of defining your case, do you think you should identify a particular time period, before and after which events will be deemed irrelevant to the case, or is your case timeless?

How much time and effort should I devote to collecting the case study data? How do I know whether I'm finished collecting the data? Unlike other methods, there is no clear cut-off point. You should try to collect enough data so that: 1) you have confirmatory evidence (evidence from two or more different sources) for most of your main topics; and 2) your evidence includes attempts to investigate major rival hypotheses or explanations. What do you think are some of the cut-off points for other methods, and why wouldn't they work in doing case study research? And How do I start analyzing my case study data? You might start with questions (e.g., the questions in your case study protocol) rather than with the data. Start with a small question first, then identify your evidence that addresses the question. Draw a tentative conclusion based on the weight of the evidence, also asking how you should display the evidence so that readers can check your assessment. Continue to a larger question and repeat the procedure. Keep going until you think you have addressed your main research question(s). Discuss the benefit of starting with questions rather than starting with the data." (2004; p.16) case study is related by Atkinson and Armstrong which focuses on information and elearning design and practice lessons learned from the student's experience of elearning. This case study was conducted in the methodology according to Yin and was 'Interpretive Research', which is focused on understanding phenomenon through means that people assign to them. This research method has No predefined variables - instead focuses on the complexity of behavior as it emerges. Kaplan and Maxwell (1994) Phenomenological Inquiry is also a methodology related by Yin and is research, which asks the question of: " What is the structure and essence of experience this for people. (Patton, 1990) This type of research produces data that is rich, thick, descriptive in which themes and patterns are observed by the researcher. This type methodology asks:

1) Who;

2) What;

3) When;

4) Where; and 5) Why.

Recruitment in this type of study is generally accomplished through:

Filter questionnaire

Invitation

Focus group attendance

It is related in the work of Audet (2005) that Creswell and Stake, whom were both known well for case studies hold that "all studies are value-laden and provide conclusions about value-laden and provide conclusions about value." (Creswell, 1998; as cited in Audet, 2005) Audet states that case study tradition has as its purpose the promotion of understanding through a description of cases. It is related that the philosophical pillars of the research paradigm, the analysis and representation of data should provide a detailed description of the case and the setting." (Audet, 2005) The analysis therefore will be "of multiple sources of data to lend credibility to the research through triangulation, using a survey, documents and interviews. It is not an attempt to quantify or establish validity because these are concepts inconsistent with the purposes,

...

The case study is described in a manner in which patterns are established and naturalistic generalizations are developed. Two primary sources of information are used in constructing the case study, specifically people and documents. (Audet, 2005) According to Creswell the "goodness' of a case study lies in the use of the case study inquiry method, the actual design procedures and the researcher's assumptions." (Audet, 2005) It is held by Creswell (1998) that the literature relating to qualitative research is assistive in developing sampling of participants for the interview part of research design." (Creswell, 1998) It is reported that two different strategies were used in garnering participants for interviews and specifically teachers and administrators in this study were given an invitation to volunteer for an interview by contacting the researcher via email. The second strategy was dependent upon the educators responding voluntarily. Finally sampling through a network was also used in a process in which the "names of potential interview candidates were provided through initial interviews with the school district contacts and volunteers. The constructivist paradigm is described as a "basic set of beliefs that guide action" (Lenz, 2005) which comprises the researcher's ontological, epistemological, and methodological premises. An ontological premise refers to the philosophical assumption about the nature of reality, epistemological to the interrelated relationship of researcher to that being studied, and methodological to the researcher' conceptualize of the research process." (Lenz, 2005) In case study research, as the information emerges "the researcher will choose an interpretive path to follow, and will 'report their cases as cases that will be compared with others." (Lenz, 2005) The first step in case study is gathering information through a 'within-case analysis containing a detailed description of each case and its emergent themes." (Lenz, 2005) The next step is a cross-case analysis, in which themes generated in each individual instance will be analyzed across the entire body of cases. (Creswell, 1998; as cited in Lenz, 2005)

Case study, in the view of Creswell involves the researcher pulling data apart and then reassembling the information in meaningful ways, drawing significant from it through direct interpretation. Patterns will be sought, with correspondences between categories developing in naturalistic generalizations." (Lenz, 2005) Following individual case analysis, a cross-case analysis will examine and search for themes among the cases in order to make a determination of themes that are common to all cases. (Creswell, 1998) Yin (1994) defines a case study as "...an empirical inquiry that investigates a contemporary phenomenon within its real life context, when the boundaries between phenomenon and the context are not clearly evidence, and in which the multiple sources of evidence are used. It is particularly valuable in answering who, why and how questions in management research." Yin holds that since case study follows the logic of the experiment instead of logic of the survey, it is not necessary to repeat a case study. This is because the formulation of a theory begins the experiment and then an attempt is made to gather evidence that either supports or disproves the theory and the survey is an attempt to gain a general view of something.

The work of Weiss (1997) reports an interview with Robert K. Yin in which he was asked to share his insights concerning the use of case study methodology in community based initiatives. The first question asked of Yin was: "How can case study methodology be used to study the effectiveness of comprehensive and collaborative community-based initiatives?" Yin answered by stating as follows:

As evaluators of program effectiveness, we are often faced with the challenge of identifying why and how interventions lead to observed results or outcomes. Case study methodology, by investigating phenomena in their real-life context, can be a very important tool in opening the "black box" of how interventions and program effectiveness are linked. This is an advantage over traditional experimental and quasi-experimental designs, which may measure outcomes and some process variables but fall short in dealing with the dynamic that is inherent in community-based collaborative initiatives. Our case study work uses a tool called the "logic model." The logic model outlines the cause and effect steps that link interventions with expected outcomes. It thus lays out the mystery of the "black box" as a set of linkages and hypotheses about how a collaborative really works. These hypotheses can then be "tested" using both quantitative and qualitative data. The logic model concept is not new, as it was first used in evaluability assessment. However, we are using this approach to address one of the perennial challenges evaluators face…

Sources Used in Documents:

Bibliography

Audet, Michael (2005) Teacher Professional Growth Plans: A Case Study of the Chilliwack School District. 21 April 2005. Online available at http://ir.lib.sfu.ca/retrieve/2221/etd1914.pdf

Creswell, J.W. (1998) Qualitative Inquiry and Research Design: Choosing Among Five Traditions. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.

Lenz, Pamela A. (2005) Perceived Influence on School Effectiveness: Chapters I-III. January 2005. Online available at http://www.education.duq.edu/pdf/Talking_Paper-Lenz.pdf

Yin R.K. 1994: Case Study Research: Design and Methods, Second Edition, Sage Publications London
Yin, Robert K. (2004) Case Study Methods. 20 Jan 2004. COSMOS Corporation Online available at http://www.cosmoscorp.com/Docs/AERAdraft.pdf
Atkinson, M. And Armstrong, K. (nd) Information and Elearning design and practice lessons learned form the students experience of elearning. Online available at http://web-dev-csc.gre.ac.uk/conference/conf32/presentations/armstrong_atkinson.ppt
Weiss, Heather B. (1997) Interview with Robert K. Yin - The Information Exchange Vol. III, No. 1: Harvard Family Research Project. Online available at http://www.gse.harvard.edu/~hfrp/content/eval/issue7/eval7.pdf
Laman, Opal Effie (2006) Multiple Case Study Examining Perceptions of Four Adult Sibling Participation in the Individual Education Plan, Transition Mating of a Brother or Sister who is Congenitally Deafblind. 2006 December. Online available at http://etd.lib.ttu.edu/theses/available/etd-11/unrestricted/Laman_Effie_Diss.pdf
Van Teiljlingen and Hundley, Vanora E. (2001) The Importance of Pilot Studies. Social Research Update. No. 35. Online available at http://auraserv.abdn.ac.uk:9080/aura/handle/2164/157
Clark, Hazel Grace (2006) Teacher Librarians, Technology and Collaborative Connections: A Case Study of Teacher Librarians From a Communities of Practice Perspective. 1987 Simon Fraser University 2006. Online available at http://ir.lib.sfu.ca/retrieve/2806/etd2114.pdf


Cite this Document:

"Deploying A Pilot Case Study" (2007, December 12) Retrieved November 28, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/deploying-a-pilot-case-study-33346

"Deploying A Pilot Case Study" 12 December 2007. Web.28 November. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/deploying-a-pilot-case-study-33346>

"Deploying A Pilot Case Study", 12 December 2007, Accessed.28 November. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/deploying-a-pilot-case-study-33346

Related Documents
Wal-Mart Case Study Wal-Mart Faces
Words: 9789 Length: 25 Pages Topic: Business - Advertising Paper #: 4187164

The Price-Sensitive Affluents, Wal-Mart has learned (Wal-Mart Annual Reports) is more interested in finding an exceptionally good deal and not necessarily concerned about the shopping experience. This is particularly true as one of the strongest factors influencing the execution of their strategy, the emerging global recession during this timeframe, takes hold. Again as with the Price Value Shopper and the paradoxical purchasing patterns of the Brand Aspirational segment show,

Building Information Modeling Strategy for
Words: 2811 Length: 11 Pages Topic: Engineering Paper #: 10627034

Representative Building Information Modeling Implementations in Other Countries As noted above, evaluating the effectiveness of building information modeling systems remains challenging because of the relatively recent addition of this suite of modeling tools to the architect/designer repertoire, but there are some salient successful examples of such deployment from around the world as set forth in Table 1 below. Table 1 Representative Building Information Modeling Implementations in Different Countries Country Description Finland Approximately 33% of architects and engineers

Delphi Study Influence of Environmental Sustainability Initiatives...
Words: 17687 Length: 60 Pages Topic: Energy Paper #: 50666614

Delphi Study: Influence of Environmental Sustainability Initiatives on Information Systems Table of Contents (first draft) Green IT Current Methods and Solutions Green IT and energy costs Green It and Email Systems Green IT and ICT Green IT and ESS Green IT and TPS Green IT and DSS Green IT and other support systems Green IT and GHG reduction Green IT and the Government Sector Green IT and the Corporate Sector Future Prospects of Green IT in the software industry The paper focuses on how the

Australia Airline
Words: 1717 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Transportation Paper #: 73514641

Australia Airline Management Case Study Report: Airlines This paper provides a comparative study of the goals, management style, and labor relations policies of three Australian airlines: Qantas, Virgin Blue, and Air Australia Airways. It examines the recent history of these major airlines, with a specific focus on the labor relations difficulties of Qantas, Virgin Blue's attempt to create a more innovative model of customer service as a budget airline, and Air Australia Airway's

Social Business and the Retailer
Words: 9885 Length: 34 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 5588703

Social Media Retailing Applications: Opportunities and Threats How Has Social Media Developed and What are the Benefits and Downsides of Using Social Media for Retailers Today? This study examines social business in general, how it developed and the benefits of using social media in particular. Second, this study provides a discussion concerning the potential positive as well as the effects of social business in the retail sector which is followed by a

Jet Blue Airlines: Cost Management the Objective
Words: 1338 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Transportation Paper #: 91514284

Jet Blue Airlines: Cost Management The objective of this work in writing is to review the case study on Jet Blue Airlines and to analyze their system of cost management. Price variance of fuel is noted by Jet Blue Airlines to be a critical matter in business operations as it was reported in 2007 that fuel costs were the largest operating expense for Jet Blue Airlines due to high average prices of