Verified Document

Direct Instruction Term Paper

DIRECT INSTRUCTION refers to the model of instruction developed by Engelmann in 1960s whereby he focused on a specific design of teaching and learning to prove that every child learns when instruction method is appropriate. In other words, "The Direct Instruction Model... is a comprehensive system of instruction that integrates effective teaching practices with sophisticated curriculum design, classroom organization and management, and careful monitoring of student progress, as well as extensive staff development." (Stein, Carnine, Dixon, 1998) Engelmann and his colleagues explained that for this model they began "with the obvious fact that the children we work with are perfectly capable of learning anything that we can teach... We know that the intellectual crippling of children is caused by faulty instruction -- not by faulty children." (Engelmann & Carnine, 1991, p. 376) In 1960s and 1970s, Engelmann and his colleagues Carl Bereiter, and Wes Becker developed the direct instruction model for Project Follow Through, which was a federally funded experiment that focused on learning skills of at-risk children. Project Follow Through was "the largest educational study ever done, costing over $600 million, and covering 79,000 children in 180 communities. This project examined a variety of programs and educational philosophies to learn how to improve education of disadvantaged children in grades K-3...Multiple programs were implemented over a 5-year period and the results were analyzed by the Stanford Research Institute (SRI) and Abt Associates (Cambridge, MA)...The program that gave the best results in general was true Direct Instruction... Students receiving Direct Instruction did better than those in all other programs when tested in reading, arithmetic, spelling, and language." (Direct Instruction: The Most Successful Teaching Model, 2002, reference 4)

Direct instruction is the most effective teaching strategy today and when compared with other models, it proved to be one teaching method that worked in all cases regardless of children's age or race. But direct instruction, despite being an extremely popular model has often been misunderstood or wrongly understood because education literature tends to confuse readers regarding the real structure and scope of direct instruction.

In 1976, Rosenshine was the first education researcher to include direct instruction in his review of highly effective teaching strategies. It is important to understand what direct instruction is before we can study its impact on students in secondary schools. "Many educators today consider any systematic instruction that includes teacher modeling to be Direct Instruction. Similarly, other educators think that Direct Instruction is simply an example of the application of task analysis (i.e., breaking down complex skills into smaller steps). Whereas both modeling and task analysis are features of the Direct Instruction Model, they are not the features that ultimately define Direct Instruction." (STEIN et al. 1998)

Direct instruction model is based on some important concepts and some of its main features are discussed below. These features have been extracted from the research of Engelmann & Carnine, 1991; Gersten, Woodward, & Darch, 1986; Stein, Carnine, & Dixon, 1998. The first most important feature is actually the main concept on which direct instruction model is based. According to this principle every child can be taught provided the teaching strategy is appropriate. (Kozloff et al. 1999)

Engelmann and his colleagues maintained that race, sex or environmental factors did not or could not affect the learning capabilities of a child and therefore if a child is not learning something it indicates that the teacher has not been applying the right strategy. By strategy we refer to everything from teaching method to the curriculum and Engelmann felt that the reason behind poor learning is usually ineffective teaching practice or ill-designed curriculum. The second important feature deals with cognitive learning i.e. In this model, curriculum is designed about for maximum cognitive assimilation. The third important feature is the curriculum development, which is based on knowledge synthesis, communication and behavior analyses. (Kozloff et al., 199)

According to Kameenui & Carnine, 1998, direct instruction...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

They are the keys that unlock a content area for a broad range of diverse learners... Students, from the brightest to the most challenged, are likely to benefit from thorough knowledge of the most important aspects of a given content area." (Kameenui & Carnine, 1998: p. 8) Big ideas can differ from subject to subject. For example in science curriculum it would be something like "the nature of science, energy transformations, forces of nature, flow of matter and energy in ecosystems, and the interdependence of life" (Kameenui & Carnine, 1998, p. 119). These big ideas are concepts that help "in building a level of scientific literacy among all students that is necessary for understanding and problem-solving within the natural and created world" (Kameenui & Carnine, 1998, pp. 121-122).
It has been noticed that direct instruction helps in bringing about massive changes in learning capabilities of children regardless of their race or environment. Nadler (1998) found that Wesley School in Houston was producing much higher percentiles compared to other at-risk students. Principal Thaddeus Lott however is not surprised because he has the one tool that helped his students transcend all barriers to achieve higher grades. This tool is direct instruction, which resulted in "a 10-percentile rise in standardized-test scores." (Nadler, 1998)

Similarly various other studies have indicated a pronounced difference between those students who were taught through direct instruction model and those who were not. In 1984, Meyer conducted a research on benefits of direct instruction and observed the progress of some minority students of Ocean Hill-Brownsville, Brooklyn. It was discovered that by the time these children reached 9th grade, they knew much more than 10th graders in non-direct instruction schools. They were found to be at least seven months and one year ahead of their older counterparts in math and reading respectively.

Another study conducted by Gersten and Becker (1998) also gave similar verdict in favor of direct instruction. It was found that even after direct instruction was discontinued in later years, students who had received it in elementary school continued to perform better than non-direct instruction students in secondary school.

Yet another study showed that students who had received direct instruction had better chance of finishing high school without dropping out and getting admission in college. (Darch, Gersten, & Taylor, 1987; Meyer, Gersten, & Gutkin, 1983)

Nadler (1998) agrees:

From its earliest days, DI was shaped to succeed in the educational killing fields of urban America. It worked. It raised student IQs by training children early to apply logical distinctions to new materials. It worked well with children who were at, below, or above the norm for their grade. It accommodated both accelerated programs and remediation. It fostered classroom discipline from the earliest ages. The package, implemented systematically in grades K-3, proved so potent that even when it was abandoned after the third grade it still had measurable, statistically significant effects on high-school graduation and college acceptance -- an advantage of at least 10 percentiles."

Direct instruction was primarily meant for young students in elementary school but because of its success it has been implemented in many secondary and adult schools. We have shown what research says about impact of direct instruction on secondary students but it must be borne in mind that direct instruction almost always begins at elementary level and available educational literature and research tests the scores and achievements of secondary students who had received DI at elementary level. This is because the learning pattern a child adopt during his early years is what determines his ability to learn in later life. For this reason, researchers study the impact of DI received at elementary level on a child's learning skills in higher classes and not of DI received exclusively during secondary school.

Direct instruction has proved to be better than most other teaching models and…

Sources used in this document:
References

MARCY STEIN, DOUGLAS CARNINE, AND ROBERT DIXON, Direct Instruction: Integrating Curriculum Design and Effective Teaching Practice. Vol. 33 no, Intervention in School & Clinic, 03-01-1998.

Gersten, R., Woodward, J., & Darch, C. (1986). Direct instruction: A research-based approach to curriculum design and teaching. Exceptional Children, 53, 17-31.

Engelmann, S., & Carnine, D. (1991). Theory of instruction: Principles and applications (Revised edition). Eugene, OR: ADI Press.

Direct Instruction: The Most Successful Teaching Model April 24, 2002 URL:
http://www.jefflindsay.com/EducData.shtml
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Instructional Designs I For Exceptional Children
Words: 1748 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Education Instructional Design I For Exceptional Children Instructional Designs I for Exceptional Children This Portfolio Narrative will present my combined ten years of field work as an educator of special needs and special education students in an inclusion setting. I have had the privilege of acquiring all these experiences in a private school, as opposed to a public or pre-school, setting. The private school experience has furnished me with a plethora of unique and

Child and Adolescent Psychiatry in Hong Kong
Words: 988 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Child and Adolescent Psychiatry in Hong Kong The prevalence of mental health problems in people with disabilities is estimated at between thirty and fifty percent, in Hong Kong (Vasa & Roy, 2013). Anxiety disorders are the most common mental problems occurring during adolescent and childhood, at least one in ten people having anxiety disorders. In addition, anxiety disorders are the most common manifestations of psychological distress among people with autism. People

Child With Disability
Words: 2379 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

fifth of all Americans have some type of disability (United States Census Bureau, 2000). Alarming? Yes, however, disabilities do not discriminate and people of all ages, race, and socioeconomic backgrounds can be affected or have a family member who has a disability. Disabilities in children may include, but are not limited to Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder, Asperger's Disorder, Autism, Central Auditory Processing Disorder, Dyscalculia, Dyslexia, Dysgraphia, Dysprazia, Learning Disabilities, and

Children: Reading L. Jones Teaching
Words: 1475 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

One teaching model that seems to be very effective within the portfolio framework is the "Process Model." The process model is, at its most simple, a method of writing in which the "process" of writing and revision is emphasized. Perhaps one of the easiest ways to express its essence is that it is the method of using progressive "drafts" to arrive at a final product. Of course, this model can

Child Psychology Child Clinical Psychology
Words: 2204 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Paper

In order to decrease the risk of burnout, it is important to find ways to deal with stress. Learning to generate a division between ones work life and personal life is a significant first step. Practicing good stress management methods can also be very helpful (Pros and Cons of Being a Clinical Psychologist, 2012). Even though one establishes normal work hours during the day, as a psychologist they may find

Children's Literature Diverges From Adult
Words: 1310 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Ultimately, Osborn succeeds in using idiom of the period that is immediately accessible through various venues of popular culture (she describes Crockett as seeming to "be half varmint") and weaves the language of the legend into the story. This differs significantly from Fritz' work in that the story of Pocahontas involves primarily third person language and modern idiom with none of the tall-tale style phrasing. Overall, this story differs

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now