Disappearing Ink -- Todd Gitlin In A Essay

Length: 5 pages Sources: 1 Subject: Teaching Type: Essay Paper: #42690915 Related Topics: Cellular Phones, Reading, Study Guide, Graphic Design
Excerpt from Essay :

Disappearing Ink -- Todd Gitlin

In a September 1999 Op-Ed piece in the New York Times, New York University Professor Todd Gitlin wrote of a new trend in university education, cropping up amongst American colleges -- an Internet company posting free notes for core required courses at 62 major universities. He was reminded of his days at Berkeley, in which a note taking service attended lectures (always a graduate student), take notes, type them, and sell for a nominal fee. The notes were professionally done, organized in a manner that would suit "most of the group," and even the professor could use them as a template for courses. However, soon class attendance began to wane; why go to class if you could get the materials elsewhere? And those who attended were far less lively and willing to discuss key events in a cogent and active manner. Gitlin notes that education is not about rote memorization, at least it should not be. Instead, education is about discourse, new ideas, making new connections -- and often learning more from one's colleagues than the text or professor (Gitlin). College tuition is expensive, it is less a fee than an investment, and the very idea of modernizing and deconstructing classwork has some very serious connotations.

Over the last few decades, the extraordinary developments in technology have had a similar extraordinary influence on education, particularly that of the internet, online learning, and interactive computer-based learning in the classroom. In fact, as early as the mid-1990s educators were receiving reports from the Department of Education that "through the use of advanced computing and telecommunications technology, learning can also be qualitatively different. The process of learning in the classroom becomes significantly richer as students have access to new and different types of information, can manipulate it on the computer through graphic displays or controls…. And can communicate their results and conclusions in a variety of media…" (Technology's Impact on Learning) What literally hundreds of research studies do tell us, though, is that used properly, technology can enhance the achievement and interaction of students at all levels, improve teacher/student/parent communication, and even improve school administration and management.

In the 21st century, it is not only ink that is disappearing, we know most note taking is recorded, later transcribed, or notes furiously written on netbooks and laptops, but also the idea that technology can distance one from the very process of communication, dialog, and ultimately personal growth and actualization. However, technology can, as most know, be used in both positive and negative ways depending on the circumstances. For example, Texting, or text messaging, is a modern colloquial term that refers to the exchange of information between mobile devices, made possible by transmitting messages through cellular networks. Because so many students have access to cell phones, and often carry them to school, communication with texting is not unusual but expected.

One of the consequences, though, of the internet age is the preponderance of entrepreneurs using E-Mail and E-Commerce to provide services for students; from tutoring to lecture notes; from essays to actual customer research and writing. Online lecture notes are a fairly recent phenomenon, obviously an extension of Gitlin's campus note taking services. These not companies are not affiliated in any way with a university, or with a specific professor. Instead, they are privately owned businesses that have attracted large sums of money to tap into the market of student services. The companies, like the graduate student at Berkeley, work on a for-profit basis and the lecture notes are solicited from students enrolled in the course or companies may recruit note takers; sometimes paying as much as $400 per semester per class of notes.

One first must ask about the
Philosophically, if we decide that we need to
police the use of these services because some choose to miss class and get the notes, we must also realize that a weapon of any kind is harmless unless it is used. If students wish to compromise their education, and considerable expense, by skipping class and the value of the lecture from a live professor, that is a personal choice they will make. A good professor will base their exam on a variety of components: class lectures, the text, outside reading materials, and of course, course notes. Missing one of these components should, in theory, negatively impact the grade and encourage students to attend class. What might even be more proactive would be for the professor to distribute, either on paper or electronically, their own outline of the lecture. If a professor uses a power point, for instance; that day's lecture could be uploaded to a virtual blackboard as a PDF file for students to access as needed.

If we really analyze the situation, the distribution of notes is really not anti-education. Much new theory in constructivist education, for instance, states that it is more advantageous to tell students what will be taught, then teach it, and then ask questions and dialog together (I do, we do, you do). This approach makes it very clear what you, the instructor, thinks is important and should be emphasized. There is nothing wrong with emphasizing the terms and concepts students should know -- everything does not have the same level of importance in a lecture, and therefore, notes highlight and organize the way one should think about the material, review, or study for an exam.

Thus, the arguments seem polarized: one side believes that commercial note taking companies, or surrogate students hired to take notes, pose a major threat to education. This view believes that students will not come to class, will simply rely on the materials from the note takers, and not participate in the materials used in the syllabus. One cannot imagine, though, that there are many learning experiences in which the class notes are the sole means of communicating the appropriate information.

Conversely, others believe that online note companies may actually be quite beneficial and suggest that teachers welcome this service. However, if teachers rely on the publication of online notes, they might refer students to those materials rather than take extra time and effort to adjust their own explanations. Instead of allowing outside internet companies to organize notes, this can all be prevented if teachers manage and distribute their own notes. The veracity of the materials are ensured, their timeliness, updating, and even source materials -- what is missing is the economic incentive for the middle-man, to profit off something that should be, by most academic standards, free. One is not giving away answers by publishing class notes. What one is doing is providing a way for students to understand and focus though seemingly insurmountable readings lists and concentrate on what the professor believes to be important.

Still, there are positives to the integration of new technologies in the classroom, too. Done right, the use of any additional technology that helps learning, and certainly internet research and/or cooperative note taking, opens up a wide world of possibilities. It is all about using sources responsibly, analyzing the text, and finding the best way to research one's topic. Take Wikipedia for instance; it can be one of two things; a first blush overview and source idea for many subjects, or a way to copy material without even being sure of its academic veracity. The same would be true when utilizing notes penned by others -- how credible is the source.

Wikipedia is not meant to be the depository of all human knowledge saved for posterity with no qualms about sources. It is a reference work on all types of subjects that is constantly evolving, it is not meant to be a final destination, nor a single source for a subject. Simply a way to disseminate knowledge in a practical, real-time manner using everyone everywhere as an expert. Wikipedia was conceived, and is managed, to be the starting place for research. It is a quick review of most topics, and, if the editors are doing what Wikipedia wants, will source and reference their material enough, and update needed citations, that it will provide not only content, but sourcing and additional expertise as well. Wikipedia is also not meant to be the only source users cite -- in fact, that is antithetical to its purpose. Instead, at least one author noted how truly amazed he was at Wikipedia and sister sites, in all languages across the globe, are all being run by a non-profit foundation…

Sources Used in Documents:


Bloom, A. The Closing of the American Mind. New York: Simon and Schuster, 1988.

Broughton, J. Wikipedia - The Missing Manual. New York: O'Reilly Media, 2008.

Gitlin, T. "Disappearing Ink." 10 Septmber 1999. The New York Times. October 2010 .

"Technology's Impact on Learning." June 2003. NSBA.org. October 2010 <http://www.nsba.org/sbot/toolkit/tiol.html>.

Cite this Document:

"Disappearing Ink -- Todd Gitlin In A" (2010, October 25) Retrieved December 5, 2021, from

"Disappearing Ink -- Todd Gitlin In A" 25 October 2010. Web.5 December. 2021. <

"Disappearing Ink -- Todd Gitlin In A", 25 October 2010, Accessed.5 December. 2021,

Related Documents
Text Messaging in Clinical Information
Words: 1832 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Nursing Paper #: 29852340

messaging has become a common method of communication in the modern society because of the proliferation of mobile phones and Internet-based instant messaging platforms. Text messaging has permeated nearly every facet of the society including the healthcare sector where medical personnel utilize it to relay patient information. The increased use of text messaging in the healthcare sector is attributable to the fact that medical personnel are increasingly looking for

Weight Loss Through Text Messaging
Words: 4018 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 92701191

The text asked for the patient's fasting blood sugar and included the date and time of the message. When patients entered their blood sugar, the system sent a confirmation message. Any results below 70 or greater than 400 were flagged and routed for further intervention by a registered nurse dedicated to the study. Additionally, the patient received appointment reminder messages at 7 days, 3 days, and 1 day prior

College Students' Text Messaging, Use
Words: 728 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 54109233

There are, however, admitted limits to the study. Firstly, the sampling size was relatively small and from a homogeneous population. There may also be correlational factors that affect the result which do not reflect the causation of higher rates of student literacy who text. Students who are highly plugged in to Internet technology, for example, may be more affluent and thus more apt to have advanced technology which enhances texting

Texting and Driving Safety the
Words: 1046 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Transportation Paper #: 44863012

That is because texting also involves the same brain regions and cognitive processes as communicating by telephone that are responsible for the dangers associated with cell phones and driving and combines that risk factor with another additional independent risk factor: visual distraction. Unlike cell phones, which distract the driver visually for only a small percentage of the time when they are being used for verbal communication, texting while driving is

Messaging During Simulated Driving, Drews Et Al.
Words: 937 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Transportation Paper #: 24749930

messaging during simulated driving," Drews et al. (2009) study the effect that text messaging has on driver attention spans and response times. The authors studied drivers in a driving simulation to examine how the drivers responded to texting while driving. Their findings indicate that texting while driving results in poor driver performance with respect to attention span and response time. The authors note the their scores, which are some

Communication Practice in a Text:
Words: 1206 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Communication - Language Paper #: 64022243

By not waiting for an answer, though, "S" also deflects attention from the Prague issue. Second, by changing the subject to "oh we're all going to see Judge Jewels aren't we on the Thursday second November obviously" "S" brings up something else before committing to going, perhaps implying she wishes to still remain non-committal about Prague, but also reconfirm their friendship by reminding "A" about Judge Jewels, a social