Dream ACT's Newest Proposal -- May 2011, Research Paper

Length: 6 pages Sources: 4 Subject: Teaching Type: Research Paper Paper: #77459186 Related Topics: Dreams, I Have A Dream, Immigration Reform, New York City
Excerpt from Research Paper :

¶ … Dream Act's Newest Proposal -- May 2011, Senate Bill 952

If Adolph Hitler and Eva Braun had somehow managed to make their way to the United States after World War II and had a child on American soil instead of killing themselves, the child of these hated foreigners would have automatically been an American citizen imbued with all of the rights and privileges afforded thereto. By very sharp contrast, children brought to the United States by illegal immigrants do not receive the same entitlements as citizens, and in many cases, they receive no social support services at all despite the fact that their parents may be hard-working, taxpaying members of their communities with no criminal records and spotless citizenship otherwise for numerous years. This fundamentally unfair approach to treating children differently with respect to the provision of social services -- including educational and healthcare services -- based on the status of their parents could be overcome by the adoption of the provisions of the so-called DREAM Act, but opposition to the bill has prevented its passage to date. To determine the basic provisions of the DREAM Act as well as what its proponents and critics have to say about it, this paper provides a review of the relevant literature, followed by a summary of the research and important findings in the conclusion.

Review and Discussion

According to Palacios (2010), at least 65,000 undocumented students graduate from American high schools each year without any plans for higher education or a career, and countless other undocumented students simply drop out of school based on a lack of educational incentive and become mired in a vicious cycle of low-paying jobs or criminal activities. To address this need, the Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors Act (DREAM Act) would provide the opportunity for undocumented students who are willing to attend college or serve in the armed forces to more fully contribute to American society by creating a clear path to citizenship and allowing states to determine eligibility requirements for in-state tuition (Palacios 2). As originally proposed by Senator Dick Durbin (D-IL) and Rep. Howard Berman (D-CA), the DREAM Act would serve to repeal Section 505 of the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996 (HRIRA) that has heretofore prevented states from offering in-state tuition to undocumented students unless they offer the same benefit to all out-of-state students (Palacios 2). The elimination of this provision of the Illegal Immigration Reform and Responsibility Act of 1996 would permit individual states to determine the eligibility requirements for higher education benefits, including in-state tuition (Palacios 2). The DREAM Act is widely regarded as being a viable approach to addressing the existing disparities in the treatment of undocumented students by:

1. Providing undocumented students a pathway to citizenship.

2. Allowing undocumented students who meet the following criteria to apply for "conditional" permanent residency status for a period of six years:

The student must have entered the country before the age of 16 and also have been present in the United States for a continuous period of five years immediately preceding the date of enactment of the DREAM Act.

At the time the student applies for conditional permanent residency, the student must have been admitted to a two-or four-year institution of higher education or earned a high school diploma or general education development certificate (GED) in the United States.

The student must have no criminal background and demonstrate good moral standing.

During the six years of conditional permanent residency, in order for the conditional status to be lifted and changed to permanent, the student must satisfy one of the following:

1. Earn a degree from a two-or four-year institution of higher education, or complete two years, in good standing, toward a higher education degree.

2. Serve two years in...


The student must meet the requirements for conditional permanent residency (arrived in the U.S. before age 16 and have good moral standing) for the exception of high school graduation or admittance into an institution of higher education. In addition, the DREAM Act provides some higher education financial assistance. Undocumented students who are enrolled in institutions of higher education and meet all of the requirements for conditional permanent residency status would be eligible for federal student loan and federal work-study programs (Palacios 2).

The most recent version of the DREAM Act (hereinafter alternatively "the Act") was introduced in the 112th Congress on May 11, 2011 by Senators Richard Durbin (D-IL) and Harry Reid (D-NV) in the Senate as S.952 and in the House by Representatives Howard Berman (D-CA), Ileana Ros-Lehtinen. In July 2011, senior members of the Obama administration presented testified before a Senate Judiciary Subcommittee on Immigration, Refugees, and Border Security hearing concerning the recently re-introduced Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors (DREAM) Act (S. 952) (Johnson 1). Officials at the hearing, the first in response to the re-introduction of the Act, included Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano, Education Secretary Arne Duncan, and Under Secretary of Defense for Personnel and Readiness Dr. Clifford Stanley, who emphasized President Obama's continuing support for the DREAM Act and described the various ways in which the DREAM Act represents a timely and effective respond to the needs of the nation (Johnson 1). According to Senator Durbin, The DREAM Act would provide the opportunity for a select group of immigrant students who possess the potential to more fully contribute to American society. "These young people were brought to the U.S. As children," Durbin notes, and adds, "they should not be punished for their parents' mistakes" (1). The DREAM Act would provide eligible participants the opportunity to achieve legal status if they:

1. Came to the U.S. As children (15 or under);

2. Are long-term U.S. residents (continuous physical presence for at least five years);

3. Have good moral character;

4. Graduate from high school or obtain a GED;

5. Complete two years of college or military service in good standing;

Proponents of the DREAM Act cite a number of valuable outcomes, including the following:

1. The DREAM Act would benefit the U.S. Armed Forces. During a period in America's history where two shooting wars are still being fought, advocates emphasize the need for DREAM Act participants. Moreover, military service has long been recognized as a legitimate path to American citizenship (Landau 27). Senator Durbin emphasizes that, "Tens of thousands of highly-qualified, well-educated young people would enlist in the Armed Forces if the DREAM Act becomes law" (1). Further, the Defense Department's FY 2010-12 Strategic Plan concludes that the DREAM Act would help "shape and maintain a mission-ready All Volunteer Force" (quoted in Durbin at 1). Likewise, U.S. Department of Defense Secretary Gates has advocated passage of the DREAM Act because it "will result in improved recruitment results and attendant gains in unit manning and military performance" (quoted in Durbin at 1). Another high-level defense official, General Colin Powell, also supports the DREAM Act and argues, "Immigration is what's keeping this country's lifeblood moving forward" (Durbin 2).

2. As the adverse effects of the Great Recession of 2008 linger on, the second benefit of the DREAM Act has assumed new relevance and importance because it would help further stimulate the American economy. In this regard, Senator Durbin cites the results of a UCLA study that found the DREAM Act could pump between $1.4-$3.6 trillion into the U.S. economy during the working lives of its participants. One prominent advocate of the DREAM Act is New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg, who advises that young people who are willing to commit to the requirements of the DREAM Act are precisely those people the American economy needs in the future: "They are just the kind of immigrants we need to help solve our unemployment problem. It is senseless for us to chase out the home-grown talent that has the potential to contribute so significantly to our society" (quoted in Durbin at 2).

The newest version of the DREAM Act also contains important controls in order to prevent abuse of its provisions. For instance, Senator Durbin emphasizes that "DREAM Act participants are not eligible for Pell and other federal grants and are subject to tough criminal penalties for fraud. DREAM Act applicants must apply within one year of obtaining a high school degree/GED or the bill's enactment; and must prove eligibility by a preponderance of the evidence" (Durbin 3). Moreover, there are a number of other protections in place to help ensure compliance with the Act's provisions as well as the caliber of the applicants who can gain admission to the program. For example, Senator Durbin adds that in order to qualify for the newest version of the DREAM Act, "An individual must submit biometric information; undergo background checks and a medical exam; register for the Selective Service; demonstrate…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Durbin, Dick. (2011). "Passing the DREAM Act." Senator Dick Durbin, Illinois: Assistant

Majority Leader. [Online]. Available: http://durbin.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/hot-


Johnson, Kevin R. (2011, July 7). "Acting on a Dream: The Obama Administration Speaks Out

Cite this Document:

"Dream ACT's Newest Proposal -- May 2011 " (2011, July 13) Retrieved August 3, 2021, from

"Dream ACT's Newest Proposal -- May 2011 " 13 July 2011. Web.3 August. 2021. <

"Dream ACT's Newest Proposal -- May 2011 ", 13 July 2011, Accessed.3 August. 2021,

Related Documents
Dream Act and Its Implications
Words: 954 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 26847533

Clearly, the provisions of the DREAM Act would be of enormous benefit to the tens of thousand of undocumented Latino/Latina and Chicano students already living in the United States as well as the needs of the U.S. armed forces, but the act remains in legislative limbo at this time. Despite some initial hope following the election of President Barack Obama that the legislation would be fast-tracked for approval, particularly

Dream Act -- Immigration Controversy the "Dream
Words: 1156 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Government Paper #: 1110034

Dream Act -- Immigration Controversy The "Dream Act" is legislation that was originally introduced to the U.S. Congress in 2001 and in 2009 it was re-introduced after being co-authored by Republican U.S. Senator Orin Hatch of Utah and Democrat U.S. Senator Dick Durbin of Illinois. The "Dream" Act in Dream Act is an acronym for "The Development, Relief and Education of Alien Minors Act." The Act is designed to allow young

Dream Act: The Development, Relief and Education
Words: 1031 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Government Paper #: 61693435

DREAM Act: The Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors Act is a proposal for a bipartisan regulation that deals with the tragedy that young people brought up in America have experienced with regards to the current immigration laws. While initial attempts to introduce this legislation can be traced back to as early as 2001, recent attempts have been fueled by President Obama's announcement of certain directives. In June 2012,

Immigration Reform Dream Act
Words: 1686 Length: 5 Pages Topic: American History Paper #: 98120978

Immigration Reform and the Dream Act Regardless of one's individual political position, a study of immigration in modern America reveals that the current immigration system is not working. Preferential treatment of immigrants from some countries over immigrants from other countries and preferential treatment of high-wage immigrants combined with policies of active deportation reflect a reality that no longer exists in America. The reality is that there are huge numbers of undocumented

Dreams in Sigmund Freud and Franz Kafka
Words: 1434 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 21722588

Dreams in Sigmund Freud and Franz Kafka Dreams, the Unconscious, and the Real Self in the Interpretation of Dreams by Sigmund Freud and the Metamorphosis by Franz Kafka In 19th -20th century societies, the prevailing philosophical discipline and way of living among people is centering one's attention to the 'Self.' The concept of the Self is influenced by the individualist society prevalent in Western societies. Indeed, individualism through introspection is evident in

Dream When Dreams and the
Words: 1078 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 46679559

" (Flanagan: 38) Theorists, scientists and thinkers have come up with their own views on dreaming. Dreams are considered "warnings," "premonitions," "announcer of good" and "indicators of future" as well. Many feel that dreams come from a divine power that warns people about the consequences of their actions or tries to put them on a better path by sending messages in the form of dreams. Initially it was believed that