Eat Less Salt And Die' Indicates Various Article Review

Length: 5 pages Sources: 3 Subject: Black Studies Type: Article Review Paper: #53321402 Related Topics: Hypertension, Inferential Statistics, Cholesterol, Regression Analysis
Excerpt from Article Review :

¶ … Eat less salt and die' indicates various scientific tenets. The author argues that hitherto injunctions on unhealthiness of salt and prescriptions to reduce dietary intake of salt are misguided. On the contrary, salt far from being unhealthy, is healthy and should not be controlled in the least. In order to most effectively evaluate Teitelbaum's argument, we need to assess various characteristics that primarily include the reliability and validity of the sources that he used per conclusion.

The study that Teitelbaum primarily leans on was one reported by the Journal of the American Medical Association and published May 4, 2011. Conducted by researchers at the University of Leuven in Belgium, Stolarz-Skrzypek et al. measured an impressively large sample of healthy individuals (n= 3.681) with range 20 to 60 and beyond. Urinary sodium levels indicate intake of salt. Tracking the health of these individuals for the next 8 years, the researchers discovered that those with the highest urinary sodium levels had, contrary to popular belief, the lowest risk of developing hear disease, compared to the high-salt people. The conclusions of the study, as Teitelbaum pointed out, contradict the prescriptions of the American Heart Association (AHA), which suggests that people should limit their salt intake to 1500 mg per day. Salt intake may be deleterious to people who suffer from congestive heart failure or high blood pressure, but cutting back may actually be detrimental for the body "the salt-needing body naturally triggers you to eat more salt when you try to cut back" (Teitelbaum, Psychology Today).

There are various characteristics that make this quantitative study reliable. Firstly an impressive sample of people was used. The larger the sample the more plausible the alleged significance (Breakwell et al.) specially if random selection (as in this case) was used. Secondly, the study was well-matched in age and sex and, thirdly, the study was a longitudinal one ascertaining that researchers allowed a feasible amount of time to elapse before concluding that massive consumption of salt did not result in serious illness. The researchers also made sure to select an equal number of participants from each of 6 subgroups by sex and age (20 to 60+). Also positive was the fact that the same participants were used throughout; that participants were repeatedly monitored;...


These included tools to measure clinical and biochemical variables, questionnaires, and general monitoring to determine fatal and non-fatal outcomes. A 24-hour urine sample was collected from participants at baseline and, in 2008; another urine sample was collected from participants in two different locations. Blood pressure was also measured at baseline and follow-up with mercury sphygmomanometers. Surveys questioned medical history; smoking status; drinking habits; medication use including contraceptives and hormone replacement therapy; and educational levels. Venous blood samples collected blood glucose and serum total cholesterol measurement. Diabetes was also tested for by self-reported diagnosis, fasting glucose level, or use of antidiabatic agents.

The "International Classification of Disease" manual was used to code immediate and underlying causes of death for any of the participants, and information was also collected on 2856 participants on the incidence of nonfatal events via that same standardized questionnaire that was used at baseline. For the hypersensitive cohort, Chi-square and normal z test were used for descriptive statistics, whilst non-parametric statistics (e.g. Shapiro-Wilk) were used to assess inferential results. A multiple Cox regression analysis was used to assess correlation with the dependent variables being sex, age, blood pressure level, body mass index, alcohol intake, use of hypertensive drugs, urinary potassium excretion, educational attainment, smoking status, total cholesterol level, and diabetes. The study conformed to strict ethical requirements.

For the blood pressure cohort, researchers used the t test and the McNamara test with statistical methods including single and multiple linear regressions. Associations between blood pressure and explanatory variables were investigated, whilst accounting for family clusters and adjusting for co variables. In short, the many and intricate considerations and precautions that were involved with and included into consideration of the study, as well as its cross-sectional breadth and longitudinal monitoring, indicate internal and external validity and reliability of this study.

The shortfalls with this study are, however, several. Firstly, correlation is not cause. For all we know, some other factor may have been inherent in these people (perhaps their genes, specific age factor, or healthy characters for instance) that disabled intake of slat…

Sources Used in Documents:


Breakwell, G.S., Hammond, S., & Fife-Schaw, C. (2000). Research methods in psychology. London: SAGE.

Stolarz-Skrzypek K, Kuznetsova T, Thijs L, Tikhonoff V, Seidlerova J, Richart T, Jin Y, Olszanecka A, Malyutina S, Casiglia E, Filipovsky J, Kawecka-Jaszcz K, Nikitin Y, Staessen JA (2011). European Project on Genes in Hypertension (EPOGH) Investigators. Fatal and nonfatal outcomes, incidence of hypertension, and blood pressure changes in relation to urinary sodium excretion.. Journal of the American Medical Association. 4, 3051, 1777-85.

Teitelbaum, J. (2011). Eat Less Salt - and Die? Psychology Today

Cite this Document:

"Eat Less Salt And Die' Indicates Various" (2011, August 14) Retrieved August 2, 2021, from

"Eat Less Salt And Die' Indicates Various" 14 August 2011. Web.2 August. 2021. <>

"Eat Less Salt And Die' Indicates Various", 14 August 2011, Accessed.2 August. 2021,

Related Documents
Gypsy Roma Healthcare in the United States Today a Culture Sensitivity...
Words: 4402 Length: 16 Pages Topic: Family and Marriage Paper #: 27826360

Gypsies, otherwise known as Roma, came to the Americas with the very earliest settlers. Throughout the course of the past 500 years, the Roma, their preferred name, have held on to their traditions and practices. Historical written record says that the Portugese exported Gypsies to South America. According to legend, the Portugese did the same thing in what is now South Carolina, long before the English came to settle the

Aloud or in Writing, Making
Words: 17261 Length: 55 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 71062622

Companies such as XYZ Widget Corporation are well situated to take advantage of burgeoning markets in developing nations, particularly in Asia and Africa. 2. XYZ can grow its business by expanding its operations to certain developing nations in ways that profit the company as well as the impoverished regions that are involved, particularly when marketing efforts are coordinated with nongovernmental organizations operating in the region. 3. Several constraints and challenges must

Saudi Arabia Obesity: Adolescent Girls
Words: 6273 Length: 17 Pages Topic: Health Issues Paper #: 67800127

In order to get various information for comparative analysis, several online databases will be explored so that the scientific data and social factors that will be unearthed are factual enough and relevant to the study of obesity among teenagers. The publication year was used from 2000 to present. This is because the researcher can be access to the best data. Also, this period has showed the fast economic development that

Poisoning Our Planet if It
Words: 8834 Length: 20 Pages Topic: Animals Paper #: 68794962

From the point-of-view of the variation and flexibility of the species such cultivated woody crops rank as no more than cornfields. While the tree farms are conveniently be stretched on the private lands, national forests those are considered priceless reservoirs of most of the biological diversity of the nation cannot expand so easily. The commercial logging is considered as the greatest danger for survival of the national forest system.

New Technology the Best Cure
Words: 13809 Length: 50 Pages Topic: Disease Paper #: 56996011

Taken in isolation, some of the new, minimally-invasive procedures are less expensive by far, when analyzed on a procedure-by-procedure basis, than previous significant surgical interventions, as demonstrated below: Procedure Cost Estimated duration of 'cure' CABG 5-7 years PCI (percutaneous coronary intervention 3-5 years Based on the above analysis, it would appear to be clear that a PCI is more cost-effective than CABG procedures. This may not be true when all costs are considered, however. The logic of

South Africa and HIV
Words: 12832 Length: 43 Pages Topic: Religion Paper #: 23289090

Preface – Moral Leadership in an International Context South Africa - Johannesburg and Cape Town December 2018 – January 2019 Wow! What an adventure! This trip/course to South Africa with my Candler School of Theology comrades was a full bounty of knowledge and personal growth. The agenda set forth by our instructors Dr. Robert Franklin, Dr. Gregory Ellison, and Dr. Letitia Campbell was chock full of meetings and interviews with current moral leaders