Ethical leadership is required to stop the 'Planned Obsolescence' principle in Consumer Product Design and Development
This paper attempts to identify and explain the issue of 'Planned Obsolescence' and whether the ethical leadership can help eradicate it from consumer perspective. Ethical decision making model developed by Winter (1992b) and Corporate Social Responsibility model developed by Carroll (1991) will be used as the theoretical foundation for this paper. Survey method will be used to ascertain the response of the subjects and regression was used to assess the gathered data.
Innovation is not always a friend of consumer. The businessmen in the middle have full control over it and do manipulate its introduction and shelving as per their wish. To earn a hefty sixty percent margin and restart the process of innovation and sales and profits through capacity investments (Reinhardt et al., 1997), the manufacturers are forced to continue introducing new products in the market while the previous ones are already new, thus making the previous ones obsolete. The customer who had bought the previous one now needs to buy the latest one as well in order to stay at level with his competitors, resulting in double revenue for the firm. For instance, now that the processor functionality becomes twice of what it was 1.5 years ago and manufacturing product technology completes its turnover cycle in just 3 years, the desktop personal computer market now leads the speed with which the cycle of technological turnover for electronics embedded in many products completes itself. (Goodall, Fandel, Allan, Landler, & Huff, 2002).
The expectations are that the fixed investment needed in an electronic chip fabrication plant will rise to $10 billion by 2015. Add the technological or market failure perils to it (Tewary & Wang, 2005), and the manufacturer will put aside the ethics guide and run to do anything that can save his money. That's when the leadership comes into picture. Normal managers would continue using obsolescence as the easiest tool in the technology industry but a leader, a visionary will not hurt the consumers because of an ill-planned investment. Why will a leader do such a thing? How can ethical problems really solve this dilemma and who would like to actually do it in real life? Let's try to answer these questions.
Though the empirical evidence which relates personality traits to ethical leadership is still not overwhelming, one's cognitive moral development (e.g., Turner et al., 2002) his level of standards (Howell & Avolio, 1992) and conscious use of authority (House & Howell, 1992) and his social responsibility norm (Kanungo, 2001) are supposed to affect the ethical leadership talent. Different personality traits are linked with the ethical leadership acumen. Dependability, fidelity, trustworthiness, faithfulness, audacity and concern for other people, carefulness and endurance, acting upon the decisions of one's conscience, and empathy are seen as vital for ethical leadership (e.g., Bass & Steidlmeier, 1999; Brown et al., 2005; Guillen & Gonzalez, 2001; Khuntia & Suar, 2004).
In recent years, scholars have argued that ethical leadership has become an essential element for today's managerial programs (as cited in Erickson, 2006). Initially, research on ethical decision-making focused on actions that increase profits and maintain honesty in all transactions. However, recent studies have included ideas that construct and maintain lucrative and profitable relationships as well. This transformation has reverted to the pre-industrial age of corporate management, illustrated by direct marketing and sales activities that promote the possibility for an emotional commitment amid buyers and sellers that rise above small economic exchange (as cited in Erickson, 2006).
Ethical leadership is clearly a business practice focused on decision-making efficiency. Designing sustainable and durable products is beneficial to companies as it improves their relationship with customers. However, the implementation of an ethical and moral product engineering and designing system takes a long time and huge investment. Furthermore, employees also have to be taken on board and informed about the long-term benefits it could bring. Common bond across horizontal and vertical boundaries have got to be created by the top management to achieve unity of purpose. The goal of the current leadership ought to be to form a bridge between the human behavior and the business structure in order to establish...
That's why the self-reports employed to find out the traits required for ethical leadership failed completely. The respondent's own fact twisting makes the self-reports biased. (e.g., Viswesvaran & Ones, 1999) The characteristics like integrity, conscientiousness and honesty are most likely to be prone to faking (e.g., McFarland & Ryan, 2000). Therefore, using the results generated by self-reports and integrity tests are a very debatable topic in this arena. (see e.g., Lilienfeld, Alliger, & Mitchell, 1995; Rieke & Guestello, 1995) Hence, how to measure these very desirable characteristics still remains a big question for the empirical evidence researchers.
Scholarly research on planned obsolescence principle has been carried out with limited scope and has produced mixed results. In most research done recently, little work has been done in measuring consumer perception values about ethical leadership corporate social responsibility and what it means to them. This study aims to fill this gap and survey consumer perception about ethical leadership and corporate social responsibility related to planned obsolescence.
3. Research Questions:
1. Are consumers aware of current planned obsolescence practices?
2. Do they view corporate leadership as responsible being responsible for obsolescence practices?
3. What related experiences have they and their significant others had in the past?
4. How important is corporate social responsibility to them?
4. Significance of the Study
The study has both theoretical and practical implications. Firstly, while, a growing body of literature exists dedicated to customer complaint, business process management (BPM) as well as leadership (Wheatley, 2005), nonetheless, there is little empirical research on topics relating to ethical leadership and how innovation and change can be implemented to stop the use of the Planned Obsolescence principle in product design and design.
On a general level, this study will carry significant value for companies around the world since this research will thoroughly cover the concept of corporate social responsibility and ethical decision-making at the management level from a consumer's perspective.
The findings of this study will provide valuable information for the policy makers both in the top management of companies to make effective decisions to support and fund effective product design programs.
This study and its findings will become an addition to and update of the international research on ethical leadership, planned obsolescence and corporate social responsibility.
5. Motivation and Purpose:
In keeping with ethical leadership that integrates innovation and change, which aims to resolve customer complaints, presents businesses numerous rewards and reimbursements. To start with, this kind of relationship can produce a loyal consumer. Research also shows that more than the frequent buyer; the loyal consumer has an affecting connection to the manufacturer (as cited in Schein, 2004). These sentiments can comprise reliance, partiality, and consideration of the corporation's capability to produce durable and effective products (Schein, 2004).
6. Theoretical Framework:
This study uses ethical decision making model developed by Winter (1992b) and Corporate Social Responsibility model developed by Carroll (1991) as the theoretical foundation for this paper. Winter and Barenbaum (1985) were extremely disturbed by the failure of self-reports and integrity tests (specified above) and came up with TAT testing mechanism. In this type of testing, the social responsibility is gauged by pictures relating to moral and legal standards of behavior, internal responsibility, concern for others, care about the results and self-evaluation (Winter, 1992b). They included 5 variables to gauge the inclination towards ethical decision making.
(1) Exhibiting self-control when making right decisions;
(2) Always doing what's fair and unbiased;
(3) Thinking and acking for the greater good of others;
(4) Making decisions that are necessary and good for the company;
(5) Exhibiting role-model qualities
Since this measure uses the coding of running text, the temptation for social desirability is reduced (for an overview of validation studies see Winter, 1991, 1992b). This measure of social conscientiousness zeros in on whether a person shows an inner obligation to do what is right and fair and is always thinking of greater good of people and the company and demonstrates role-model qualities.
Keeping the issue of obsolescence in mind, one should think about how to find such an ethical leader first who would morally consider obsolescence a wrong practice because it harms others, thus displaying a concern for others. The leader should be taking ownership of his actions, holding himself responsible for going against obsolescence on ethical grounds. Similarly, he should possess all the characteristics that are mentioned in the discussion above.
Before going any further on obsolescence and ethical leadership issue, let us first see how ethics' implementation has been a debatable issue in past, which will help us see…
King Jewels: Ethical Leadership Case Leadership style may have contributed to unethical behavior because: a) There was no leader providing guidance and keeping a watchful eye on employees for last three years. b) Andy Wong had been busy travelling and expanding business and hence failing to provide the much-needed guidance and supervision c) Company had become overly ambitious and leadership was more interested in excessive expansion and big plans than in checking quality, d) Ho
Leadership Self-Assessment Analysis In the wake of the corporal scandals of Enron and the Arthur Anderson Company, there have been increased calls for strong ethical leadership. Leadership had always been regarded as a key factor in ensuring the effectiveness of any organization. However, new models are also being developed to challenge the limitations of the prevailing classical theories of leadership. This paper argues for a tempered approach, one that combines effective leadership
Ethical Issues in Nursing Over the last ten years, the demand for long-term care services has been facing increasing amounts of pressure. Part of the reason for this is because of the large portion of the population that is becoming older (the Baby Boomers). As they have the potential to cause the overall amounts of demand to increase dramatically. Evidence of this can be seen with information compiled by the Government
Resolving Ethical Business Challenges: Elaine Business managers and executives usually face several ethical challenges that require them to demonstrate ethical leadership in resolving. Elaine's situation is an example of some of ethical business challenges that these leaders experience with regards to the advantage and disadvantage of each decision. The first decision relates to Graphic, Inc. loan, which was engaged in litigation about promotion of its products to children (Ferrell, Fraedrich &
Ethical Training -- Successes and Failures Ethical Training: Successes and Failures Ethics are often thought of as black and white, but that is really not the case. There are many shades of grey, and what is ethical in some instances may not be ethical in others. Additionally, there are concerns when it comes to what one person thinks is ethical vs. what another would find ethical. That is often why there are
Leadership is a process that helps in directing and mobilizing people. It has for the past 100 years been a subject of many studies. These studies have come up with theories of the nature and exercise of leadership. Some of these theories include trait theories of leadership, theories of emergent leadership, leadership style theories, psychodynamic theories, and the path goal theories among others. The second section of this paper focuses