FDR The New Deal Term Paper

¶ … primary sources on the New Deal Programs. It has 6 sources in Chicago format. Frank D. Roosevelt attempted to turn around the declining economy of the U.S. during the 1930s by introducing the New Deal. This comprised of various programs which aimed at restructuring and rectification of the economy and yet, when the New Deal was launched it failed miserably due to poor administration, and lost objectives. The failure was so dramatic after the words of hype to sell a failing economy that the programs are still criticized with fervor today by critics and economists alike.

Jim F. Couch and William F. Shughart (1999) in their book "The Political Economy of the New Deal" objectively project the political scenario and the administrators Harold Ickes and Harry Hopkins as having the major role for its failure. The basis of the authors' premise is that when the New Deal was introduced, the U.S. GDP had been staggering. The promise of the New Deal programs to meet this goal had been sufficient for the distribution of the funds to the various States. However, Couch and Shughart argue that the New Deal failed because of the leakage of the funds due to corruption within the administration, the discovery of which disillusioned the public. The authors review several economists and experts in the field of econometrics including Lee Alston, Joseph Ferrie, Gavin Wright, Donald Reading and John Wallis etc. And add credibility to their research. These researches include the presidential politics, funds distribution, Congress structure and loan programs. It is evident from their objective approach to the analysis of the New Deal programs that the authors address expert political and economic issues in a professional manner not comprehensible by the ordinary readers.

The selfishness of self-interest groups' is also evident in the work of Deborah C. Malamud (2003). "Who they are - or were" discusses the emergence of the middle class in the American society. According to her, although America boasts of equality and openness, its political entities develop programs that serve the interest of particular...

...

Writing from the people's perspective, clearly Malamud reprimands self-interest groups at the political level who develop, shape and promote middle class so as to serve their purpose. The concept of wage rates, white/blue collar jobs and whiteness of the American society is inherent in the wage and hour legislation, federal welfare relief and the new federal law of unionization developed during the New Deal. Malamud thus attempts to divulge the fact that it is not always clear whether Federal programs are meant for the public or the interest groups who generate them. Her study focuses on the Federal Emergency Relief Administration (FERA); New York Temporary Emergency Relief Administration (TERA); Civil Works Administration (CWA); and Public Works Administration (PWA) etc. programs which trace the methods with which the funds were allocated. The author's work is sufficiently credible as she effectively provides arguments of her thesis from researched documents of the various institutions named above and dialogues recorded.
Jennifer Long (1999) in her analysis of the three programs of the New Deal, namely the Knoxville program, Nuclear Project, and the Tennessee Valley Authority program, project the thesis that during the Great Depression, the American public became a puppet of the flood of self-interest groups from the private sectors. Although the purpose of the New Deal programs had been to increase employment when they were launched it became clear that each program merely served the particular sector promoted by Congress. Long does not refer to many external sources but rather relies on her primary resources to address her readers: mainly employees and those readers who are currently under the impression that the government programs would benefit them. Her article serves the purpose of providing insight to the working of the government and illustrates how the workers have been subjected to Federal manipulation for the past 6 or more decades.

Jeff Manza's (2000) thesis is that historical evidence of the New Deal indicates that it raised issues of class, race, gender,…

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Young, James T. 1993. The origins of New Deal agricultural policy: interest groups' role in policy formation. Policy Studies Journal.

Adams, Don and Goldbard, Arlene 1986. New Deal Cultural Programs: Experiments in Cultural Democracy. Webster's World of Cultural Democracy, Accessed at http://www.wwcd.org/policy/U.S./newdeal.html#INTRO

Manza, Jeff 2000. Political Sociological Models of the U.S. New Deal. Annual Review of Sociology.

Long, Jennifer 1999. Government Job Creation Programs -- Lessons from the 1930s and 1940s.Journal of Economic Issues.


Cite this Document:

"FDR The New Deal" (2003, November 12) Retrieved April 25, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/fdr-the-new-deal-157977

"FDR The New Deal" 12 November 2003. Web.25 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/fdr-the-new-deal-157977>

"FDR The New Deal", 12 November 2003, Accessed.25 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/fdr-the-new-deal-157977

Related Documents

FDR’s Approach President Roosevelt took a proactive approach to the Great Depression, immediately proposing the New Deal programs as practical steps towards rebuilding the nation’s economy. When he was elected, Roosevelt also demonstrated understanding of the need for emotional messages to help the American people remain calm and confident. For example, one of FDR’s most famous quotes was delivered in his inaugural address: “the only thing we have to fear is

New Deal
PAGES 6 WORDS 1895

New Deal Philosophy and economy of new Deal The government of the United States became greatly involved in economic issues after the stock market had crashed in 1929. This crash visited most serious economic dislocation on America's economy. It lasted 1929-1940. This prompted President Franklin D. Roosevelt to launch the New Deal to alleviate the emergency. Very important legislations were and institutions were set up during the New Deal Era. These legislations

FDR: The New Deal Years 1933-1937: A History, Kenneth S. Davis presents a meticulous account of Franklin Delano Roosevelt's first term. This book is the third volume in Davis' much-lauded biography series of the 32nd president. In this volume, Davis focuses on Roosevelt's New Deal policies, providing a thorough analysis of how the president laid the foundations - often without his full comprehension -- of the American semi-welfare state. Davis' core argument

New Deal Assistance President Roosevelt's New Deal Program failed to do enough for those hit hardest by the Depression: Impoverished Afro-American and white citizens working in the rural areas of the U.S., the elderly, and the working class. There are several reasons why these constituents remained outside the reach of the New Deal program. First, there had been in general very little focus on the needs of these constituents. The New

New Deal
PAGES 4 WORDS 1358

New Deal Politically-motived objections to President Roosevelt's "New Deal" would long outlive FDR himself. In 2003, when Nobel Prize-winning economist Paul Krugman was looking for a term to describe the ideologically-driven motivations of President George W. Bush and his administration, the phrase he selected was "the great unraveling" -- Krugman's image saw Roosevelt's New Deal programs (above all Social Security) as having become the very fabric of the society in which

New Deal Era and the
PAGES 2 WORDS 628

The American government has since steered clear of measures like price regulations and has instead promoted a model that trusts the elasticity of the market. However, New Deal measures like unemployment insurance and social security have remained in place. World War Two, rather than any direct effects of the New Deal, helped stimulate the American economy. Since the Reagan administration, the American government has followed a trajectory nearly opposite to