Freud's Writing By Socrates And Socrates' Writing Essay

Length: 4 pages Sources: 1+ Subject: Mythology - Religion Type: Essay Paper: #65155062 Related Topics: Sigmund Freud, Writing, False Memories, Civilization
Excerpt from Essay :

¶ … Freud's Writing by Socrates and Socrates' Writing by Freud

Socrates Commenting on Freud's Civilization and its Discontents

Sigmund Freud presents a very interesting set of principles in his work Civilization and its Discontents. Here, he describes his belief in the true identity of the nature of man. More than anything else, man is aggressive. This aggression is essentially caused out of the tension and conflict between innate primal desires and the demands of social mores. Such aggression is often channeled through the death drive, the primal need to destroy which must be released in one way or another, even in a modern context.

In this view, society then attempts to civilize that aggressiveness so that we can live together without killing each other. It redirects primal and sexual energies into more positively viewed energies and behaviors. In Freud's view, religion serves as an institute of society, and aims to tame the naturally wild and aggressive state humans are born into. Thus, Freud stresses the inseparable relationship between society and the individual that I simply cannot agree with. Civilization makes men unhappy, but it is a necessary evil to enjoy some of the finer rewards living in society has to offer. In this, Freud rightfully believes that the price of civilization is simply too high,

Yet, this is where I am personally lost, as morality and ethics do not stem from a common consensus within a society, but rather from the individual and his or her own actions. According to Freud, society restricts man, but I believe that the individual does have responsibility towards other people and the society in which one resides in. Essentially, the individual is the city; our individual identities are entirely wrapped up with the context of the cities we live in. Therefore, breaking with the city is like breaking with oneself. As I show in "Crito" in Plato's Five Dialogues, this belief is in stark contrast with Freud's concept of how the city and civilization...


Yet, I believe in adhering to the laws of one's society out of my moral obligation to do what is right. I stand true to this belief, as I always have done, and am willing to risk my life in order to uphold the laws of my dear city, Athens.

Moreover, the value of inquiry is an important element in Freud's work which I can also actually agree with. The reality principle is the concept that human beings try to avoid suffering through regulating their pursuit of pleasure. Inquiry is an important step to understanding the world around us and therefore creating the reality principle and how it maintains our own individual desires and emotions. This keeps us more in tune with the external world. It is an important concept in Freud's psychoanalysis that the individual should spend great effort in understanding the self as well, in order to help ease the tension of repressed memories and experiences. Another element that I do agree with Freud on is our unconscious selves as determining the path of our own inquiries. Freud posits the concept of the subconscious. At first glance, it is unknown to us; yet, with continual inquiry into its strange idiosyncrasies as exhibition of our repressed memories and experiences we begin to understand more of ourselves. My personal philosophy is that we have a connection to an immortal soul. Once again, at first glance, its conditions are lost to us. But then we continuously recollect knowledge and truth from our immortal soul, which is very similar to Freud's concept of the unconsciousness. The unconscious Id holds a number of repressed experiences that hold a wealth of knowledge into why we are the way we are. It is a crucial element in psychoanalysis to unravel that mystery, just as it is an important element within the context of my own philosophies.

Part II: Freud's Response to "Sermon on the Mount"

Even I must admit to this being one of Jesus' most influential sermons in all of the New Testament. It is one of the sermons which truly reflect the founding principles of Christianity. It features the "Lord's Prayer"…

Sources Used in Documents:


Freud, Sigmund. Civilization and its Discontents. Norton & Company. 1989.

Freud, Sigmund. Interpretation of Dreams. Megalodon Entertainment LLC. 2010.

Plato. Five Dialogues. 2nd ed. Hackett Publishing. 2002.

The Holy Bible. New International Version. Harper Publishing, 1983.

Cite this Document:

"Freud's Writing By Socrates And Socrates' Writing" (2012, March 11) Retrieved June 25, 2021, from

"Freud's Writing By Socrates And Socrates' Writing" 11 March 2012. Web.25 June. 2021. <>

"Freud's Writing By Socrates And Socrates' Writing", 11 March 2012, Accessed.25 June. 2021,

Related Documents
Socrates Freud's Civilization and Its Discontents Sermon on the Mount...
Words: 1674 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 59938744

Freud, Socrates, Christ I, Socrates, have only questions for the author of Civilization and Its Discontents, Dr. Sigmund Freud. It surprises me greatly that Dr. Freud should so misread the great tragedy of Oedipus Tyrannos by my fellow Athenian, the poet Sophocles. Does Freud really believe the motivations of Oedipus to be some sort of universal constitutent of human behavior? As my distinguished colleague Frederick Crews (Professor Emeritus of English at

Civilization and Its Discontents: Freud
Words: 775 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 17874785

Freud, Civilization and Its Discontents Socrates on Freud's Civilization and its Discontents: Religion, the nature of man and the value of inquiry According to Sigmund Freud's Civilization and its Discontents, certain aspects of human nature are immutable. In some ways I do agree with this: I believe that every human being has a certain, innate tendency or ability to do something uniquely well. That is why I devised my vision of an ideal

Plato Vs. Freud on Eros and Sexuality
Words: 1029 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Black Studies - Philosophy Paper #: 45932921

Plato vs. Freud on eros and sexuality Plato's concept of love mandates two rectifications. Both of these rectifications are necessary in order for us to appreciate the relevance of Plato's theory of love to contemporary problems. The first depiction comports with the non-sexual aspect of the loving relationship, because Plato's theory of love indeed includes sex. The second depiction, or rectification, is related inextricably to the heterosexual aspect of the loving relationship.

Hamlet and Oedipus
Words: 2904 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 82500506

Oedipal Hamlet Of all the great works of William Shakespeare, arguably his masterpiece is Hamlet. It is also perhaps his most famous work. People who have never seen a production or read it still have a vague understanding about the play's basic plot. This is of course the story of a young prince of Denmark who is mourning for his recently dead father, also named Hamlet who may or may

Perspectives and Commitments
Words: 580 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 17516599

Socrates, "The unexamined life is not worth living (" It is for this reason that a critical examination of our most fundamental beliefs about truth and reality whether right or wrong becomes an important undertaking ( The examination of major life perspectives challenges as well as helps us to better establish many of our own assumptions about life ( We should all be concerned with how different views of

Clinicians Have Always Been Reminded
Words: 4252 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 33632219

He can then be influenced to live what he now understands but has yet to do. The therapist or doctor must encourage the patient or awaken his social interest and raise his level of energy along with it. By developing a genuine human relationship with the patient, the therapist or doctor can re-establish the basic form of social interest, which the patient can use in transferring it to others.