Good And Bad About Religious Diversity Essay

Length: 3 pages Sources: 3 Subject: Mythology - Religion Type: Essay Paper: #40265235 Related Topics: Global Civilization, Exclusionary Rule, Assimilation, Android
Excerpt from Essay :


Diversity and Pluralism

Is Pluralism the Best Outcome for Society?

Is Pluralism the Best Outcome for Society?

Diana Eck (1997) takes great pains to distinguish between diversity and pluralism, as it relates to the religions practiced in the United States. The word 'diversity' simply means that Americans practice more than one religion, but a religious pluralism implies an ongoing effort by each faith to engage with each other to negate the negative outcomes often associated with diversity. For example, Eck (1997) list three philosophies individuals may turn to when faced with religious diversity: exclusion, assimilation, and pluralism. An exclusionary philosophy demands that members of other religions, should they desire a life in America, strip themselves of their religious affiliation if it differs from the dominant religious faith in America, i.e., Christianity. A person supporting an assimilation philosophy would welcome diversity, but only if immigrants promised to quickly adopt a Christian faith after settling in America. By contrast, a pluralistic philosophy not only welcomes diversity, but also invites non-Christian faiths to engage in the American discourse without losing their unique identities.

Eck (1997) argues that religious pluralism in America is the ideal outcome, based in part on the negative social outcomes that can occur when diversity is treated using exclusion or assimilation. Diversity, unfortunately, can exist side by side with intolerance....


Religious ghettos, for example, have existed in the U.S. In the past. Religious tolerance alone, according to Eck (1997), is not enough to create a pluralistic society. Direct and purposeful engagement is required, with the goal of acknowledging, accepting, and valuing diversity. Pluralism requires the recognition of the common ground rules encoded in the First Amendment, while bringing to the table both differences and similarities in beliefs and practices. Striving for a religious pluralism therefore requires learning about and accepting differences, which will result in the creation of a more complex and richly-textured society. Eck (1997) sees no downside to this goal.

A slightly more pessimistic view of pluralism was presented by Thomas McFaul (2006). His treatise on religious diversity and pluralism also used three outcomes: exclusion, pluralism, and inclusivism. His definition of exclusion mirrors Eck's (1997), however, pluralism from his perspective is the practice of learning how to tolerate and accept each other's differences. The outcome of religious pluralism is a more productive society as the destructiveness of exclusion is actively negated through tolerance. This would be possible if religious leaders identified and emphasized the common ethical principles espoused by the world's religions. In contrast, Inclusivism strives to move beyond pluralism to discover a common worldview. This is accomplished by seeking a common greater Truth, thereby rendering religious differences irrelevant.

Both Eck (1997) and…

Sources Used in Documents:


Dick, P.K. (1968). Do androids dream of electric sheep? New York, NY: Ballantine Books.

Eck, D.L. (1997). From diversity to pluralism. In: On Common Ground. New York, NY: Columbia University Press. Retrieved from

McFaul, T.R. (2006). Religion in the future global civilization. The Futurist, 40(5), 30-6.

Cite this Document:

"Good And Bad About Religious Diversity" (2014, December 03) Retrieved January 20, 2022, from

"Good And Bad About Religious Diversity" 03 December 2014. Web.20 January. 2022. <>

"Good And Bad About Religious Diversity", 03 December 2014, Accessed.20 January. 2022,

Related Documents
Virtual Religious Service Islam Is a Religion
Words: 1447 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 98705019

Virtual Religious Service Islam is a religion of great misconceptions and of immense misunderstanding. It was because of this same notion that this religion in particular was of great interest. With all the negative publicity that Islam receives in the media, people only get exposed to the violent extremists that represent a minute minority of this religion. A picture of violence and death is flashed on the television daily, forcing many

Cultural Diversity in Organizations Organization
Words: 4681 Length: 17 Pages Topic: Anthropology Paper #: 71138902

The solutions are numerous and more diversified. Knowledge is crucial for business success. There are two types of knowledge: explicit or tacit. The explicit type is easily codified, stored and transmitted to other individuals. As opposed to the former, the tacit one is embedded in people. The size of the tacit knowledge is proportional to the diversity of the workplace. Therefore, organizations face the increasing challenge today of finding ways

How Diversity Functions in the Organization
Words: 920 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Human Resources Paper #: 82340174

Simons and Rowland (2011) seek to explore the difference between functional and social diversity in organizations. They begin with the premise that the existing literature does not adequately explore the differences between these two types of diversity. So the first issue that they raise is with respect to solidifying a definition for the two concepts. In this way, the basic concept is to examine the existing studies to "identify areas

Appreciating Diversity in a Hospital Setting
Words: 1295 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 62709592

Cultural Diversity Healthcare providers deal with people and family during stressful and difficult situations. Professionals delivering palliative care must understand how culture and religious background affect this interaction. The provision of a favorable healing environment is possible via the understanding of culture and religion. How cultural diversity affects the quality of services and health outcomes Regardless of the similarities, fundamental variations among people arise from nationality, culture, ethnicity, as well as from personal

Cultural Diversity Issues
Words: 675 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Culture Paper #: 69969007

From comes the news story of Western Michigan University Bronson School of Nursing receiving $2 million in grant money for scholarships to students who are from different cultural backgrounds so that a more diverse culture of student nurses can be achieved (VanTimmeren, 2017). As Bryan (2014) points out, culture is very important in this day and age because it informs people’s perspectives and values about what is good and

Cultural Diversity As an African-American
Words: 2313 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Race Paper #: 41403313

Literature classes focus mainly on the works of dead white guys, and science talks about the accomplishments of dead white guys. While there are token mentions of the works of other races, they are not given equal representation. Furthermore, many of the classics chosen contain antiquated attitudes about race. However, I am against censorship. Stories do not lose their value because of discriminatory depictions of African-Americans; instead they capture