Drug-associated psychoses and criminal responsibility in law
✍️ How to write this paper — tools & examples ▾
Health Care Law Relating to Psychiatry
Drug-Associated Psychoses and Criminal Responsibility
Andrew Carroll and Bernadette McSherry
Behavioral Sciences & the Law, Sep/Oct2008, Vol. 26 Issue 5,
The insanity defense exists in a variety of forms across Anglo-American jurisdictions.
Many jurisdictions follow a version of the established M'Naghten Rules (M'Naghten's Case, 1843), which refers to a fault of cause coming from an illness of the mind. For many years, the law has struggled with how to allocate criminal accountability to those affected by drugs. An intricate system of rules relating to voluntary and involuntary intoxication and crimes of specific and general intent has come about. The law draws a difference when conveying criminal responsibility to those who commit crimes while experiencing psychotic signs. If the symptoms are thought to come about because of ingesting drugs, which is an external cause, the criminal is usually convicted of the crime. If the symptoms arise from a mental illness, which is an internal cause, the offender may be afforded a defense of insanity. In reality, making such a distinction can often be difficult. There are difficulties in determining criminal accountability when the use of drugs is followed by the appearance of a psychotic illness procedure that then persists to have a sovereign existence even in the lack of the ongoing substance use.
There is a mounting amount of case law that deals with conveying accountability to those suffering from such disorders of mental state that has led to varied results. Even though a wide variety of advances have been accepted in various jurisdictions, there are three extensive approaches to the issue that can be distinguished. These are liberal, conservative, and intermediate. The major purpose of this article was to look at the key concerns for the law, expert witnesses, and policy makers that follow from these approaches.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.