Skip to main content
Term Paper Undergraduate 1,639 words

Samuel and Herodotus: contrasting views of kingship and history

~9 min read Literature
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
Essay 1,639 words

Herodotus Sam

Views of kingship, visions of prophesy, versions of democracy: The Greek and Hebraic -- the Old Testament vision of Samuel vs. The father of history Herodotus' Histories

Herodotus, the Greek "Father of History," provides a secular rather than a sacred interpretation of why historical events transpire, over the course of the historical events leading to and during the Persian Wars. This point-of-view may be contrasted to the moral gloss of provided the author of the Hebraic book of Samuel. In the Hebrew Bible God's prophecy is conveyed to the alleged author, the prophet himself. God's words seem both to foresee and foreshadow what will occur, as well as to convey a predestined cast to the events that transpire, given the Israeli people's demand for a king. But both Herodotus and Samuel believe that history does not evolve randomly, nor does it evolve as a web of amoral and mutually interactive social, political, and economic forces, as a modern historian might.

Neither author endorses conventional and autocratic kingship. But for Samuel, historical events evolve out of 'stories' and out of a narrative overly imposed by the moral views of the narrator. Herodotus has a moral slant, which he sees as manifest in the natural, lived texture of human existence and the demands for democracy in the human condition, and specifically in the Greek as opposed to the barbarian heart. But he does not locate this moral slant as part of a prophetic, preordained divine order. In contrast, Samuel attributes the fabric of the narrative of story of kingship over the course the whole history of Israel to the morality of the one true God, as revealed in the words of the prophets, and the failings of the people of Israel to heed that God's call not to have a king.

In his tales of the battle of Marathon, Herotodus always sees the morality of history as rooted in the superior system of democratic governance of the Greeks, as opposed to the Persians, rather than the gods of either of these peoples. Herodotus does suggest that through prophesy, the direction of history can be possibly suggested, even divined, but this is because of the secular moral failings of the Greek's enemies, not because the Persians are less moral individuals. Herodotus' moral views in a secular political context are evidenced in his book "The Campaign of Xerxes." The most famous aspect of the Persian campaign is Herodotus' allegation that the Persian leaders dug trenches behind the fighting men, so as to prevent them from saving their individual lives. This anecdote is meant to show how although the Greeks fought willingly to the death to spare their own territories and to win glory for a cause and land they believed in, while the Persian warriors were coerced into war.

Xerxes, unlike the pluralistic makeup of the Greek leadership of nations, is shown to be a tyrant and a madman, much like Samuel's Saul during his declining years. Only Xerxes persecutes soldiers as well as citizens, during a war, away from their own native land.

1,100 Words Hidden
When Xerxes is on his campaign, he decides to dig a canal, and this "was because of excessive great-mindedness that Xerxes ordered the canal dug,"…
Key Concepts in This Paper
Herodotus Samuel kingship prophecy Persian Wars Hebrew Bible autocracy ancient history
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2004). Samuel and Herodotus: contrasting views of kingship and history. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/essay/herodotus-sam-views-of-kingship-57342

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.