Human Stem Cell Medical - Term Paper

Length: 17 pages Sources: 6 Subject: Genetics Type: Term Paper Paper: #11610140 Related Topics: Human Cloning, Muscular System, Human Brain, Genetics
Excerpt from Term Paper :

This bill was sent to the U.S. Senate and set for vote mirroring a bill previously passed by the House during the Summer of 2003 which failed to pass the Senate because of vehement disagreement that was even "within the parties over the prohibition of therapeutic cloning.(National Legislation Concerning Human and Reproductive Cloning, 2004; paraphrased) As of the date of the report on legislation eight U.S. states had passed laws that explicitly prohibited reproductive cloning using human embryos and another five U.S. states have placed a prohibition on cloning for any purpose whatsoever with 22 other U.S. states introducing bills outlawing the reproductive cloning of humans. (Ibid; paraphrased) Patenting laws for genetics allow inventors to patent genetics but only specific genetic factors may be patented and inventors are required to:

1) Identify novel genetic sequences;

2) Specify the sequence's product, 3) Specify how the product functions in nature --i.e. its use; and 4) Enable one skilled in the field to use the sequence for its stated purpose.

The USPTO issued out patents relating to gene fragments due to the fact that the full sequence and function of the gene is not known. The gene fragments are 300 to 500 base and are referred to as sequence tags (ESTs) which represent only about 10 to 30% of the cDNA while the genomic genes may be often ten to twenty times larger than the cDNA. The cDNA is a molecule that is laboratory manufactured version of a gene with only the information rich regions and it is these that provide the capability for researchers in the genome field to go forward to the important areas of the biology. There has been much controversy among scientists and with most scientists urging the USPTO that the broad patenting of the human genome should not be done at this state of research.

I. Implications of Diamond v. Chakrabarty (1980)

Diamond v. Chakrabarty was decided by the Supreme Court and was a case dealing with man-made, genetically-engineered bacteria capable of breaking down crude oil and having significant value in the treatment of oil spills. The Patent Office allowed method claims for producing the bacteria and for a combination of a floating carrier and the bacteria, but it rejected claims for the new bacteria itself. According to the examiner's decision statutory subject matter does not govern living things and the bacteria were living things and not subject under Section 101. Accompanying the 1952 act are the Committee Reports that inform the reader that the statutory subject matter intended by Congress to be included was: "anything under the sun that is made by man." The same year as the case Diamond v. Chakrabarty, 1989) the Bayh-Dole Act was passed in order that patent rights be granted to universities and other recipients of grants and other receiving or using federal funds.

IV. Implications of Later Cases

The case that followed Chakrabarty was Diehr's Rubber Molding. In this case Diehr and Lutton were inventors of a method used in operation of molding presses manufacturing rubber items such as car tires. The method that they used "produced properly cured rubber articles by ensuring that the articles remained in the press for the proper time so that they were not either over-processed or under-processed. It did this by continually monitoring the actual temperature in the mold and repeatedly calculating the cure time using a well-known formula, the Arrhenius equation." (Legal Protection of Digital Information, 2006) The claim was rejected by the examiner because he believed that the men were stating a type of computer programming claim. However the CCPA reversed and held that a claim that is staked upon a process or method does not depend on gaining validity under 35 USC 101 because if the claim is drawn upon 'subject matter' it does not become non-statutory simply because a computer is part of the execution process. If the rejection of a claim is solely due to the fact a computer program is involved this is not supported in law due to the broadness of the issue. The court ruled that this must be reversed because it did not have its basis in the law." (Legal Protection of Digital Information, 2006; paraphrased)

V. Free Market System Impacts

Impacts to the free market are positive in that "Gene patents are allowed because of the benefits that these patents can provide to the patentee.

One of these benefits is that gene patents can be seen as an incentive to encourage research by scientists. The research required to conduct studies is expensive, and researchers need a way...


Patents and licensing fees provide a way for companies and researchers to regain the funds spent on studies. Some believe that researchers would be less likely to invest in research if there was not a way to regain some of the money spent on the research (Hill, 2003, "Patents, Medicine," 2002). In this way patents can help to protect against market failure and foster innovation (Walpole, Dawkins, Sinden, O'Leary, 2003). Also, funds generated by patents can be reinvested in future research." (Koporc, nd)

Koporc,. further states: "Gene patents are also widely defended as a means of free enterprise ("Patents, Medicine," 2002). As a researcher puts his or her time and effort into creating something, he or she may deserve to reap the benefits from such a discovery. This argument would support licensing fees and restrictive access to the invention. In this understanding of the role of gene patents, research and drug development is similar to any other business, which is encouraged to make a profit from its endeavors. This view may seem harsh when considering that the inventions being patented can directly impact human health, but it is a principle found throughout the business world and is highly valued in the United States today.

Koporc states that: "Another argument that supports gene patenting states that patents are important because they encourage the sharing of information and innovations (Walpole et al., 2003, Hill, 2003, "Patents, Medicine," 2002). Once a patent is granted for an innovation, that innovation becomes available to the public ("Patents, Medicine," 2002). This required sharing of information would prevent researchers from hoarding information for their own benefit. This requirement could provide other companies and researchers with databases of relevant information and the potential to research that product further." There is a dilemma presented in the patenting of the human stem cell in that much of the stem cell application is technological which if protected by patent would bar the release of the information and effectively bar research or use by any other than those who could afford to pay the patentee. (Caulfield, 2003) reveals that there are concerns in relation to patenting of stem cells. The patent to the "Primate Embryonic Stem Cell" is retained by the Wisconsin Alumni Research Fund. In the U.S. where government policy state that research is only to be done on stem cell lines already in existence these stem cell lines are important and they are valuable. The owners of the stem cell lines effectively have a monopoly because new stem cells are now lawful at this time for collection. (Caulfield, 2003

VI. What Ways Do Patents Objectify Human Dignity?

Because of the potentiality of human stem cell research in radical science and eugenics groups the human dignity factor is objectified in view of the ethnic cleansing goals of some in society, although let it be noted that not all who forge the path in eugenics are completely radical and it is said that many of those who study eugenics do not believe in any type of force or coercion. Another problem is with the factor of 'ownership' of human stem cell lines and specifically of the human embryo by corporations, organizations, or individuals in that 'ownership' of any part or whole of a human being is inherently believed by most to be wrong. The Human Genetics Alert publication in the article entitled: "Why Should I be Concerned About Human Genetics" states that:

It is hard to see how creating embryos purely as a source of biological raw material (ES cells) is compatible with respect: it seems part of the trend of turning human life into a commodity. (2006)

Further stated is that:

The commercialization of human biological samples has also led to the exploitation of indigenous peoples. Several cell lines from indigenous tribes have been patented by U.S. government institutions, without the consent of the people from whom the samples were derived, although some of these patents were withdrawn, following protests by the tribespeople. Concern over such 'biopiracy' has led countries such as India to try to restrict foreign scientists' access to their wealth of human genetic diversity."

VII. Is there a just way of thinking about intellectual property law?

According to the Hugo Ethics Committee statement on Stem Cells (2004) in its…

Sources Used in Documents:


O'Connor, Sean M. (nd) Intellectual Property Rights and Stem Cell Research: Who Owns the Medical Breakthroughs?

Kadereit, Suzanne & Hines, Pamela J. (nd) Overview of Stem Cell Research New England Law Journal 2005 Mar 28. Online available at

Chadwick, Ruth et al. (2004)HUGO Ethics Committee Statement of Stem Cells (2004) November

Legal Protection of Digital Information (2006) Chapter 5: Software-Based Inventions Online available at:.
Brian Gargano, The Quagmire of DNA Patents: Are DNA Sequences More than Chemical Compositions of Matter?, 2005 Syracuse Sci. & Tech. L. Rep. 3, 5 (2005) ("With the advent of recombinant DNA technology and advanced techniques in DNA sequencing, it became possible to identify and isolate individual genes.... A 'genome' is the set of all DNA and DNA sequences in an organism, including its genes."), available at
Koporc, Colleen B. (nd) Gene Patents: Do They Need Reform? Creighton University Online available at: r/Papers/Gene%20Patents_Koporc.doc
Barton, John H. (2000) Rational Limits on Genomic Patents. Nature Biotechnology 18-805 (2000). Online available at
Genesis of Eden Diversity Encyclopedia (2006) Online available at
Why Should I be Concerned About Human Genetics (nd) Online available at

Cite this Document:

"Human Stem Cell Medical -" (2006, November 15) Retrieved December 1, 2022, from

"Human Stem Cell Medical -" 15 November 2006. Web.1 December. 2022. <>

"Human Stem Cell Medical -", 15 November 2006, Accessed.1 December. 2022,

Related Documents
Human Body Is Made of 206 Bones
Words: 1775 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Anatomy Paper #: 16392376

human body is made of 206 bones and an estimated 500 muscles, most of which are skeletal muscles attached from one bone to another. While one end of the skeletal muscles attaches to a relatively stationary bone, the other attaches to a movable bone. Some of the major bones of the body and muscles attached to each include Tibia -- which is one of the bones in the lower leg

Human Body Cavity the Internal
Words: 330 Length: 1 Pages Topic: Anatomy Paper #: 16317327

The large intestine begins near the lower coils of the small intestines but then ascends up the right side and bend back over the top of the highest loop of the small intestine. Several layers of muscle and sinewy tissue wrap around the area housing the internal organs (Iazzetti & Rigutti, 2007). The other organs located in the major body cavity include the bladder, gall bladder, and pancreas. In addition,

Human Body Decomposition Over Time
Words: 3187 Length: 12 Pages Topic: Anatomy Paper #: 76839575

A decomposition does not end after the soft tissue has disappeared. The skeleton also has a decompositional rate that is based on the loss of organic (collagen) and inorganic components. Some of the inorganic compounds we use to determine the length of time since death include calcium, potassium and magnesium. (ibid) In a temperate climate for example, it normally takes ten to twelve years to decompose fully to a skeleton. Therefore,

Human Body Have Revealed New
Words: 2139 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Careers Paper #: 86504635

..). Because of these problems, employees working under these conditions also suffer from more vehicle related accidents. In particular, individuals working evening and night shifts are more likely to fall asleep on their way home after work. Statistics demonstrate that "...41% of extended hours employees reported nodding off while driving compared with 28% of day workers" (Extended hours...). What this effectively suggests is that firefighters and first responders face a

Human Body and Diseases
Words: 882 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Disease Paper #: 92657912

Human Health and Disease How could the information learned about a disease's epidemiology be used to protect public health? What kind of epidemiological information would a public health official want to know about this disease? What actions might they take based on this information? The epidemiology will look at factors such as demographics, causes, patterns and the impact the disease is having. This is used to determine the symptoms, educate the general

EVA Kwong and the Human Body Eastern
Words: 1214 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Art  (general) Paper #: 90706521

EVA Kwong and the Human Body Eastern philosophy and culture are highly driven by an underlying sense of animism, which denotes that there is life and interconnectedness in all things. The trees, rocks, soil, air and even our own bodies are seen as connected on a continuum that is imbued with the energy of life. This is perhaps the underlying principle defining the work of Hong Kong-born sculptor Eva Kwong. Indeed,