Immunizations And Public Org India Research Paper

Length: 12 pages Sources: 1+ Subject: Disease Type: Research Paper Paper: #13081055 Related Topics: India, Public Personnel Administration, Vaccination, Vaccines
Excerpt from Research Paper :

The resulting information points to the idea that there are more factors at play than simply developing and then providing vaccination doses to developing nations. The action plans that produce better results are paramount to success, and factors of social significance are just as important as or more important than having enough clinicians or clinics to administer the immunizations. The idea that community based and local volunteers would be needed to help administer and do family teaching about immunizations in India is also supported by Prinja, Gupta, Singha & Kumar who stress that in their large trial, associated with timely vaccinations of children in India with the DPT vaccination the results were far better when local volunteers were recruited as the presence of these individuals as well as their supportive education helped individuals better understand the need for their children to get the vaccination (Web-97). Another concept that is raised in the literature as a potential and real barrier to improved urban immunization rates is a special focus on migrant populations and especially new migrants to the area. It is noted by Kusuma, Kumari, Pandav & Gupta that as the overall economic and education levels of the migrant mothers improved over time immunization rates for children improved but new migrants were a particularly vulnerable population (Web-1326).

While the primary focus of the above to research traditions stress interpersonal communication with trusted volunteers from the region as the most effective tool in very hard to reach areas Obregon, Chitnis, Morry, Feek, Bates, Galway & Ogden stress that it is usually a combination strategy, with regard to awareness campaigns that is most effective. According to Obregon et al. The research conducted for polio eradication communication; "…illustrates how evidence-based and planned communication strategies -- such as sustained media campaigns, intensive community and social mobilization, interpersonal communication and political and national advocacy combined -- have contributed to reducing polio incidence in these countries" (Web-624). The work goes on to stress that planned communication strategies, including all of those mentioned above help by, "…mobilizing social networks and leaders; creating political will; increasing knowledge; ensuring individual and community-level demand; overcoming gender barriers and resistance to vaccination; and reaching out to the poorest and marginalized populations" (Web-624).

While interpersonal communication may not be the most efficient rate of either education or compliance with immunizations the issue bears a more expansive look. The reason for this is because the research, from past experiments, clearly indicates that at this stage in the game, i.e. when much has been gained with many of the immunization rates the most important group of unimmunized individuals are all part of a marginalized social group. Among these individuals are multiple barriers to access but overall and sense of mistrust for outsiders. This social barrier can be fundamentally overcome by allowing a member of the same said group to participate in education and implementation of immunizations by simply providing appropriate social cues about the importance of immunizations and most importantly from a trusted "inside" voice.

In another article addressing the need to better educate health care providers regarding the implementation of immunization programs an existing system was measured. The system (ISDS) is a visiting supervisory program where visiting supervisors go to clinic locations teach clinicians and support staff proper procedural process and provide corrective action for incorrect procedures. The interventions recur three times and are relatively costly, due in large part to personnel and travel expenses. The work attempts to determine the cost and effectiveness of this system in an attempt to recommend the system be adopted locally, to reduce costs and possibly improve outcomes as effectiveness was rated very high but over half the cost of the ISDS program was associated with personnel and travel expenses (Web-221).

Sahu, Pradhan, Jayachandran & Khan also point out that access is exceedingly important but that as far as India goes there are also several sets of unknowns even when the researchers used due diligence to provide the most factors in their assessment. The researchers note that though the 2010 90-100% immunization...


There is a considerable, unexplained variation in the immunization coverage between different communities, even in the most complex model used in this study, which could explain the entire heterogeneity of immunization coverage among Indian states" (Web-332).

Conclusions establish what we know and what we don't know

From this relatively concise but comprehensive review of literature on the overall immunization issue as well as the Indian issue with regard to immunization rates and hold out communities there are several things that we do know. We do know that India is unlikely to meet international and national deadlines for the immunization of 90-100% of all children for all the desired disease types and that there is still much administrative work to be done to resolve the issue, with when this goal will be met. We also know that much of the work above is focused on single vaccination types, though there are a few exceptions. We also know that the literature is clear that special attention needs to be paid to small hold-out populations that produce serious risk for low level endemic disease that can cause serious disease outbreaks. We also know that a combined effort utilizing a list of education and communication tools is the most effective manner in which large increases can be seen in vaccination rates. Lastly, the literature is very clear on the fact that local volunteers capable of developing interpersonal communication with marginalized populations are one of the most effective interventions that can be done in India and this is evident in many research studies.

We do not know if the literatures' reflection of single vaccine focused programs are the standard for vaccination. It would seem that a combined vaccination effort would address access and the fact that opportunities for giving a single dose of any one vaccination are limited and therefore a combined effort seems logical. This perception may be a trick of the literature, and not be the case but there is limited mention in the literature of the combined tactic, as is common in developed nations. This also seems to be despite the Indian national interest in a whole range of vaccination standards. Another issue that may be a party to this perception of single vaccine focused campaigns is the fact that many of the programs associated with vaccination that are not administered by the local administrations themselves are supported by non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and other charities who might have a particular disease eradication focus. Administrative focus on this issue seems paramount as opportunities for vaccination, especially in disenfranchised populations seem to be very few and therefore a combined vaccination effort would seem logical. Lastly, though this may not be possible in all areas due to the nature of Indian Education, though very recently the government adopted compulsory free education for all children ages 6-14 (Pokharel Web) a discussion of compulsory immunizations for entrance into school might need to be addressed. At the very least school site mobile clinics may need to be developed and evaluated.


This work discovered a couple of significant missing pieces in a better understanding of the administration and delivery of immunizations in India. First the work clearly illuminates that the literature does not describe combined efforts or multi-viral immunization schedules and visits, and second that the issue of compulsory education entrance immunizations has not been discussed with regard to India. Due to the fact that the first unknown could simply be related to the literature and the fact that most research works are conducted on limited focuses or it could be that some immunization standards are simply single minded, this work will close with a proposal for a research project that looks at the willingness of parents to accept a compulsory immunization policy. The immunization policy would include the five immunization types that the Indian government sees as most essential to meeting high rates of immunizations; tuberculosis, measles, whooping cough, diphtheria and polio (Sahu, Pradhan, Jayachandran & Khan Web-332). The proposed immunization program would be adopted as part of the new compulsory free school programs and clinics would be provided at school or near school to provide immunizations to those who have not had them. I must reiterate that this is a research focused not on actually implementing such a program but a guide for future implementation tactics and policy review. The impetus for this type of research would be to assess the willingness of Indian parents to allow the implementation of such a program, as compulsory vaccination has been one of the major ways that developed nations have achieved such high rates of immunization and maintained them for so long. The work…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Ali, Hammad, Nicholas Zwar & Jo Wild. "Improving Childhood Immunization Coverage Rates: Evaluation of a Divisional Program." Australian Family Physician. 38 (10) (October 2009): 833-835. <>. (10 November 2010).

Arora, Narendra K., Sanjay Chaturvedi & Rajib Dasgupta. "Global Lessons from India's Poliomyelitis Elimination Campaign." Bulletin of the World Health Organization (2010) 88-232 -- 234 (10 November 2010).

"Global Routine Vaccination Coverage, 2009" MMWR Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report. 59 (42) (October 29, 2010) 1368-1371. <>. (10 November 2010)

Hull, Harry F. The Future of Polio Eradication Lancet Infectious Diseases (2001) 1 299 -- 303. Mark, Catherine & Jose g. Rigau-Perez. "The World's First Immunization Campaign: The Spanish Smallpox Vaccine Expedition, 1803 -- 1813." Bulletin of the History of Medicine (March 2009), 83 (1) 63-94. <> (15 November 2010).
Pokharel, Krishna. "India Mandates Children Go to School Compulsory Education for All Children Ages 6 to 14 Is Part of Move to Harness Economic Potential." Wall Street Journal India (1 April 2010) <> (18 November 2010)
Suraratdecha, Chutima, Venkata Ramana, Satish Kaipilyawar, JVG Krishnamurthy, Srilatha Sivalenka, Naveena Ambatipudi, Sanjay Gandhi, K Umashankarc & James Cheyne. "Cost and Effectiveness Analysis of Immunization Service Delivery Support in Andhra Pradesh, India." Bulletin of the World Health Organization (March 2008) 86 (3) 221-228. <> (10 November 2010)

Cite this Document:

"Immunizations And Public Org India" (2010, November 29) Retrieved June 26, 2022, from

"Immunizations And Public Org India" 29 November 2010. Web.26 June. 2022. <>

"Immunizations And Public Org India", 29 November 2010, Accessed.26 June. 2022,

Related Documents
Contrast Between Healthcare Systems in Developed and Developing Countries...
Words: 2099 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Children Paper #: 23062620

Health Care Systems India Malnutrition, Mortality, Malaria: Health Care in India Perri Klass in her article "India" describes a situation when she is unable to diagnose a case of tuberculosis in a South Asian child. As a pediatrician, her repertoire of knowledge of first world diseases is unable to assist her amongst the medical travails of the children of India. Klass describes scenarios where she is unable to comprehend the magnitude of

MMR Vaccine and Autistic-Spectrum Disorders
Words: 6800 Length: 21 Pages Topic: Disease Paper #: 49586616

Controversy with vaccines, adverse reactions of the MMR vaccine and the negative publicity surrounding it SHAPE Measles, Mumps and Rubella Vaccine: Absence of Evidence for Link to Autistic-Spectrum Disorders Henry K. Nguyen, MD Candidate Increased incidence of measles, mumps, and rubella is directly due to controversies regarding the measles, mumps, and rubella vaccine despite the absence of data supporting a correlation between this combined vaccine and development of autism. Correspondence to: Mentor: Dr. Anshu Kacker 5650 including Abstracts Increased incidence of

Is Healthcare a Right
Words: 3418 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 56544496

Along the way, scholarly resources such as books, peer-reviewed journal articles and reputable websites will be used to create or support the opinions or answers given. The three questions that will be answered will include what basic types of healthcare everyone should have access to and why, a choice from thirteen risk factors that impact infectious disease and a recitation of how nurses can play a part in one

Child Abuse How Large Is
Words: 4401 Length: 16 Pages Topic: Children Paper #: 46242485

The second includes verbal and emotional assaults including persistent patterns of belittling, denigrating, scapegoating, and other nonphysical, but clearly hostile or rejecting behaviors, such as repeated threats of beatings, sexual assault, and abandonment. The third, residual, category includes other forms of emotional abuse such as attempted sexual or physical assaults; throwing something at a child but missing; withholding shelter, sleep, or other necessities as punishment, and economic exploitation (p.11). According

U.S. Has Not Signed the U.N. Convention
Words: 4141 Length: 15 Pages Topic: Government Paper #: 5125089

U.S. has not Signed the U.N. Convention Treaty on the Rights of Children This paper presents a detailed examination of the Treaty on the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Children. The writer explores the treaty and the nations that have signed it. The writer than delves into some of the reasons the United States has not signed it. This paper is written from a legal standpoint therefore there

Epidemic Polio Epidemic of the 1950s the
Words: 1192 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Disease Paper #: 80125701

Epidemic Polio Epidemic of the 1950s The concept of epidemic regarding infectious diseases is a rather simple concept to understand: over a period of time, an infectious disease spreads within a population -- local or otherwise -- causing, in excess, results that far surpass human expectation of said disease. In the case of poliomyelitis, nobody expected the outbreak to have caused such massive impact on society, let alone the fact that there