McDonald's vs KFC: Five Forces, Balanced Scorecard & SWOT
This paper presents a comprehensive strategic analysis of two global fast food giants, McDonald's and KFC. Using Michael Porter's Five Forces Model, the paper examines competitive dynamics in the global fast food industry, including rivalry among incumbents, threats from new entrants and substitutes, and the bargaining power of suppliers and customers. The paper then evaluates each company's past, current, and projected performance across the four dimensions of the Balanced Scorecard: customer relations, internal business processes, financial performance, and learning and growth. A SWOT analysis follows, identifying core strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats for each firm. The paper concludes with strategic recommendations drawn from the Baldrige National Quality Program framework to help both companies strengthen their market positions and sustain long-term competitiveness.
- Introduction to McDonald's and KFC: Background and overview of both companies
- Porter's Five Forces Analysis of the Global Fast Food Industry: Industry competitive dynamics across five dimensions
- Balanced Scorecard for McDonald's: McDonald's performance across four scorecard areas
- Balanced Scorecard for KFC: KFC's scorecard across customers, finance, and growth
- SWOT Analysis for McDonald's and KFC: Internal strengths and weaknesses, external opportunities and threats
- Strategic Recommendations: Actionable strategies for both companies going forward
- Conclusion: Summary of findings and strategic outlook
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper applies three well-established analytical frameworks — Porter's Five Forces, the Balanced Scorecard, and SWOT analysis — in a coherent sequence, moving from industry-level analysis to firm-level evaluation to strategic prescription.
- Direct comparisons between McDonald's and KFC are woven throughout each section, giving the analysis a consistent dual-company structure rather than treating the two firms in isolation.
- The recommendations section draws explicitly on the Baldrige National Quality Program, grounding strategic advice in a recognized quality management framework rather than relying solely on opinion.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates multi-framework strategic analysis: the student stacks three distinct management tools (Five Forces, Balanced Scorecard, SWOT) to build progressively from macro-environmental scanning to internal capability assessment to actionable strategy. This layered approach shows how external competitive forces relate to internal performance gaps and ultimately inform specific recommendations.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with company introductions, establishing context for both firms. It then moves outward to industry analysis via Porter's Five Forces before turning inward with Balanced Scorecard evaluations for each company. The SWOT analyses synthesize internal and external factors, and the recommendations section ties all prior findings together. The conclusion summarizes key takeaways. Each section builds logically on the previous one, making the argument flow easy to follow.
Introduction to McDonald's and KFC
McDonald's
McDonald's is the world's leading fast food chain, currently operating more than 34,000 restaurants and outlets in 119 countries. It is an American multinational corporation headquartered in Oak Brook, United States. Since its inception, McDonald's has spread its business network into all major markets of the world. At present, McDonald's enjoys a huge customer base, serving an average of 69 million customers every day (McDonald's, 2013). McDonald's is ranked among the top fast food brands in the world, having established a strong brand image through high-quality products and highly efficient customer services. Its major product offerings include hamburgers (Big Mac), Chicken McNuggets, Quarter Pounder, chicken sandwiches, French fries, soft drinks, soups, desserts, milkshakes, breakfast items, coffee, and salads. McDonald's currently employs more than 1.7 million people across its outlets, restaurants, production units, and offices around the globe (About McDonald's, 2011).
McDonald's has grown its business network through self-ownership and franchising agreements. More than 80% of McDonald's restaurants and outlets are franchised to private businesspeople from local and international markets. It is the world's largest and fastest-growing drive-through and counter-service fast food restaurant chain. Since its expansion into the global market, McDonald's has introduced a large variety of fast food products to meet consumer expectations and remain innovative and competitive. McDonald's has implemented the latest machinery at its production units and advanced enterprise management systems — including inventory management, customer relationship management, and strategic human resource management — across its offices. McDonald's has also received numerous quality and favorite-brand awards and recognitions at the international level (McDonald's, 2013).
KFC (Kentucky Fried Chicken)
KFC (Kentucky Fried Chicken) is a multinational chicken fast food restaurant chain operating more than 17,000 restaurants and outlets in 115 countries. KFC is a subsidiary of Yum! Brands — the leading brand in the global restaurants industry. It was founded in 1930 by Harland Sanders in North Corbin, Kentucky, and its operational headquarters are situated in Louisville, Kentucky. KFC operates with a total workforce of around 190,000 employees. Its successful global expansion can be attributed to a continuous growth strategy that enabled it to expand internationally at a rapid pace through franchising and licensing. KFC's main product offerings include fried chicken (drumstick, breast, thigh, and keel) and its many variations, such as chicken burgers, chicken wraps and sandwiches, crispy chicken strips, and French fries, as well as other fast food products like salads, coleslaw, soft drinks, juices, and desserts. Its most successful product is pressure-fried chicken pieces made with the original recipe seasoning mix (KFC, 2013).
KFC ranks number one among chicken restaurant chains worldwide and number two overall in fast food restaurant chains, behind McDonald's. It is also one of the most liked food brands in the world. The acquisition of KFC by PepsiCo International provided it a competitive advantage along with strategic benefits such as an extensive supply chain and distribution network, a strong brand image, and financial support from a large beverage supplier. Like other top fast food brands, KFC relies on private investors for its business expansion strategies. Currently, more than three-quarters of KFC outlets and restaurants are operated by private businesspeople from home and global markets (KFC, 2013).
Porter's Five Forces Analysis of the Global Fast Food Industry
Michael Porter's Five Forces Model helps organizations analyze the competitive environment within a particular industry. Companies use this model to assess the intensity of competition and design their operational, financial, and marketing strategies accordingly. The five forces analyzed are: rivalry among existing competitors, competition from new entrants, threats of substitute products, the bargaining power of suppliers, and the bargaining power of customers (Kotler, 2010).
Rivalry Among Existing Competitors
The global fast food industry is concentrated among a few large fast food giants and numerous small-scale manufacturers. The top market leaders include McDonald's, KFC, Pizza Hut, Wendy's, Burger King, Starbucks, Dunkin' Donuts, and Yum! Brands. The industry is dominated by McDonald's and KFC, which hold the highest market shares and customer bases. These top brands are known for their menu variety, product quality, and taste (KFC, 2013). The industry also exhibits a form of near-perfect competition in which a large number of small-scale manufacturers have captured a significant portion of the total market share. Top market leaders like McDonald's, KFC, and Pizza Hut pursue growth strategies to maintain their market positions and remain among the top global fast food brands (Blythe & Megicks, 2010).
Competition from New Entrants
The fast food industry has very low barriers to entry, and as a result, more and more businesses are entering the industry seeking to build their brands. These new entrants are direct competitors for existing industry leaders, using various marketing tactics to attract potential customers — including low-price strategies, discounts on special events, and free coupons and memberships (Kurtz, MacKenzie, & Snow, 2010). New entrants succeed in drawing customers away from market leaders by tailoring their products to local lifestyles and eating habits. McDonald's and KFC are able to counter this competition on the basis of product quality and an extensive distribution network. However, due to high manufacturing costs and premium pricing, they are less able to compete in a direct price war with new entrants (Pride & Ferrell, 2012).
Threat from Substitute Products
Although McDonald's, KFC, and other market leaders offer an extensive range of fast food products, various substitute products exist that customers may choose instead. This creates an indirect competitive threat for market leaders. For example, McDonald's milkshakes and soft drinks must compete with brands like Starbucks, Coca-Cola, and Pepsi (McDonald's, 2013). Similarly, KFC's pizza and fried chicken range competes with numerous local and global fast food brands offering fried beef, beef burgers, vegan pizzas, and other alternatives (KFC, 2013).
The Bargaining Power of Suppliers
Suppliers are among the most important stakeholders in the fast food industry. They provide essential raw materials such as wheat, chicken, beef, oil, vegetables, and other ingredients used in production. Due to the large number of fast food manufacturers competing for these inputs, suppliers enjoy considerable bargaining power and are able to demand high prices for premium-quality raw materials (Ellwood, 2002). Top market leaders like McDonald's and KFC have built strong relationships with large-scale suppliers to ensure a continuous supply of raw materials at negotiated prices (Kotler, 2010).
The Bargaining Power of Customers
Consumers in the fast food industry also hold strong bargaining power relative to manufacturers. McDonald's and KFC are long-standing top industry rivals, each attempting to attract the other's customers through high-quality products and promotional offers (About McDonald's, 2011). However, consumers ultimately choose brands that meet or exceed their expectations. Because many brands in the market offer similar products at highly competitive prices, McDonald's and KFC must deploy effective marketing strategies to attract and retain their most valuable customers and generate attractive revenues (Kotler, 2010).
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.