International Pol. Ec. The Four Different Scenarios Essay

Length: 5 pages Sources: 10 Subject: Economics Type: Essay Paper: #93941725 Related Topics: International Political Economy, International, International Economics, International Econ
Excerpt from Essay :

International Pol. Ec.

The four different scenarios laid out by the World Economic Forum in 2009 paint distinctly different visions of the development of global financial markets. The four scenarios are financial regionalism, re-engineered Western centralism, fragmented protectionism and rebalanced multilateralism (Wyman, 2009). Of these four different scenarios, there is evidence late in 2010 that would support the evolution of two of these different scenarios. These scenarios, in particular the one with the most support, will be given primary consideration in this paper. The implications for these scenarios for my chosen company, an IT firm with a local focus, will also be discussed in this paper.

The WEF scenario that fits the world best as of late 2010 is the first scenario, financial regionalism. This scenario relies on post-crisis blame-shifting, something that can be seen in the global political environment at present. The United States has raised serious issues about China's currency manipulation policies, viewing those policies as a significant contributor to global economic recovery (Chan & Ewing, 2010). China takes the same view of the United States, with its efforts at spurring inflation through bond buybacks (Peng, 2010). Germany has also been critical of the U.S. And some of its fellow EU members for their role in the ongoing financial crisis, which some of those members have blamed Germany and its proposals for a credit resolution mechanism for (Euro Intelligence, 2010). Mutual blame among the three major economic regions is one of the key antecedents for the financial regionalism scenario.

One of the other key antecedents is a particular pattern of economic performance in the different regions. For this scenario to arise, emerging market economies would have to have recovered to see growth of around 9%, while Europe and the U.S. remain in a low growth scenario at around 1.2% annual growth. The current estimates for 2011 GDP growth for China, India and Brazil are 11.7%, 11.7% and 8.4% respectively. For the U.S., 2011 growth is estimated to be 3.6% and for the EU 2.1% (IMF, 2010). These figures compare strongly to the ones needed to bring about a financial regionalism scenario, with strong emerging market growth and sluggish growth in Western economies. In addition, China has emerged as a leader among Asian economies, and Asia in general is fast becoming an economically dominant region with most major Asian economies continuing to record strong growth. China has repeatedly rejected, both in terms of politics and economics, the liberalist ideals of democracy, openness, human rights, and free trade. For example, its banking system remains largely state-owned, and therefore to a significant degree immune from the financial crises that have hit the U.S. And European banking systems.

There is no evidence that the U.S. And Euro are no longer going to be reserve currencies. In Asia, the yen has failed to gain traction as a world currency and the yuan cannot be a reserve currency because it is not free-floating. The Euro, however, does face crisis in light of the financial crisis in its peripheral countries. There is also no strong evidence to suggest that the EU is beginning to regulate financial institutions heavily. Most major European nations have for some reason rejected the lessons of Canada and Australia with respect to the value of strong bank regulation.

There is also some evidence to support fragmented protectionism. This scenario describes a world characterized by division, conflict, currency controls and race-to-the-bottom dynamics (Wyman, 2009). The current divisions outlined above, between the U.S., China and Germany in particular, serve...


China in particular is engaged in currency controls as a means to provide its export-based economy with competitive advantage. The relationship between the U.S. And China, once mutually beneficial, may be becoming mutually destructive and will lead to increased conflict in the coming years (Garrett, 2010). There is also evidence that the Eurozone could disintegrate under the pressure of public debt -- at least this is a scenario that Paul Krugman (2010) can envision.

However, global growth predictions are not in line with current reality, as China and other major emerging economies have recovered quickly and strongly from the economic crisis. Economic stagnation is limited primarily to the U.S. And Europe. There are elements of protectionism creeping into political rhetoric, but thus far this has not resulted in any significant protectionist trade policies. We have yet to see significant resource conflicts but one could easily envision that nationalism is increasing, especially among key economic players like the U.S. And Germany.

Re-engineered Western-centrism is rejected because the economic antecedents for this scenario simply do not exist. This scenario relies on slow growth in emerging economies, but that is not the case. There is no evidence of productivity increases and indeed most Western nations are still subject to significant overcapacity. Rebalanced multilateralism is an interest idea, and the underlying economic performance of the U.S. And Europe fits with this scenario. However, the negativity in the current dialogue between the world's major trading nations does not imply that the "global economy will learn from its mistakes through sharing." This scenario could come to pass over time, but for the moment it appears unlikely because it relies too heavily on the world's major economies setting aside ego and working collectively.

Of the four scenarios, the one that is most likely is financial regionalism. The implications of this scenario are that global economic power is going to shift eastward to Asia, with China as the region's leader rather than Japan. Each region is currently seeking its champions. The U.S. will be the default champion of its region even if its growth and governance lag, simply by virtue of its size. Germany looks to be the leader of Europe, and there is evidence that it is acting strongly to ensure that its policies hold the most sway in Europe (Lindsey, 2010). Europe is becoming increasingly inward-looking (Ibid) and is seeking tighter controls on its markets, particularly in light of the debt crisis along its periphery. For its part, the U.S. is maintaining its market democracy paradigm, highlighted by the passage of a relatively toothless financial reform bill.

Eastern markets will be strongest under this scenario with the BRIC nations in particular recording strong growth and building global GDP share to 27%. North America and Europe will see their share of GDP shrink under this scenario. For a local IT company, this means that the domestic market will not offer significant growth. The overcapacity and unemployment that characterize the U.S. economy today will remain a threat going forward. This will put pressure on the company to find innovative ways to grow in a sluggish market.

There are two main strategic options to achieve growth under a no-growth scenario. The first is to find a high growth domestic sector. This option is a challenge because such sectors are few and rely on innovation to attain opportunities. However, if the firm can innovate and find new markets for its IT products and services by introducing new products and services, then the company can attain growth even in a persistently weak economy.

Another option is to expand geographically. Growth is going to be focused on BRIC nations in the coming years. Expanding into these countries is challenging under this scenario, however, as trade flows outside of energy and tourism are reduced. The banking systems in the different blocs are going to be relatively incompatible, which again will make significant expansion into BRIC nations difficult. However, if these challenges can be overcome, possibly through a joint venture or a local partner, then this would be a viable option for growth even in the face of slumping domestic demand.

A final -- and decidedly less attractive -- option, is to scale the business back to reflect a no-growth scenario in the…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited:

Chan, S. & Ewing, J. (2010). Echoing Obama, Bernanke presses China on imbalances. New York Times. Retrieved November 19, 2010 from

Euro Intelligence. (2010). European panic over QE2. Euro Intelligence. Retrieved November 19, 2010 from[tt_news]=2948&tx_ttnews[backPid]=743&cHash=8bec5d30ed

Garrett, G. (2010). G2 in G20: China, the United States and the World after the global financial crisis. Global Policy. Vol. 1 (1) 29-39.

IMF. (2010). Reports for select countries and subjects. IMF. Retrieved November 19, 2010 from

Cite this Document:

"International Pol Ec The Four Different Scenarios" (2010, November 19) Retrieved September 19, 2021, from

"International Pol Ec The Four Different Scenarios" 19 November 2010. Web.19 September. 2021. <>

"International Pol Ec The Four Different Scenarios", 19 November 2010, Accessed.19 September. 2021,

Purpose of

The documents we provide are to be used as a sample, template, outline, guideline in helping you write your own paper, not to be used for academic credit. All users must abide by our "Student Honor Code" or you will be restricted access to our website.

Related Documents
International Finance the Three Companies That Will
Words: 3260 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 42390177

International Finance The three companies that will be evaluated for purchase are LG, Sony and Xiaomi. Some of the report will discuss the individual companies, but a large portion of this report will go into discussing the country situations of these companies. They hail from South Korea, Japan and the People's Republic of China respectively. The differences between these Northeast Asian countries can be significant, and it is these differences that

International Finance in Japan This
Words: 2608 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 84149663

" (2008) It is also reported that the companies and banks are hurting in all economies that are "dollarized" economies" or those in which devaluation of the Dollar is occurring in recent years. While high Dollar inflows first drive growth and production, the capital inflows tend to hurt banking profitability when governments try to "mop up" excessive liquidity and sterilize Dollar inflows in exchange for low-yielding government bonds. China's banks, for

International Finance Conflict and Free
Words: 624 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 72635921

By suggesting that increased amounts of free trade promote a conflict-free international market, McDonald makes a revolutionary argument that may bolster not only the international financial market, but also political and strategic alliances between states. Both unique and significant, McDonald's argument that increased amounts of free trade between states lead to decreased amounts of conflict has strong implications not only for the field of international finance, but also for a

International Finance Currency Risk Arises
Words: 987 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 65357569

The size of the market and its characteristics must be considered, to ensure that there is ample opportunity in the market. The expertise of the firm should be a factor, since expertise in a given market, or type of market, can play a significant role in organizational success. The governmental/legal environment must be carefully considered. Each country has its own approach to FDI, some being more open than others. In

International Finance Islamic Financing - Sukuk Al
Words: 1700 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 89426734

International Finance Islamic Financing - Sukuk Al Murabaha, Sukuk Al Musharaka and Sukuk Al-Wakala Islamic Finance is financing which is compliant with the requirements of the Shari'ah. While the concepts are centuries old, the foundations of Islamic banking and the modern financial tools which have been developed as compliant with Islamic law are relativity recent; early development seen to start in earnest in Egypt in the 1960's (Khan and Mirakhorv, 2005). The

Finance International Finance Questions Acquisition
Words: 757 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 18355820

The risk associated with acquisition is higher, as this includes the price paid for the acquisition and then the cost of managing the operations. However, the acquisition is likely to result in the greatest revenue growth in the short-term. Question 2 - Size and International Opportunities There are certain circumstances in which the size of a firm is not affected by intentional opportunities. If a firm uses strategies such as licensing