Verified Document

International War Crimes Tribunals Why Essay

Also, some may argue that punishing those who simply took orders is immoral in that they had no choice. Furthermore, these tribunals and their hanging of common soldiers does not do much to deter war crimes. According to McMorran, many believe it is unlikely that men and women like Hitler and Stalin would have been deterred by the prospect of a war crimes tribunal. These men did what they did because they actually believed it was right. As one can see, it takes a certain state of mind to be able to wage this kind of war. These men acted as if they were on a crusade. It is unlikely that they would have stopped because they knew a war crimes tribunal was in their future. This model also applies to many of the other acts of aggression that have occurred since World War Two. The Rwandan genocide was fueled by those who believed the extermination of a people group was correct, and the September 11 terrorists also had a higher motivation.

Finally, war crimes tribunals do not necessarily help...

Instead, the tribunals can actually deter the progress of countries working together. Instead of allowing for reconciliation, the tribunals pit one country against another again. Thus, the countries are encouraged to relive their hatred. McMorran suggests that another type of post-war justice system, the truth and reconciliation commissions, are believed by some to be better for the healing of two wounded states.
While war crimes tribunals often result in decisive action against a loosing nation's war criminals, they are not necessarily successful. Because they do not always punish those who are giving orders, deter war crimes, or encourage countries to move on together in peace, they cannot be labeled institutions that work.

Works Cited

McMorran, Chris. "International War Crimes Tribunals." July 2003. Beyond Intractability. 21 October 2008. Beyond Intractability. http://www.beyondintractability.org/essay/int_war_crime_tribunals/

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

McMorran, Chris. "International War Crimes Tribunals." July 2003. Beyond Intractability. 21 October 2008. Beyond Intractability. http://www.beyondintractability.org/essay/int_war_crime_tribunals/
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

International Relations Challenges in Approaching
Words: 3079 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

Conciliation seems to be more to the purpose, if opposing bodies are expected to work together to govern a country. Humphrey said in his study on From Victim to Victimhood, "By contrast, trials have played a much smaller role during political transition and thus have addressed far fewer victims. They have, however, been very important in re-establishing the authority of law and the state" (2003 184) What division of labor

International Law V Torture in
Words: 7379 Length: 25 Document Type: Thesis

S. Congress 2006). Under a military commission's procedures and rules of evidence, the accused may present evidence, cross examine witnesses against him, and respond to evidence presented against him; attend all the sessions of the trial; and have the rights to counsel and self-representation. The bill does not grant him the right to see all the evidence against him to establish his guilt or innocence. It authorizes the Secretary to

Cosmopolitanism International Law and the Persistence of
Words: 1944 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Cosmopolitanism International Law and the Persistence of the Sovereign Nation-State Seyla Benhabib can only point to the European Union as an effective and practical example of transnationalism or post-nationalism in today's world. International law and organizations have certainly become more important than they were in 1945, but integration has proceeded much farther in Europe than any other region of the world. Today, this has become a political, social and cultural arrangement,

Tribunals and Their Importance
Words: 1708 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Why are tribunals very important among two or more countries? If a nation is involved in claims with another nation, the question of how far each nation respects the independent sovereignty of the other and the integrity of its own judicial system arises. To this effect, tribunals play a crucial role of arbitrating the claims between the involved countries while at the same time recognizing and respecting the sovereignty and the

United States Accept/Reject International Criminal
Words: 2465 Length: 6 Document Type: Thesis

"..three asymmetric methods that could be used to exploit the Court: (1) misusing the Court's investigative processes, (2) filing questionable or fraudulent complaints, and (3) manipulating mass media (Austin, W. Chadwick, Kolenc and Anthony Barone, 2006, p. 291)." Finally, the issue of how the court might deal with the problem of international terrorism is not well understood (Yarnold, Barbara, 1991). The court's authority to extradite and prosecute terrorists from third world

United States and the International Criminal Court
Words: 1478 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

United States and the International Criminal Court i request writer "jonsmom2" topic: "The United States International Criminal Court." paper reflect research explain U.S. association ICC. Also briefly examine goals ICC, review U.S. attitude joining outline problems U. The United States and the International Criminal Court The ICC (International Criminal Court) was founded in July of the year 2002 on the day that the Rome Statute which is the founding treaty of the ICC

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now