Lie Detection: Recent Research and Examination
The study, "Early vs. Late Disclosure of Evidence: Effects on Verbal
Cues to Deception, Confessions, and Lie Catchers' Accuracy" by Jordan and colleagues attempts to pinpoint the elements of coerced confessions among other aspects in subterfuge. The dilemma with this study is that all attempts to make it seem as organic and realistic as possible in order to capture genuine human responses were not well executed, such as the mock interrogation room. No parts of the study design were strong or compelling enough to elicit aspects of human behavior that could provide a consistency or organic quality of response. Furthermore, the researchers often fall into the trap of creating research designs which are too complex to provide real use.
A researcher who doesn't make the mistake of creating an overly-complex research design is Dr. Richard Wiseman. His experiments use simple, straightforward methods to attempt to find trends in human behavior and human perception of lying. For example, the BBC allowed Wiseman to conduct research on their show: he interviewed breakfast anchorman Chris Hollins about his family vacation of choice: in one segment Hollins is lying (talking about Wales); in the other segment he is telling the truth (talking about France) (BBC, 2007). Viewers were asked to vote about which answer was correct and there was generally a 50-50 split in the votes, a fact which corresponds with other consistent findings of Wiseman on lying, namely that most people are very poor...
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now