Locust Club -- "We Protect Interview

Length: 8 pages Sources: 4 Subject: Criminal Justice Type: Interview Paper: #4018697 Related Topics: Police Corruption, Negotiating, Labor Relations, Interview
Excerpt from Interview :



Theoretically speaking though, why is there a constant tension between police unions and local and state governments? Can't they all just get along? Well, to answer this question, perhaps we should briefly examine the differences between police unions in the United States and those in Canada to see if there is some underlying difference between the way the two are viewed by their respective societies. In a project commissioned by the U.S. Department of Justice entitled, "Police Labor -- Management Relations (2006, Vol 1) the issue was addressed explicitly, the project states:

Labor relations in Canada and the U.S. share a similar history and similar original legislation. So why are the bargaining regimes and outcomes so different? The one word answer is legislation. Whether public sector or private sector, the notable difference between Canadian and U.S. labor relations history is that Canadian legislators have not eroded or outright annulled the substance and spirit of our early, formative legislation that enables the organization and certification of bargaining units, recognition of unions by employers, and facilitates collective bargaining and the administration of collective agreements.

Consequently, police labor relations in Canada operate in a protected environment where neutral third-party dispute mechanisms, like binding interest arbitration, are the norm. To our advantage as well, arbiters and most employer negotiators recognize the police as unique employees in unique workplaces. Police-to-police comparison generally is the accepted standard. For the most part, this has allowed us to hold our own in comparison with self-regulating professions, with each other regionally, and for larger bargaining units nationally. Most important, this protected environment has allowed us to stay ahead of the private sector and separate ourselves from the rest of the public sector in gains in salary and benefits. Good wage and benefit packages account for the low incidence of police corruption in Canada. Being able to rely on a defined process in our legislation and maintaining a favorable image in the eyes of the public as well as the respect of most of our politicians has helped us survive, and in most workplaces avoid, poor labor-management relations. (Kilnnear, 2006, p. 27-28),

In Canada police unions are not viewed as a pernicious entity, a money-gulping indolent bureaucracy, instead it is ingrained in the social fabric that a police union is a positive influence that assiduously works -- via the cooperation of its members -- to mitigate crime. Their ways of operation, their legislation, is clearly defined and transparent. And, what is most important is the understanding by both policy makers and the police unions is that police work is fundamentally different than any other type of work in the public sector. Consequently, it should be treated differently and comparisons that juxtapose police salaries and benefits with jobs in other sectors of the workforce are inherently flawed. In the U.S. however, police unions (really unions in general), are not viewed with the same deference and respect. Unfair comparisons are drawn in an effort to bust unions.

In addition to the external pressures the Locust Club faces, there is also internal pressure(s) within the organization. For example,

...

After all, cops are people too, so there are no shortages of complaints and issues that need to be addressed and handled in a calm and efficient manner. What's important is that these issues get resolved internally so that the Locust Club maintains a unified front and a singular voice when sitting at the negotiating table.

One way the Locust Club creates a cohesive and generally frictionless working environment is through their grievance policy, which gives individual officers a forum to voice issues and concerns they are having with policies, union management, operations, chain of command, etc. The policy also encourages suggestions from officers who see ways of ameliorating the procedures and/or current policies (J. Collins, personal communication, May 13, 2011).

According to Justin, the way the policy works is officers are pre-assigned union delegates based upon which platoon they belong to (personal communication, May 13, 2011). If they have an issue or a problem they write it up and notify their union delegate. The Locus Club then decides whether the grievance is a viable compliant and whether it should be handled internally or if it should be brought up in the monthly meeting held in downtown Rochester before city officials. If the grievance is deemed worthy of presentation before city officials, then the union delegate will voice the grievance at that monthly meeting and then both the union and city officials will review the current contract and rules and decide on a proper course of action (J. Collins, personal communication, May 13, 2011).

In the majority of instances, grievances are quickly resolved and a decision is agreed upon and adjudicated. In some instances there are protracted disputes about where both sides favor a different resolution, which may eventually lead to arbitration and mediation (J. Collins, personal communication, May 13, 2011). Overall this seems to be an effective way at keeping the peace between the Locust Club and Rochester city officials.

In interviewing Justin and learning about police unions, in particularly the Locust Club and their efforts to maintain favorable relations with city management while at the same time negotiating the best labor agreement they can for their members, I was struck by a recurring theme, a simple thread that weaves its way throughout all of labor-management relations: respect. At the end of the day, labor relations is about having, earning, and keeping mutual respect for the parties involved (Kilnnear, 2006, p. 34). The challenges the Locust club is faced with are plentiful, shrinking municipal budgets, an ostensibly bloated pension and benefits program, overtime mitigation policies, protecting the sworn officers who keep the public safe, but if the Locust Club can maintain the respect of the community and city in which it serves, and those who serve in city council, then it has a real shot of ensuring the best salaries, benefits and pension programs for its members. The best way to protect the police is ensure they are treated with the respect they've earned fighting crime in the city of Rochester, NY.

Works Cited

Blair, G.G., Burgess, M., Dowling, J.L., Greenberg, S., Harrell, W., Hoover, L.T., Hunt,

T., Kilnnear, D., Polzin, M.J., Shannon, M.R. (2006). Policing And Police Labor Relations In Canada: Similarities and Contrasts with the United States of America. Police Labor-Management Relations (Vol. I): Perspectives and Practical Solutions for Implementing Change, making Reforms, and Handling Crises for Managers and Union Leaders. (27-34). Washington DC: Department of Justice.

Clottin, C. The Evolution of the Rochester Police Department Locust Club. Retrieved from www.locustclub.org/documents/locustclub_history.pdf

Kovacic, S. (2010). Badge of Honor Association. Retrieved from http://badgeofhonorassociation.com/

Mazzeo, M.…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Blair, G.G., Burgess, M., Dowling, J.L., Greenberg, S., Harrell, W., Hoover, L.T., Hunt,

T., Kilnnear, D., Polzin, M.J., Shannon, M.R. (2006). Policing And Police Labor Relations In Canada: Similarities and Contrasts with the United States of America. Police Labor-Management Relations (Vol. I): Perspectives and Practical Solutions for Implementing Change, making Reforms, and Handling Crises for Managers and Union Leaders. (27-34). Washington DC: Department of Justice.

Clottin, C. The Evolution of the Rochester Police Department Locust Club. Retrieved from www.locustclub.org/documents/locustclub_history.pdf

Kovacic, S. (2010). Badge of Honor Association. Retrieved from http://badgeofhonorassociation.com/


Cite this Document:

"Locust Club -- We Protect" (2011, May 19) Retrieved June 25, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/locust-club-we-protect-44830

"Locust Club -- We Protect" 19 May 2011. Web.25 June. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/locust-club-we-protect-44830>

"Locust Club -- We Protect", 19 May 2011, Accessed.25 June. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/locust-club-we-protect-44830

Related Documents
Collective Bargaining
Words: 1880 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Careers Paper #: 71108111

Collective Bargaining The labor laws are encouraging unionization. This is because the state Labor Relations Board determined that the RAs have a right to form / join a union and they are entitled to collective bargaining. At the same time, the university is recognizing the union as the legitimate representative for the RAs. These factors are showing how the law is encouraging everyone to unionize. This is from the state making the

Collective Bargaining
Words: 3418 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Transportation Paper #: 85028556

Collective Bargaining The bargaining environment in which Magic Carpet Airlines (MCA) found itself was a hostile one. The flight attendants' union (LFA - League of Flight Attendants) wanted much more than MCA wanted to give, but it was also clear that the LFA had legitimate concerns with the way they were treated by MCA and what they were offered financially. LFA was very committed to the idea that concessions needed to

Collective Bargaining
Words: 1139 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Sports Paper #: 70813143

Collective Bargaining MLB Collective Bargaining in the MLB Locate an article describing a collective bargaining situation that has arisen within the past two years. This article should be from a newspaper, an academic journal, or a credible online news source. Use a minimum of two additional references to support your discussion and to respond to the questions in the assignment. State the nature of the collective bargaining dispute. The next collective labor agreement in

Collective Bargaining
Words: 872 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Careers Paper #: 43702089

Collective Bargaining It is the purpose of this Agreement to promote and provide for harmonious relations, cooperation and understanding between the city of Miami, the Sheriff and the employees all stakeholders involved in law enforcement. In addition, this agreement is designed to provide an orderly and equitable means of resolving any misunderstanding or differences which may arise out of through the daily work activities of law enforcement within the city of

Collective Bargaining Agreements Refer to a Document
Words: 1182 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Careers Paper #: 83709290

Collective bargaining agreements refer to a document of agreement signed between the management of a firm and its employees prepared by representative labor union that specifies terms of employment such as duration, wages, work conditions etc. In nursing profession, CBA are not something new and while some may oppose it, most still believe that these agreements are for the benefit of nurses and hence must be signed as they offer

Collective Bargaining in Relation to
Words: 898 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Sports Paper #: 70085051

The fact that there was need for stiffened penalties shows how the players could have been using hard drugs or human growth hormones to enhance their performance. On the other hand, it seems like most of the players were being punished without substantial evidence which lay on the line their careers hence thought it best to include a neutral panel of experts to clarify matters. Resolving the dispute The dispute was however