Loss And Grief The Loss Research Proposal

Length: 11 pages Sources: 8 Subject: Psychology Type: Research Proposal Paper: #67987332 Related Topics: Grieving Process, Art Therapy, Grieving, Behavior Modification
Excerpt from Research Proposal :



Art therapy is particularly useful with younger children. With children under the age of eight it can be difficult for them to grasp the concept of death, it can be equally as difficult for them to express the things they are feeling about the loss of a loved one (Shaw, 2000). Through the medium of drawing or painting a counselor may gain a better understanding of their patient's subjective experience of the loss as well as any unresolved emotions or unanswered questions remaining after the fact. Art therapy is also an effective means of determining the relative normality of a child's cognitive function following a traumatic event (Shaw, 2000).

Older children respond more effectively to client centered interviews (Shaw, 2000). A client centered interview is a psychoanalytic approach which encourages the patient to talk extensively guided minimally by questions or suggestions from the therapist. This approach might allow through the extensive vocalization of formally internalized feelings, thoughts, and questions the root of any unresolved issues associated with the loss which may have proven detrimental to the client's successful continued psychological functioning (Shaw, 2000).

Secondary intervention techniques are more intensive as the behavioral and psychological problems associated with bereavement are apparently persisting to a degree which is disruptive to the individual's daily functioning (Gwynne, Blick, & Duffy, 2009). These techniques include weekend retreats and even the referral to group therapy session or support groups. While it is at times useful to spend a significant period of time reliving a significant life event such as the loss of a loved one, in children it may ultimately prove more harmful than helpful (Larson, & Hoyt, 2007). Perpetually reliving a traumatic event may actually reverse the process of healing and acceptance especially with younger adolescents effectively trapping them in that stressful and difficult time. The participation in group therapies and support groups allows individuals particularly adolescents to gain a sense of camaraderie which can be important in times of grief, however, these groups may act to foster malingering or even a psychological dependence on the sympathy and attention garnered at such sessions (Larson, & Hoyt, 2007).

Tertiary intervention techniques are long-term therapeutic treatment plans including behavior modification, drug regimens, and standing appointments with therapists for the treatment of pronounced disorders resulting from bereavement. It is the function of primary and secondary intervention strategies to prevent the majority of individuals in need of some bereavement intervention from reaching this final and most severe treatment stage (Burnett et al. 1997). To qualify for a tertiary intervention treatment an individual must display a pervasive and fundamentally disruptive pattern of behaviors stemming from the loss event and preventing their successful reintegration with society (Tomita, & Kitamura, 2002). In the case of children, the need for a tertiary intervention is especially concerning in that it will inevitably impact the rest of their lives.

Given the generally pessimistic review of bereavement intervention techniques shared by the majority of researchers, it would be interesting and probative to determine whether the results of these trials are replicable in the field. Rather than including all data, it would be of use to screen participants prior to the inclusion of their treatment objectives and outcomes in the raw data collected. If treatment is provided efficiently and immediately only to those individuals actually in need of counseling, it is my contention that intervention techniques would produce statistically significant results in lessening the amount of time necessary for participants to return to normal functioning following a crucial loss.

Method

Design

This study will be cross sectional. A local hospital will be chosen based on proximity to the researcher as well as their willingness to participate in the study. The grief counseling department will agree to turn over redacted records of applicable participants. No personally identifying information will be included about the participants themselves, nor will the researcher have any interaction with them. The grief counseling center will provide the participants with a copy of the Inventory of Complicated Grief before and after the therapy as well as the Core Bereavement Items measure. The inventories as well as general nature of the therapeutic intervention including; who initiated the therapy, duration of therapy, and clinicians opinion of efficacy of therapy will be turned into the researcher upon

...

All participants will receive a briefing form prior to their completion of the inventory. Participation will be entirely voluntary and informed consent will be required for their inclusion.

Sample

Ideally the sample would include an ethnically, economically, and age diverse group of participants. However, as this study utilizes convenience sampling such normative distribution is unlikely to occur naturally. As such a number of local hospitals should be included in the study. Further, only participants who score greater that 25 on the ICG and greater than 17 on the CBI. This ensures that only individuals presenting with a genuine need for therapeutic intervention will be included in the data analysis. It is important to limit the sample to those individuals genuinely in need in order to ensure that the effects observed are actually a result of therapeutic intervention.

Measures

The two measures proposed for the study are the Core Bereavement Inventory (CBI) as well as the Inventory of Complicated Grief (ICG). The CBI is a 35 item self-assessment scale which measures the subjective experience of loss. Composed of three internal subscales which assess thoughts, separation, and grief this scale is easy to administer yet highly informative in terms of assessing a full picture of the individual's relative psychological functioning. The scale has a cronbach's alpha of .85 which is a reasonable level of internal reliability. Further, this scale is attractive because it can be used with children and adolescents.

The ICG is a 19 item scale which assesses the physical components of grief and the degree to which they are disrupting an individual's life. This scale specifically measures symptoms of grief distinct from unrelated depression or anxiety. A cluster of seven symptoms assessed by this measure were indicative of long-term dysfunction. The cronbach's alpha for this scale is .94 indicating an extremely high degree of internal reliability.

The final item used in data collection is the redacted case file of the participants. Specific information regarding the nature of the loss, and personally identifying information will be removed prior to review of the data. The relevant factors are age of participant, nature of loss (general descriptor ie: mother, father, uncle), who initiated treatment, length of treatment, techniques employed, reason for terminating treatment, success of treatment. These items are non-invasive yet in combination with the pre- post test design of the study will yield information regarding the techniques which are most successful for distinct age groups.

Data Analysis

This study will employ a cross sectional pre- post test design. The relative success of each participant's intervention will be determined through the use of the two grief measures taken before and after treatment. These results will then be correlated with the various intervention techniques to determine which are on average most successful. The participants will be grouped by age and ethnicity when sufficient data is available.

Discussion

The ultimate value of this study will be in the empirical evidence supporting the inclusion or exclusion of commonly used bereavement intervention techniques. The inclusion of only those individuals in actual need of therapeutic intervention will allow researchers to assess the specific therapeutic success of techniques without interference from data sets which are inconclusive because the intervention addressed an individual coping normally with the loss. This research may also effectively rejuvenate the somewhat pessimistic view of bereavement intervention.

The primary limitations of this study will be in the acquisition of a diverse sample population. Because the study is employing a convenience sampling technique, the sample may not be representative of the community as a whole; as such this study will need to be repeated on a larger scale including more grief counseling departments and offices. The ability to get conclusive data regarding children specifically those under the age of 12 will also be difficult given the sensitive nature of the treatment and many parents and guardian's desire to shield their child from any additional trauma or stress. It should be emphasized though that the collection of this data will ultimately be no more invasive or traumatic than their participation in therapy. The potential for long-term effects of this study, or harm as a result of this study to participants is extremely low.

In future such measures of exclusion should become more stringent addressing the problem of eliminating confounding variables such as individuals who have existing mental health problems, or who are coping normally with their grief. Until data samples are collected which control for such variables, the data will be largely inconclusive.

References

1. Tomita, T., & Kitamura, T. (2002). Clinical and research measures of grief: A reconstruction. Comprehensive psychiatry, 43, 95- 102.

2. Larson, D., & Hoyt, W. (2007). What…

Sources Used in Documents:

References

1. Tomita, T., & Kitamura, T. (2002). Clinical and research measures of grief: A reconstruction. Comprehensive psychiatry, 43, 95- 102.

2. Larson, D., & Hoyt, W. (2007). What has become of grief counseling? An evaluation of the empirical foundations of the new pessimism. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 38, 347- 355.

3. Currier, J., Holland, J., & Neimeyer, R. (2007). The effectiveness of bereavement interventions with children: A meta- analytic review of controlled outcome research. Journal of clinical child and adolescent psychology, 36, 253- 259.

4. Forte, a., Hill, M., Pazder, R., & Feudtner, C. (2004). Bereavement care interventions: A systematic review. BMC Palliative Care, 1-14.


Cite this Document:

"Loss And Grief The Loss" (2010, April 18) Retrieved August 15, 2022, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/loss-and-grief-the-loss-196627

"Loss And Grief The Loss" 18 April 2010. Web.15 August. 2022. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/loss-and-grief-the-loss-196627>

"Loss And Grief The Loss", 18 April 2010, Accessed.15 August. 2022,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/loss-and-grief-the-loss-196627

Related Documents
Grief and Religion the Five Stages of
Words: 1183 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Mythology - Religion Paper #: 40218195

Grief and Religion The Five Stages of Grief and Religion In 1969, Elisabeth Kubler-Ross, a Swiss researcher, presented a list of five stages that individuals experience when dealing with death; and since then these principles have since been applied to loss and grief in general. The five stages of the Kubler-Ross model are Denial, Anger, Bargaining, Depression, and finally Acceptance; and it can be asserted that these stages are experienced in one

Grief Counseling Human Beings Need One Another
Words: 1162 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 83593672

Grief Counseling Human beings need one another in order to make things seem right and sane. Helping others in their time of need not only can help alleviate the stress from the person needing help, but also the person giving the help can also benefit greatly from this exercise. It seems that the human condition is designed to help each other. The purpose of this paper is to describe the group counseling

Grief and Mourning in Schizophrenia
Words: 1059 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 89837327

Grief Schiz Precautions and Procedures for the Prevention of Suicide and the Treatment of Depression in Recently Diagnosed Schizophrenics Any major chronic medical diagnosis can have psychological and emotional reverberations for the patient, as chronic conditions can often be perceived as a "life sentence" of sorts. The inescapability of symptoms and the long-term prognosis of many chronic disorders can cause patients to seriously question their future quality of life, the impact that

Grief Counseling
Words: 3600 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 16578028

Grief Counseling Experiencing loss can have a long-term effect on a person, especially if that loss is deeply personal, such as the loss of a loved one. Grief counseling thus exists to ease a person through the grief process, which is never the same for anyone. According to Jane V. Bissler, the stages of grief have been "borrowed" from the five stages of dying, yet these are not the same at

Grief and Loss Although Often
Words: 3594 Length: 12 Pages Topic: Death and Dying  (general) Paper #: 45876757

Yet, Kubler-Ross is not without critics, as many contend that there exists no real evidence that stages are present in coping with death (Stages pp). According to Robert Kastenbaum, using the term "stages" implies that there is a set order of set conditions, and asserts that there is no evidence that dying people go through the exact Kubler-Ross stages in their proper order (Stages pp). He believes that any patient

Grief and Loss
Words: 2086 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Psychology Paper #: 26308056

Grief and Loss: Adolescents This work intends to outline the theoretical explanations of grief, in particular Worden's tasks of grief. Further this work intends to explore the role of the nurse in the support and care of an individual who is grieving. In this instance of study the focus is a 15-year-old girl who will be called Elaine Brown. She has been tired for some time, losing weight and is constantly thirsty.