Managers As Professionals Management As Term Paper

Length: 10 pages Sources: 15 Subject: Business Type: Term Paper Paper: #36317468 Related Topics: Professionalism, Accounting Theory, Talent Management, Disaster Management
Excerpt from Term Paper :

It can be argued that from a responsibility standpoint, it is only money and can be replaced. Therefore, the risk associated with the actions of the manager do not compare with other professional fields. It would appear that licensure is not necessary, nor is a particular body of knowledge in order to become a successful manager.

Morality and Managers

We have demonstrated that managers do not have to possess a standardized set of minimal knowledge in order to perform their job well. Many examples illustrate successful entrepreneurs that do not have even the minimal knowledge base, yet they are a success by many standards. From the standpoint of the necessity of a minimal knowledge base, it would appear that managers do not qualify as professionals from a sociological perspective. However, the public and the company place an incredible amount of trust in managers to carry out their functions in a manner that serves to enhance the needs of the company, shareholders, employees, and customers (Chum, 2005). They shoulder a considerable amount of trust, for someone that may not meet the minimal requirements of the job.

The third quality of a professional is that they use their knowledge base for the public good. Let us assume that the manager has the necessary knowledge base. They must commit to operate their company in a way that accomplishes public good. When the Enron scandal broke, it became apparent the corporate and personal profits were at the top of every managerial Christmas List. Marketers padded their own pockets at the expense of everyone, including the general public (Yost, 2007). This was only one of many scandals to surface that breached public trust in corporations. There are certain corporations that do exist for the public good, but most entrepreneurs have their own interests at the top of their priority list.

Although there are many exceptions to the rule, many corporations exist solely for the profits of those in charge. The second part of criteria number three for professionals, is that they serve the public good, even at the expense of profit. This phrase creates a paradox for the business manager. To makes profits is for the general good. They do not have a service to offer, other than maintaining profit levels for the company. Taking care of the company, means taking care of profits. A business that continually loses money for the public good ceases to be a business for long. In return for committing to use that knowledge for the public good, even at the expense of profits, is exchanges for greater autonomy and monopoly. The manager must maintain profits to achieve autonomy and power. The manager cannot adhere to the fourth principle of professionalism and continue to do their job.

The fourth criteria is adherence to a code of ethics with provisions for monitoring compliance and sanctions necessary to enforce it (Khurana, Nohria, & Penrice, 2005). Scandals have placed an emphasis on this lack of ethical turpitude in the managerial profession. Currently, managers are expected to act in a manner that exemplifies a high moral standard (Chum, 2005). However, America has taken off the rose-colored glasses, and now realizes that mangers are under incredible pressure to maintain profits. The bending of rules is acceptable practice, as long as one is not caught. Corporations monitor themselves and must decide which actions they will allow, which actions are not allowed and when to look the other way. There is no standard managerial monitoring system.

When one considers the sociological theoretical model of professionals, it appears that at the current time, managers are found to be lacking in all points considered. They are not held to standards of knowledge, or morality on their jobs. Their responsibility is to maintain profits and there is no regulatory agency to make certain that they do so in a manner that benefits the general public. By this measure, one can determine that at the current time, managers are not professionals.

Should they be Professionals?

It is apparent by now, that managers are not professionals, as compared to other professional occupations such as doctors or attorneys. However, it is difficult to ignore the fact that managers are professionals in their own right. They should tremendous responsibility for the


They are accountable to their shareholders, employers, and in some cases, regulatory agencies. Regardless of managerial style, they must conform to certain unwritten standards among peers. They gain knowledge in a number of ways.

If one takes the standpoint that managers should become a professional organization, similar to other professions, some ground rules need to be established. At the current time, the rules that govern managers are an abstract set of practices. Everyone knows the procedures and practices that are a part of the managerial culture. Organizational culture dictates managerial practices, as much as managerial practices dictate organizational culture. Organizational culture is the driving force of managerial style (Rhodes & Brown, 2005).

This is one of the key elements that makes the idea of standardizing the managerial profession more difficult than any other profession. For the physician, following established rules and practices means increased patient safety. However, for the manager, following established rules and norms can mean disaster. The manager must be able to think outside the box and must be able to see and seize opportunities as they come along. Holding managers to a certain set of standard practices may serve to eliminate the creativity that is the driving force of innovation (Adams, 2005).

The role of the manager is reactionary depending on the situation. However, the role of the physician and attorney are reactionary to the situation as well. The requirements of having a minimal amount of certified knowledge does not limit their ability to react to situations as they arise. The architecture is currently in place to develop a standardized information. There are certain common elements that are a part of the typically college or certificate program. Regardless, of the business specialty, there are certain bits of key information that every business school graduate knows. This could easily be developed into a standardized set of knowledge to be tested prior to obtaining a license to practice as a business professional.

Once the test is passed, the manager would be a part of a professional organization and would be held to uphold certain ethical policies and practices. If they did not, they would lose their license to practice. In addition to a generalized standardized test, specialty tests could be developed that cover topics within specialized disciplines. For instance, there could be tests developed for retail managers, bank managers, technology managers, etc. It would be up to the particular organization as to whether they required specialty certificates of proficiency.

There are advantages and disadvantages to this type of professional licensure for managers. For the companies that hire, them it would mean that they could be assured that the managers they hired had attained at least a minimal level of competency (Boxall & Gilbert, 2007). They would have a better idea of the knowledge base that the manager possessed, as opposed to the wide range of missing knowledge that occurs when someone learns their profession through other than a standardized curriculum.

The managers would also benefit from attaining a certain level of competency in their field. They may gain knowledge that would help them to avoid common mistakes in their practice. Requiring a certain level of competency, by way of an exam means that they can assure at least a minimal amount of professionalism to the workforce. Even for those that have attained their fortunes without a college degree, gaining knowledge can only make them better than they are already.

Providing a means to make certain managers adhere to a generally accepted code of ethics will not prevent all unscrupulous activities for those that are determined to break the rules. However, it would place a certain threat above their heads that could serve as a deterrent against poor business practices (Edwards, 2005). The educational, exam, and licensing practices associated with the establishment of professional managerial organizations would add an extra expense burden to future managerial candidates. Managers are gauged by both financial and non-financial measures (Hogue & James, 2000). There is concern that a standardized test would only cover financial measures.

However, this may also help to deter those who are not dedicated to serving their corporations in the best possible fashion (Edwards, 2005). It could help to weed out the bad managers, as they would not be willing to pay the extra fees. The fees would serve as a test of dedication to the field and the desire to become the best manager possible. One of the key disadvantages is that this program may be inaccessible to small to medium sized managers due to the expense (Sunder, 2000). Small and medium enterprises are much more sensitive to managerial actions than larger corporations with a well-developed infrastructure of…

Sources Used in Documents:


Adams, R., 2005. Innovation management measurement: A

International Journal of Management Reviews, Vol. 8, Issue 1, pp. 21-47.

All Star Directories, Inc. 2008, AACSB Accredited. [Online] Available at

Boxall, P. & Gilbert, J., 2007, the management of managers: A review and conceptual framework. International Journal of Management Reviews, Vol. 9, Issue 2, pp. 95-115.

Cite this Document:

"Managers As Professionals Management As" (2008, January 09) Retrieved August 4, 2021, from

"Managers As Professionals Management As" 09 January 2008. Web.4 August. 2021. <>

"Managers As Professionals Management As", 09 January 2008, Accessed.4 August. 2021,

Related Documents
Managing IT Professionals Managing Creative,
Words: 330 Length: 1 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 60475566

The best place to start, then, is with the creative, skilled professionals, who many need this sort of environment. In addition, it will be important to manage the relationship between creative, skilled professionals and other workers, as it may seem that these workers are being extended privileges that do not apply to other workers. In addition, managing creative, skilled professionals may pose problems as they may see their work as

Nurse Case Manager: Case Management in the
Words: 952 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Healthcare Paper #: 84835461

Nurse Case Manager: Case management in the nursing field is basically described as the functions and activities carried out by the nurse case manager within a specific care setting. In some cases, these functions and activities are usually performed by a self-governing practitioner, especially in private case management practices and community nursing facilities (Cohen & Cesta, 2005, p.278). Generally case management responsibilities are provided by the nurse case manager in acute

IT Professionals Managing and Motivating
Words: 909 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Careers Paper #: 33159885

3). Thus, one of the ways to meet the unique challenges posed by IT professionals is to encourage them to develop their contributions to a field they love while also allowing them to advance appropriately. By encouraging these professionals to operate independently, they are prepared to contribute to the company most efficiently through their innovative and solo work. This helps managers deal with the unique role that IT professionals

Management As a Profession According to the
Words: 2183 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 49560366

Management as a Profession According to the Merriam Webster dictionary, a Profession is: a. A calling requiring specialized knowledge and often long and intensive academic preparation b. A principal calling, vocation, or employment and c. The whole body of persons engaged in a calling. Increasingly management as a class of employment has come to be seen as a profession which qualifies on all three levels of this definition. Though there are

Management Theories and Philosophies Royalco
Words: 4436 Length: 16 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 84562196

Individuals work half a day, or weekly based on the sharing arrangements. Split and sharing of the jobs leads to the organizations benefit, as talented individuals who are unable to work on a fulltime basis get an employment chance. Although adjustment problems occur, the arrangement of a proper schedule is required. III. Telecommuting also known as the flexiplace, is a working condition that allows the least portion of the scheduled

Managing and Motivating Technical Professionals
Words: 930 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 89945128

Giving them the opportunity to participate in the product launch decisions from a marketing standpoint also highlighted an embarrassing point for marketing, and that was engineering often understood the competition and its true functionality better than anyone in marketing. The reason is that the engineers had taken great pride in working on their product features they were responsible for to make them the best in the industry, and it