Military Draft Term Paper

Length: 3 pages Sources: 1+ Subject: Military Type: Term Paper Paper: #44145907 Related Topics: Military, Military History, Homeless Youth, Gps
Excerpt from Term Paper :

Military Draft

In arguing against reinstating the military draft in the United States, several things come immediately to mind. First among those, for anyone who has learned anything at all about the Vietnam War, is that the draft can be devastating to society, causing upheaval at home as well as the return of bright, strong young men in body bags. David Halberstam, a journalist of considerable experience, wrote a book, The Best and the Brightest, about the sacrifice of these young Americans for precious little, if any, gain to this country or any other.

Moreover, that war lasted for years, ending in horrific scenes of people running through the streets of Saigon trying to leave any way they could. In the end, there was a Communist takeover despite the loss of all those young Americans.

In an article called "Thinking About the Draft," William Galston wrote:

In the wake of September 11, the United States has undertaken a range of new and expanded military commitments, especially in Central Asia and the Middle East. The military occupation of Iraq is likely to last longer, and require larger forces, than civilian leaders in the Department of Defense had predicted prior to the war."

In short, Iraq appears to be going the way of the Vietnam effort; it would be senseless to draft young Americans for a repeat of the Asian mess two generations later. An apt current phrase to apply would be "different day, same old stuff."

Galston makes the point, also, that the Vietnam era draft was "widely regarded as arbitrary and unfair, and it was held responsible for dissention within the military as well as the wider society."

Allied to the problem of the draft in terms of societal upheaval in the current time period it its effect on the next generation. The generation that was drafted to fight in Vietnam was the Baby Boom generation, the largest in


It is possible to believe, in fact, that the war was welcomed as a way to thin out the ranks of that enormous, resource-using generation. The current generation of young men and women is not nearly so large, and there is already information daily in the media that soon there will be insufficient workers to fill jobs. Those facts may be part of the reason the push to reinstate the draft has been so stealthily managed by the current administration. If the generation in question -- and their parents -- were fully aware of the progress already made toward draft reinstatement, perhaps those groups would take more significant action to prevent it.

Before the 2004 election, there was draft legislation pending in the House (HR 163) and the Senate (S 89), that got almost no "mainstream media but (was) getting some discussion on the Internet."

The Internet is where many young men and women, arguably, turn for information regarding issues of importance to them. However, it is unlikely they would have found the trails to the stealthy operations of the military hierarchy itself. While politicians were working in public to gain passage of the two bills, Swomley thinks even before the election, the Pentagon had "begun a quiet campaign to fill all 10,350 draft board positions as well as similar positions on 11,070 appeals boards. This all seems to have had its origin in a February 11, 2003 ...."

The question might be asked: What is it reasonable to conclude from this? It is reasonable to conclude that the Bush administration belatedly realized it needed warm bodies to operate the high-tech machinery in Iraq, when sandstorms…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Galston, William A. 2004. Thinking about the Draft. Public Interest, Wntr, 6ff.

Swomley, John. 2004. The Return of the Draft? The Humanist, July/August, 14ff.

Galston, W.A. 2004. Thinking about the Draft. Public Interest, Wntr, 61ff.


Cite this Document:

"Military Draft" (2005, March 23) Retrieved May 11, 2021, from

"Military Draft" 23 March 2005. Web.11 May. 2021. <>

"Military Draft", 23 March 2005, Accessed.11 May. 2021,

Related Documents
Draft Vietnam War
Words: 692 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Military Paper #: 61082872

Military draft during the Vietnam War [...] how the military draft was a major issue that divided millions of American young men, and explain this dilemma and how it affected the Vietnam Conflict. The draft lottery, implemented in 1970, was contentious because not everyone agreed the United States should be fighting in Vietnam, and many young men simply refused to serve in the military in war they thought was

Military Retirees Are Entitled to
Words: 12717 Length: 46 Pages Topic: Military Paper #: 18599361

First of all only a scant few of these Veterans groups will acknowledge the "promise" of free health care; for the most part these groups will tout the benefits already promised by the Veterans Administration and assert that cuts in these benefits are the same a broken promise-or contractual breach in legal terms. The idea of the United States military making a "promise" or forging a legally binding agreement between

Military Education Sams Monograph Prospectus Field of
Words: 1564 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Military Paper #: 60847945

Military Education SAMS MONOGRAPH PROSPECTUS FIELD OF STUDY The field of study will be a combination of history and operational art. The proposed topic is professional military education at the field-grade level during periods of peace. The training and actions after Armistice and after World War II will serve as case studies to help understand the topic at a deeper level. After twelve years of conflict and two wars, what reasonable quality of training

Military As a Job in
Words: 1417 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Military Paper #: 33008890

Several of them indicated that in today's hot economy, a college graduate could earn a lot of money. Several of them had anecdotes of college graduates whose entry pay was significantly higher than the entry pay and bonuses being offered in the survey" (p. 109). This study also found that all of the high school seniors surveyed "had a negative view of the military as a job or career

Military Homosexuals in the Military
Words: 1820 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Military Paper #: 79554487

However the survey is also likely to expose disputes that the services could face in getting rid of the policy, including defeating severe resistance in some divisions of the military even if they symbolize a minority (Gays in the Military Study: Most U.S. Troops, Families Say Gays OK, 2010). Earlier this year, the Pentagon was required to get rid of its prohibition on openly serving gays for eight days after

Military Conscription Reforms in Turkey:
Words: 2404 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Military Paper #: 71375018

The need for reforms to the conscription process is a way for the government to maintain an effect outlet for the Turkish society to reaffirm its loyalty and respect for the army. This profound and traditional respect for the army has been waning following the high number of military casualties leading to a decline of celebrations held as new recruits' board buses for training (Kuru and Stepan 130). The gathering