Participation In Complex Governance Legitimacy Article Review

Length: 8 pages Sources: 20 Subject: Government Type: Article Review Paper: #49692988 Related Topics: Public Safety, Public Administration, Recruitment Selection, Interest Groups

Excerpt from Article Review :

Creating a common understanding of the problem enables participants and policy makers to develop a representative problem definition and thus move into the criteria identification phase of the policy development process. A representative problem definition "narrows the context within which alternative solutions will be generated and evaluated" (p. 353). This narrowing is important because without it, the rest of the policy development process will lack the focus necessary to reach a solution.

The authors' table shows that, during the alternative generation phase, the purposes Discover, Educate, and Legitimize are used. Discovery, in this phase, is used to develop solutions. The public is educated, in this phase, on the issue, about the possible alternatives, and what might happen if no action were taken. Legitimization is necessary for this phase in the process in order for the public to accept the outcome.

The table shows that during the evaluation of alternatives, the purposes Educate, Measure, and Legitimized are used. The public can be educated during this phase on the consequences of different alternatives. Measuring the public's opinion is useful during this phase to determine the political feasibility of any particular alternative.

During the final phase -- alternative recommendation -- the table shows that the purposes Educate, Persuade, and Legitimize are used. Persuasion is an important purpose in this phase to build public support. Education is an important purpose in this phase if the issue is a low conflict one, and the public wasn't included earlier in the process. Legitimization can also be gained in this phase, if it is a low conflict issue.

The nature of the issue under consideration is the second dimension in designing public participation in policy development. The desirability of citizen involvement and which participation mechanisms are appropriate vary with different issues.

Walters et al. identify six issue characteristics that affect the success of public participation: the degree of conflict, the number of stakeholders, the level of confidence in information about the issue, the amount of alternatives, the knowledge of outcomes, and the probability of the outcomes.

High conflict issues necessitate early citizen participation to develop consensus and legitimacy, as well as methods that emphasize compromise. The number of stakeholders necessitates varying actions as well. When stakeholders are organized into a few groups, communication can be made via group leaders. If stakeholders are poorly organized, participation should deal directly with the stakeholders through, for example, the media or town meetings.


Low confidence on issues can be the result of unavailable data, unreliable sources, or outdated or missing information. In this case, administrators should determine the availability of any data that might increase confidence. If there is still a lack of confidence in information, an explanation of limitations on available information, and the impact of such limitations, should be provided to participants.

If participants come to doubt the reliability of the information, consensus building can be difficult. Administrators should search for corroborating sources and efforts should then be made to convince group leaders of the reliability of information. When group leaders become convinced of the information, this spreads to those in their groups, as those in their groups tend to trust their leaders as reliable sources of information.

Complicating the matter, a lack of confidence in information shrinks the number of policy options that stakeholders will consider. In this case, an educational process should be pursued for the diminished number of policy options thus afforded. Lack of confidence in information surrounding an issue may also occur simply because the information is highly technical. In this case, publications can also explain technical complexities to stakeholders.

When there are a large amount of policy alternatives, achieving consensus around any one alternative becomes less likely. Further, identifying each alternative can become marginal, resulting in an "unending" spiral of public involvement as "more and more alternatives are introduced" (p. 355). In this situation, efforts should be made both in making each alternative as concrete as possible and in building consensus.

Knowledge of the effects of each alternative can also complicate policy problems. If knowledge of the alternatives are known fairly well, "education, measurement, and persuasion efforts can focus on the benefits and risks of the various alternatives" (p. 355). If knowledge of the alternatives is unknown or uncertain, participation should be focused on minimizing the worst outcomes or incremental improvement. Moreover, in the case that the effects of alternatives are uncertain, decisions tend to be based more on principle or value.

When the probability of outcomes is uncertain, focus groups, working task forces, or town meetings with a focus on education should be pursued.


Bardach, Eugene. (1996). The Eight-Step Path of Policy Analysis: A Handbook for Practice.

Berkeley, CA: Berkeley Academic Press.

Creighton, James L. (1981). The Public Involvement Manual. Cambridge, MA: Abt Books.

Dunn, William N. (1994). Public Policy Analysis: An Introduction. 2d ed. Englewood Cliffs,

N.J.: Prentice-Hall, Inc.

Fung, Archon. (2006). Varieties of Participation in Complex Governance. Public Administration

Review, December 2006 66-75.

Kweit, Mary Grisez, and Robert W. Kweit. (1981). Implementing Public Participation in a Bureaucratic Society. New York: Praeger.

McRae, Duncan, Jr., and Dale Whittington. (1997). Expert Advice for Policy Choice: Analysis

and Discourse. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press.

Patton, Carl V., and David S. Sawicki. (1993). Basic Methods of Policy Analysis and Planning.

2d ed. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.

Rosener, Judy B. (1975). A Cafeteria…

Sources Used in Documents:


Bardach, Eugene. (1996). The Eight-Step Path of Policy Analysis: A Handbook for Practice.

Berkeley, CA: Berkeley Academic Press.

Creighton, James L. (1981). The Public Involvement Manual. Cambridge, MA: Abt Books.

Dunn, William N. (1994). Public Policy Analysis: An Introduction. 2d ed. Englewood Cliffs,

Cite this Document:

"Participation In Complex Governance Legitimacy" (2010, April 29) Retrieved March 24, 2023, from

"Participation In Complex Governance Legitimacy" 29 April 2010. Web.24 March. 2023. <>

"Participation In Complex Governance Legitimacy", 29 April 2010, Accessed.24 March. 2023,

Related Documents
International Developments in Corporate Governance
Words: 8350 Length: 30 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 54002787

For example, Shu-Acquaye (2007) cites the basic differences in the legal systems in various parts of the world as contributing to the different approaches to corporate governance. Likewise, Shu-Acquaye cites these differences and adds, "The American corporate governance system adheres to the idea of shareholder primacy. Because the United Kingdom, Austria, and Canada share a legal system based on English common law and equity principles, they are similar to

Organizational Accountability Review of Taiwan's Disaster Management...
Words: 5800 Length: 20 Pages Topic: Government Paper #: 99826794

Organizational Accountability Review of Taiwan's Disaster Management Activities In Response To Typhoon Morakot Taiwanese System of Government 174 Responsibility of Emergency Management in Taiwan 175 Disasters in Taiwan 175 Citizen Participation 189 Shafritz defines citizen participation as follows: 192 Public Managers, Citizen Participation, and Decision Making 192 The Importance of Citizen Participation 197 Models of Citizen Participation 199 Citizen Participation Dilemmas 205 Accountability 207 Definitions of Accountability 207 The Meaning of Accountability 208 The Functions of Accountability 213 Citizen Participation and Accountability 216 Accountability Overloads

Is the European Union a State or What Else Distinguishes It From...
Words: 9068 Length: 22 Pages Topic: Government Paper #: 99365197

European Union a state, or what else distinguishes it from other International Organizations The primary question concerning global organizations as a medium of global governance relates towards the quantity and excellence of this governance within an era where we now have an overdeveloped global economy as well as an under-developed global polity (Ougaard and Higgott, 2002). There's a powerful disconnect amid governance, being an efficient and effective collective solution-seeking process

New Public Management Reforms the
Words: 4090 Length: 14 Pages Topic: Government Paper #: 65984502

Indeed, the reference to "institutional sclerosis" concerns the fact that virtually every conceivable interest in contemporary society is protected by a variety of laws that provide for extensive advising, participation and appeal procedures, a process that further exacerbates the inability of public administrators to remain responsive to their constituents (Klijn & Koppenjan 241). These authors emphasize that, "This results, among other things, in the Not In My Backyard (NIMBY)

A Concise Analysis of Financial Performance of Companies
Words: 6238 Length: 17 Pages Topic: Finance Paper #: 65988591

environmental, social and governance (ESG) performance and financial performance of companies Investors are increasingly recognizing the fact that ESG (environmental, social, corporate governance) elements can substantially affect companies' security rates and financial performance. The aforementioned components' contribution to financial markets has been growing with the rise in number of ESG opportunities and risks within the contemporary international economy. Timely and improved organizational policy-related data access and the effect of organizational

Social Equity Leadership Conference
Words: 5893 Length: 20 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 74643599

Social equity is a key issue of public administration and forms the basic theme of the 2013 "Social Equity Leadership Conference," in June. This white paper discusses the key goals of the conference based on the conference issue for social equity as global engagement and local responsibility. These are the issue facing social equity among domestic and global public leaders in public and private agencies in the education, immigration,