Prison The Modern Prison System Represents A Essay

PAGES
4
WORDS
1303
Cite

Prison The modern prison system represents a macrocosmic understanding of how to punish the collective sins of society. Within any environment, the strength of its contents is a direct reflection on the worst of its contents as well. The importance of the cathartic rehabilitation that occurs during learning, growth, understanding and forgiveness dictates how one would be rehabilitated in any system, prison or not. The sheer numbers of prisoners within the United States represents a concept of punishment that appears to exceed rational thought and reasoning. Are our citizens that troubled? Do we really need such an extensive prison system that is lost in bureaucratic inefficiency and sadistic behavior? The purpose of this essay is to examine these questions in an attempt to compare and contrast the present penal and prison systems and whether these methods are striving towards any type of collective goals. Furthermore these goals themselves will be analyzed to determine whether or not incarceration and punishment is philosophically aligned with today's general mind frame.

Any collective group must decide where it's authoritative power is located. Humanity's subjugation to law must be examined before understanding how a group can determine what is punishable and what is allowable. Law was most likely not designed for man to be subjugated to or under, however laws can be used as a tool for mankind. When these tools are misused or abused, unsatisfactory results will no doubt arise. Foucault (1971) supported this idea of relative justice and equity. Through his concept of power developed through knowledge, a successful philosophical standpoint may be derived from this idea of individual application to each law. Discipline, essential in the development of his theory, is explained as a tool for this type of management.

Anderson (2000) explained a consequence of ignoring the essence of law as private prisons have exploded as an economic force to maintain and feed certain sect of society. Privatization of a social responsibility demonstrates resistance...

...

Throwing money at a problem, while it may temporarily appear to be helpful, usually masks symptoms of the problem while not treating the root issue. Concepts of good and bad and how the relative application of moral ethics seem to be of more importance in determining solutions to these types of problems. Anderson agreed with this concept: "increasingly, the prison system has become our response to the societal and economic problems of poor people, especially in minority communities. But this sort of response does not look beyond incarceration as an answer. Far better, he emphasized, would be a response focused on making investments that strengthen families and communities."
Harmony and balance are jeopardized when the economic strength of a community is based upon the amount of criminals contained in its local private prison. There is no economic justification for lowering recidivism rates in this prison. In fact the opposite is true. The more crime will bring about more prisoners. More prisoners will bring more capital and more jobs to the community. Police forces and local statutes and regulations will no doubt intensify if economic interests are placed before more important ideas. The idea of fairness and justice must be presented in a way that can be upheld by the leadership in society. No one should expect the criminal to behave in a way opposite from its role models and leadership. When these role models and leadership ideas falter and become obsolete or harmful in any way, it is up for those who can recognize this to alert others in correcting this untruth.

Sykes (1971) described a bleak picture for prisoners in today's modern correctional institutions. Depriving conditions, Sikes explained, highlight how a person within a correctional institution is slowly but surely deprived of his or her humanity. Losing freedom, autonomy and the ability to coexist with others in peace plays a serious role in hindering growth and potential understanding. In some…

Sources Used in Documents:

Bibliography

Anderson, G. (2000). " Prisons for profit." America The National Catholic Weekly, 18 Nov, 2000. Retrieved from http://www.americamagazine.org/content/article.cfm?article_id=2321

Foucault, M (1977). Discipline and Punish. New York: Routledge.

Sykes, C. (1971). "The pains of imprisonment." The society of Captives, a Study of a Maximum Security Prison. Princeton University Press.

Zimbardo, P., Haney, C., Banks, C. (1973)."Interpersonal dynamics in a simulated prison." International Journal of Criminology and Penology, 1, 69-97.


Cite this Document:

"Prison The Modern Prison System Represents A" (2011, July 22) Retrieved April 18, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/prison-the-modern-prison-system-represents-85384

"Prison The Modern Prison System Represents A" 22 July 2011. Web.18 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/prison-the-modern-prison-system-represents-85384>

"Prison The Modern Prison System Represents A", 22 July 2011, Accessed.18 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/prison-the-modern-prison-system-represents-85384

Related Documents

Prison Funding Finding Funds for Fighting Crime: Financial Contingency planning for California's Prison System Prisons have always been a controversial aspect of society, and far more so in the modern era of sociological and psychological inquiry into the nature of crime, punishment, and rehabilitation. Deciding precisely what function prisons are meant to serve and how they should go about serving it has been the cause of a great deal of social and

Prisons For all intents and purposes the modern history of penology -- which is to say, the science and the theory of imprisonment and the state apparatus of the penitentiary -- begins with the late 18th century British philosopher Jeremy Bentham. In Bentham's day (corresponding roughly to the time of the American and French Revolutions) there was no idea of a penitentiary per se: there was instead His Majesty's Penal Colony

Prisons An analysis of the purposes for prisons in the U.S. justice system. The corrections system in America has historically fluctuated between being dedicated to incapacitation, rehabilitation, and to being punitive in nature. They can serve all three of these functions at the same time. Current trends in criminal justice remain focused on punitive justice that fosters prison environments lacking rehabilitative services, but recent scholarship and public policy have indicated a slight

Prisons in Modern Turkey
PAGES 13 WORDS 4177

Initiated in october 2000 by around 800 detainees, leftwingers and political activists (Carrol, 2001), who were later followed by members of their families as well as human rights militants, the hunger strike changed into a huge protest movement. This was brutally supressed by the police and the miltary in December, when the operation "Back to Life" was launched. This operation was met with resistance from the prisoners and had

Prison Reform
PAGES 7 WORDS 1784

Prison Reform The United States criminal justice system houses the largest prison population in the world; both in terms of the total prison population as well as the proportion of prisoners to the total population (per capita). The United States has a bigger prison population than China and India despite having nowhere near the total population. It also holds a greater percentage of its population in incarceration than any other country

Although prisoner rape is violative of international, U.S., and state laws, the historic response to prisoner rape has been inadequate and indifferent. According to Jenness and Smythe, it was the specific intent of the PREA to address these issues. As Jenness and Smyth point out, "Current institutional policies regarding sexual violence are in need of reform and greater enforcement. The Prison Rape Elimination Act creates important incentives and standards,